Rate all of their albums

Please Please Me-8
With The Beatles-7
A Hard Day's Night-8
For Sale-6
Help!-8
Rubber Soul-9
Revolver-10
Pepper-10
White Album-8
Abbey Road-10
Let it Be-7

 

The Beatles

Please Please Me 5.5
With the Beatles 6.0
A Hard Day's Night 6.5
Beatles For Sale 6.0
Help ! 7.0
Rubber Soul 7.5
Revolver 9.5
Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band 9.0
The Beatles 8.0
Yellow Submarine 5.5
Abbey Road 9.5
Let it Be 7.5

 

Suprised you rate the second album so high.


Mine:

In The City - 7
This Is The Modern World - 6
All Mod Cons - 9.5
Setting Sons - 9.5
Sound Effects - 9.5
The Gift - 8

 

In that spirit:

David & David - 10.0


.

 

Roxy Music-9.5
For Your Pleasure-10
Stranded-10
Country Life-9
Siren-8
Manifesto-7
Flesh and Blood-6
Avalon-7

 

Alice Cooper ... Scale 1-11 ... with 1 meaning I will never listen to this again and 11 being a mind blowing aural orgasm.

Pretties For You - 3 ... weird experimental at times Beatle-esque meandering
Easy Action - 6 ... the snarl appears in a formative stage
Love It To Death - 9 ... with the addition of Mr. Ezrin it all coalesced into this magnificent melange
Killer - 10 ... like a knife to the throat, pure brilliance
School's Out - 8 ... showtunes from malcontents
Billion Dollar Babies - 9 ... a sugar sweet balance between decadence and the radio
Muscle Of Love - 8 ... a loose collection of great stories which is just shy of greatness
Welcome To My Nightmare - 9 ... on with the show ALL the way, everything but the kitchen sink
Alice Cooper Goes To Hell - 8 ... part 2 of the kitchen sink, falling a little lower on the ladder
Lace And Whiskey - 6 ... a whiskey distorted vision with some glitter underneath
From The Inside - 9 ... eloquent tales from the quiet room
Flush The Fashion - 8 ... the original punk kicks his way into a new genre
Special Forces - 11 ... the Green Berets on mascara, a twisted masterpiece
Zipper Catches Skin - 9 ... tongue firmly in cheek and manhood in zipper
DaDa - 9 ... what happens when the Ghoul finds his own darkness?
Constrictor - 6 ... muscular yet lyrically slight dive into molten metal
Raise Your Fist And Yell - 9 ... a blistering B horror flick
Trash - 5 ... dumbed down hairspray
Hey Stoopid - 9 ... intelligent well played and written bouffant
The Last Temptation - 9 ... the showman expounds upon good vs. evil
Brutal Planet - 10 ... the master flays open the festering wounds of this world
Dragontown - 7 ... attempt to excavate the same graves with mixed results
The Eyes Of Alice Cooper - 8 ... reopening of a dusty but rocking garage
Dirty Diamonds - 9 ... the garage is clean and open for business!
Along Came A Spider - 7 ... reciting a killer tale that falls shy of the mark
Welcome 2 My Nightmare - 9 ... pieces from 100 different puzzles that form a new and beautiful picture

 

Keane

Hopes and Fears - 9.5
Under The Iron Sea - 6.5
Perfect Symmetry - 7.5
Strangeland - 7

 

Please Please Me 8
With the Beatles 8
A Hard Day's Night 10
Beatles For Sale 8
Help ! 9
Rubber Soul 10
Revolver 10
Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band 10
Magical Mystery Tour 10
The Beatles 10
Yellow Submarine 5
Abbey Road 10
Let it Be 9

The Rolling Stones 7
Rolling Stones #2 7
Out of Our Heads 7
Aftermath 9
Between the Buttons 8
Their Satanic Majesties Request 7
Beggars Banquet 9
Let it Bleed 10
Get Your Ya-Yas Out 8
Sticky Fingers 10
Exile on Main St. 10
Goats Head Soup 6
It's Only Rock 'n Roll 7
Black and Blue 6
Love You Live 5
Some Girls 8
Emotional Rescue 5
Tattoo You 8
Undercover of the Night 5
Dirty Work 5
Steel Wheels 6

 

Around The Sun?

 

Slightly different (but not too) take (from Mylene's) on Scott Walker.

Scott Walker

Take it Easy - 6
Portrait -6
Images -8
Scott -8
Scott 2 -8
Scott 3 -9
Sings Songs From His TV Show -4
Scott 4 - 10
Till the Band Comes In - 8
Any Day Now - 4
The Moviegoer - 5
We Had it All - 3
Stretch - 3
No Regrets -6
Lines -7
Night Flights - 8
Climate of Hunter - 7
Tilt - 10
Pola X - 7
The Drift - 9
And Who Shall Go To The Ball.... - 7 (more an EP than album)
Bish Bosch - 9

 

Bob Dylan 6
The Freewheelin' Bob Dylan 9
The Times They Are A-Changin' 8
Another Side of Bob Dylan 8
Bringing It All Back Home 10
Highway 61 Revisited 10
Blonde on Blonde 10
The Basement Tapes (not released until 1975) 10
John Wesley Hardin 8
Nashville Skyline 8
Self Portrait 5
New Morning 7
Bob Dylan's Greatest Hits Vol II (included because of the new tracks) 10
Pat Garrett and Billy the Kid 5
Dylan 4
Planet Waves 7
Before the Flood 7
Blood on the Tracks 10
Desire 9
Hard Rain 6
Street Legal 6
Slow Train Coming 7


The Doors 10
Strange Days 9
Waiting for the Sun 8
The Soft Parade 6
Morrison Hotel 8
Absolutely Live 7
LA Woman 8

 

KISS - 8
Hotter Than Hell - 10
Dressed To Kill - 6
Destroyer - 9
Rock N Roll Over - 10
Love Gun - 7
Dynasty - 6
Unmasked - 7
(Music from) The Elder - 7
Creatures of the Night - 9
Lick It Up - 10
Animalize - 7
Asylum - 10
Crazy Nights - 5
Hot In The Shade - 8
Revenge - 9
Carnival of Souls: The Final Sessions - 9
Psycho Circus - 5
Sonic Boom - 7
Monster - 7

 

My Generation 8
A Quick One 7
Who Sell Out 9
Tommy 10
Live at Leeds 9
Who's Next 10
Meaty Beaty Big & Bouncy 10
Quadrophenia 8
Odds & Sods 6
Who by Numbers 6
Who are You 6
The Kids are All Right 7
Face Dances 4
It's Hard 4
The Kinks 4
Kinda Kinks 5
Kinks Kontroversy 6
Face to Face 9
Something Else 9
Live at Kelvin Hall 4
Kinks are the Village Green Preservation Society 10
Arthur 9
Lola vs Powerman & The Moneygoround 8
Muswell Hillbillies 8
Kink Kronikles 9
Everybody's in Show-biz 7
Great Lost Kinks Album 8
Preservation 4
Preservation Act II 4
Soap Opera 4
Schoolboys in Disgrace 4
Sleepwalker 5
Misfits 5
Low Budget 6
One From the Road 6
Give the People What They Want 7
State of Confusion 6
Word of Mouth 5

 

I love this forum, but confusing. Wilco? PJ Harvey? So new to me.

Here are two I can rate

I - 10
II - 10
III - 10
IV - 10
Houses of the Holy - 10
Physical Graffiti-10
Presence - 9
In through the Out Door - 8
Coda - 7

Please Please Me - 10
With The Beatles - 10
A Hard Day's Night - 9
Beatles For Sale - 9
Help! - 9
Rubber Soul - 10
Revolver - 10
Sgt. Pepper - 10
Magical Mystery - 8
The White Album - 10
Yellow Submarine - 7
Abbey Road - 10
Let it Be - 8


JP

 

I don't agree with all of these, but your comments get a 10!

 

The Smiths - 7.5
Hatful of Hollow - 9.5
Meat is Murder - 7.5
The Queen is Dead - 9
Louder than Bombs - 9.5
The World Won't Listen - 9
Strangeways, Here We Come - 8.5
Rank - 6.5

 

Robert Wyatt

End Of An Ear - 7
Rock Bottom - 10
Ruth Is Stranger Than Richard - 9
Nothing Can Stop Us - 8
Animals Film (EP) - 6
Old Rottenhat - 8
Dondestan - 7
Shleep - 9
Cuckooland - 8
Comicopera - 10
For The Ghosts Within - 8

I left out most compilations but Nothing Can Stop Us a collection of singles released from 1982-1984 documents a concentrated period seems integral to his output and hangs together as an album. And it was the only way to get these recordings other than the singles. Flotsam and Jetsam (an excellent comp) is more wide-ranging collection of recordings and not as much a document of a period. Also left off the 1974 Drury Lane Recording. Didn't seem to belong. Maybe I'm forgetting something else?

 

Led Zeppelin:

I - 8.3
II - 8.5
III - 8.0
IV - 7.5
HOTH (haven't heard it in a long time though) - 7.8
PG - 8.3
P - 6.9 (half a great album)
TSRTS - 8.4
ITTOD - 7.2 (would be much higher on it's own though)
C - 6.6
BBC - 8.2
HTWWW - 9.4
LZDVD - 8.9
CD - 7.9

 

R.E.M.
Chronic Town EP - 7.5
Murmur - 6.5
Reckoning - 6.5
Fables Of The Reconstruction - 8
Life's Rich Pageant - 10
Document - 8.5
Green - 7
Out Of Time - 8.5
Automatic For The People - 9.5
Monster - 8
New Adventures In Hi-Fi - 7
Up - 7.5
Reveal - 8
Around the Sun - 2
Accelerate - 7.5
Collapse Into Now - 8

 

Pozar on the sacred

Please Please Me - 7
With The Beatles - 7
A Hard Day's Night - 8
For Sale - 6
Help! - 8
Rubber Soul - 9
Revolver -10
Pepper - 9
White Album - 9
Yellow Submarine - 7
Abbey Road - 10
Let it Be - 8

 

Led Zeppelin 9
Led Zeppelin II 10
Led Zeppelin III 8
Led Zeppelin IV 10
Houses of the Holy 9
Physical Grafitti 8
Presence 6
The Song Remains the Same 6
In Through the Out Door 6
Coda 5

Black Sabbath 8
Paranoid 10
Masters of Reality 7
Vol 4 7
Sabbath Bloody Sabath 7
Sabotage 7
Technical Ecstasy 5
Never Say Die 4
Heaven and Hell 7
Mob Rules 6
Born Again 4

 

The Beatles:

Please Please Me - 7 (not a bad debut, but does not really represent the Beatles sound)
With The Beatles - 8.5 (here you can finally hear the full Beatles sound, on Please Please Me there were too many filler tracks)
A Hard Day's Night - 7.9 (way too many fillers)
Beatles For Sale - 8.9 (one of their most consistent albums, even like Mr.Moonlight)
Help! - 8.5 (a few tracks i don't really care about, but overall great)
Rubber Soul - 8.9 (1 point lost for What Goes On, otherwise one of their most consistent albums)
Revolver - 9.5 (a true masterpiece, better than Sgt. Pepper)
Sgt.Pepper - 9.3 (overrated, but great)
Magical Mystery Tour - 9.5 (i know it's yet another Capitol concoction, but it actually makes for a coherent album and is now the canon release)
The White Album - 8.9 (over-ambitious, several points lost for the filler tracks)
Yellow Submarine - 4.9 (side 1 is great but repeats tracks from previous albums)
Abbey Road - 9.9 (Not a single bad song but 0.1 points lost for Her Majesty ruining a perfect ending)
Let It Be - 6.5 (great material but horrible performances that do not do them justice. And of course the infamous "wall of sound")

 

Someday, someone will explain this to me.

 

different tastes. That explains it, i think.

 

Saint Etienne (skipping all the b-side collections, fan club releases, etc.)
Foxbase Alpha - 9
So Tough - 9.5
Tiger Bay - 8
Good Humor - 10
Places to Visit e.p. - 4
Sound of Water - 8.5
Finisterre - 8.5
Tales From Turnpike House - 10
Words and Music by Saint Etienne - 8