Discussion in 'Music Corner' started by Mother, Oct 12, 2017.
Mick is the only one on that list I ever met and he called me an a**hole. Had to pick him!
Ronson. He's the "best fit", and also did a bunch of other things for Bowie's music like arrangements and strings. Very talented guy he was.
I concur. Fripp is mindblowing on Scary Monsters
Michael Picasso for me too...
He is stellar on STATIONTOSTATION
That would make Earl Slick otherworldly
Robert Fripp for me. He's not on a massive amount of material but what he does play on Bowie tracks is so good he gets my vote.
I feel that Bowie always had the right Lead Guitarist for the album. He had so many great band members.
His stellar playing on The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and The Spiders From Mars alone seals the deal for me!
With such incredible tracks as:
Hang Onto Yourself
...which are chock full of slashing crunching guitar riffs, courtesy of Mick!
Also one of the best "sequencing of 3 rock songs", anywhere, any album!!!
Starman, Moonage Daydream, Star, and It Ain't Easy, are close follow ups, with great guitar lines.
It's a perfect album showcasing Ronson's expertise!
Slick covers ALL the bases so he gets my vote
For me, the real question is, "After Ronson and Fripp, who's your favorite?"
Answer: Earl Slick
I agree that this have been fascinating, given that they were very much contemporaries. My impression though, based on years of reading Bills message board and other writings, is that Bill has a bit of animosity toward DB, like maybe he didn't get credit for having some influence on some of David's artistic directions; they definitely have circled the same territories at one time or another. Again, just my impression. He never comes out and says anything overt and he has written complimentary things about Bowie as well, but Bill can definitely be a little prickly and I wonder if that may be a reason they never hooked up.
My fave Bowie Guitarist is Reeves. The work he did across those 90's albums is stellar.
And Reeves DID do an album with Bill and it's a corker.
Bowie always had great musicians in my opinion. Have to go with Mick on this one.
Ronson is an obvious choice.
But I went with Reeves. I think a lot of those mentioned made great, and significant contributions to the music. But Reeves, at some level, picked Bowie up and helped him get back to creative ways. Bowie was a leader some many times, but he was also human. When he needed a hand, Reeves was there. He also has a more contemporary approach, imo.
Favourite - Mick
Wish Bowie had never met him - Gabrels, a tasteless oaf who I was glad to see the back of.
Indeed although I always thought that Carlos was a better rhythm player than lead or soloist but he is a top notch songwriter. His riff for "Fame" created a great collaborative vehicle for Bowie, Lennon and Carlos
For me it's a three way:
I always found it fascinating that Ian Hunter worked with two of Bowie's favorite guitarists--Mick and Earle Slick. I kind of wish that Bowie had worked with Hunter n a couple of other projects as well as producer.
Voted Earl Slick. The question was "who's your fave?" and something about Slick's light touch on those smooth hybrid soul numbers has always spoken to me. But Ronson would be "best" or "greatest" or "most popular" "Most influential" etc.
I don't understand why you want to make everyone who's not Mick Ronson feel bad.
^^In a nutshell.^^
Can't pick just one. There are so many great ones. My faves are Earl Slick (he kicks ass on so many songs.. especially Stay), Robert Fripp (Heroes nuff said), Adrian Belew!!! and of course Mick Ronson!
You really want me to choose between Ronson, Fripp, Belew, Vaughan, and Gabrels? Sorry. Can't do it.
Tough. Ronson. Fripp. Belew...but Earl Slick was the most versatile. And he played on most of my favorite Bowie tunes.
Separate names with a comma.