I'm not familiar with how "redbook", as it pertains to PE, is built into the player's circuitry. HCDC decoding, for example, can be implemented in different ways, but HDCD isn't part of redbook. Is PE addressed in the same extact way for every player? There are so many chips and circuit designs, etc, but I'd think reading the disc for the flag is a no brainer.
I've never investigated exactly how it works, but I do know that de-emphasizing is done after the D/A conversion by running the signal through a simple analog low pass filter to EQ it. I would imagine that it probably works like this: if the CD player detects the pre-emphasis flag, then it will switch the filter on. Otherwise, the filter is off. Not too terribly difficult to design. The reason it's not in some CD players is probably because: 1. They're trying to cut costs 2. They figure most people these days don't have CDs with pre-emphasis. 3. They figure most people who do have CD's with pre-emphasis probably won't even notice the difference if it's not de-emphasized.
My cd player -yamaha cdx-397 mk2 I tried to play my Genesis cd wind and wuthering UK V/C 4005 cd Sonopress copy (matrix = CDSCD 4005/B-2309 A) that has pre-emphasis, it seems that my cd player know how to play it correctly because even with the pre-emphasis the sound is not too bright , I made a copy of the cd on cdr and the cdr sounds much more bright than the original cd.
The Chord Hugo DAC can decode preemphasis according to their Production Manager: "Hugo is capable of decoding pre-emphasis in 50/15us format"
Would like to know if my TEAC PDH600 can decode it as a 35DP Glenn Gould Goldberg Variations I have sounds a bit bright to me.
You can burn the cd music on cdr, if the cdr has brighter sound than the original cd then it seems that your cd player can decode pre-emphasis.
I burned the cd to cdr with windows media player and I noticed immediately that the cdr much more brighter, the add of treble to the sound of the cdr is very significant.
It should be noted that you would have to burn to CD-R *without* the pre-emphasis flag set. A correct burn (with flags set) should sound identical to the original.
I wonder if the 35DP Glenn Gould Goldberg Variations is one of the rare CDs that has pre-emphasis but not TOC flagged (EAC didn't recognise it). How would I rip this type?
Ripping is no different; PE doesn't affect the audio data. You just have to manually add the pre-emphasis flags in the CUE sheet before burning.
Windows Media Player (Windows) - recent versions detect pre-emphasis in subcode and apply de-emphasis automatically, but just for playback, not ripping. --------- Tunes (Mac OS & Windows) - recent versions detect pre-emphasis in subcode and apply de-emphasis automatically for both playback and ripping. Windows Media Player (Windows) - recent versions detect pre-emphasis in subcode and apply de-emphasis automatically, but just for playback, not ripping. cdda2wav (multi-platform) - a command-line app (part of the cdrtools package) which can be invoked with a -T parameter to apply de-emphasis as it rips; e.g. cdda2wav -D 0,0,0 -B -T (first use cdda2wav -scanbus to figure out the right device values for the -D option). Some audio processing software can apply a de-emphasis filter to already-extracted audio (files on disk), producing new files: WaveEmph (Windows) - processes one WAV file at a time, and can optionally apply a volume gain at the same time. Note: after unzipping, right-click on the .exe and set Win98 compatibility before running it for the first time. SoX (multi-platform) - a command-line app which can be invoked with a deemph parameter to apply a de-emphasis filter; http://wiki.hydrogenaudio.org/index.php?title=Pre-emphasis
necro-bump! I've been thinking about a standalone CD player that handles pre-emphasis since my collection of PE discs seems to be growing.. so to match the rest of my gear, I contacted Cambridge Audio support. The reply I got back was: I think I might pick up one of those Onkyo C-7030 players. Does anyone know if certain players have difficulty with either PE flag (either TOC or subcode)?
Wouldn't it be easier to list players that DON'T decode pre-emphasis? It's supposed to be in the spec, so the rare few that don't are obviously an oversight (maybe in some cases an intentional cost-cutting measure). I know the Oppo BDP-83 does not.
The Oppo BDP 80 does, but only via analog out, I tested with New Order's Low-Life (TOC) I need to verify the Onkyo c 7030 analog, it does not via optical or coax
You wouldn't expect a player to apply de-emphasis on the digital output as the PE flag is carried in the SPDIF data, and the outboard DAC would deal with it.
Ok after spending more time between the Oppo 80 and the Onkyo 7030 I used Howard Jones Human's Lib this time as the test CD because it's a tough one to decipher as it still sounds pretty bight once de-emphed even with software, (New Order's Low-Life was easily detected),Howard Jones I have one with Pre in the TOC the other press with Pre in the SUB and the standard US (De-Emphed) Oppo 80 both Analog out, Both HDMI out Onkyo 7030-Both Analog out only My DC-1 has active inputs so it was quite easy switching back and forth I have re-instated my HDMI em-bedder so I can utilize the DC-1 's DAC