Midnight Oil - the album thread

Discussion in 'Music Corner' started by mark winstanley, May 20, 2018.

  1. ericthegardener

    ericthegardener Forum Resident

    Location:
    Dallas, TX
    Been listening to Midnight Oil on shuffle all morning/afternoon and Antarctica just came up. That piano outro really is brilliant. Takes an already great song and makes it even better. Especially when the piano switches to double-time just as the song is fading out. Don't know why, but that small moment really gets to me. Gotta love the details!
     
  2. bob_32_116

    bob_32_116 Forum Flaneur

    Location:
    Perth Australia
    The tune may be more mellow, in a relative sense, but the lyrics are anything but.
     
  3. mark winstanley

    mark winstanley Certified dinosaur, who likes physical product Thread Starter

    Scream in Blue (Live)

    [​IMG]
    Live album by Midnight Oil
    Released
    5 May 1992
    Recorded 1982 - 1990
    Genre Rock
    Length 59:59
    Label Sprint Music / Columbia Records
    Producer Midnight Oil & Keith Walker
    Midnight Oil chronology
    The Green Disc
    (1990) Scream In Blue (Live)
    (1992) Earth and Sun and Moon
    (1993)
    Scream in Blue (Live) is a live concert album by Midnight Oil that was released in 1992 under the Columbia Records label. It contains songs carefully culled from 5 live concerts recorded over a 9-year period.[1] The audiences sound quite large, but also included is material from a 1990 protest concert held on the street in front of Exxon headquarters in New York City.[2] The album is mixed so as to sound like one continuous concert.

    The album starts with a scathing, nearly atonal electric guitar solo and never lets up (until the final, more subdued studio bonus track Burnie), careening through a hooky hard-rock minefield of clever, socially conscious lyrics sung with passion over a rip-roaring but very tight band.[3] The tracks were evidently recorded through the sound systems of the various concerts, then mixed to a clear and well-balanced sound in the style of audio verité. Also, at the end of Only the Strong, a short sound sample is inserted containing some chanting by unidentified American Indians[2] which also sounds passionately rendered, although jarringly out of context.

    1. "Scream in Blue" 2:56 (Garrett, Moginie, Rotsey) - Horden Pavilion, Sydney, 1984
    2. "Read About It" 3:52 (Garrett, Hirst, Moginie) - Brisbane Entertainment Centre, 1990
    3. "Dreamworld" 3:42 (Garrett, Hirst, Moginie) - Brisbane Entertainment Centre, 1990
    4. "Brave Faces" 5:00 (Garrett, Moginie) - Capitol Theatre, Sydney, 1982
    5. "Only the Strong" 5:41 (Hirst, Moginie) - Capitol Theatre, Sydney, 1982
    6. "Stars of Warburton" 5:04 (Garrett, Moginie) - Brisbane Entertainment Centre, 1990
    7. "Progress" 6:17 (Garrett, Moginie) - Exxon Protest, 6th Ave, N.Y., N.Y., 1990
    8. "Beds Are Burning" 4:05 (Garrett, Hirst, Moginie) - Our Common Future Concert, Darlinghurst, 1989
    9. "Sell My Soul" 4:10 (Garrett, Moginie) - Brisbane Entertainment Centre, 1990
    10. "Sometimes" 3:29 (Garrett, Hirst, Moginie) - Our Common Future Concert, Darlinghurst, 1989
    11. "Hercules" 4:57 (Garrett, Hirst, Moginie) - Brisbane Entertainment Centre, 1990
    12. "Powderworks" 5:50 (Garrett, Hirst, James, Moginie, Rotsey) - Capitol Theatre, Sydney, 1982
    13. "Burnie" 5:04 (Garrett, Moginie) - Bonus Track, Acoustic Recording - Albert Studios, Sydney, 1992

    This is a good and worthwhile collection of live tunes from the band. It is definitely worth getting, especially if you're a fan of live albums.
    I still feel that the Best of Both Worlds DVD with Live at the Capitol and Oils on Water (+the cd of Oils On Water) is more essential.
     
    Carlox and John Buchanan like this.
  4. mark winstanley

    mark winstanley Certified dinosaur, who likes physical product Thread Starter

    Earth and Sun and Moon

    [​IMG]
    Studio album by Midnight Oil
    Released
    20 April 1993
    Recorded October 1992 − January 1993
    Studio Megaphon Studios, Sydney, Australia
    Genre Rock, alternative rock
    Length 54:00
    Label Sprint / Columbia
    Producer Nick Launay, Midnight Oil
    Midnight Oil chronology
    Scream in Blue (Live)
    (1992) Earth and Sun and Moon
    (1993) Breathe
    (1996)

    Earth and Sun and Moon
    is an album by Australian rock group, Midnight Oil, that was released on 20 April 1993 under the Columbia Records label. It peaked at No.2 on the ARIA Albums Chart.

    Midnight Oil's Earth and Sun and Moon album, produced with Nick Launay, was released on 20 April 1993 and peaked at No. 2 on the ARIA Albums Chart,[1] top 20 in Sweden and Switzerland,[2] Top 50 on Billboard 200,[3] and top thirty in the UK albums chart.[4] The single "Truganini" referenced multiple issues, including the 'last' Tasmanian Aboriginal, the treatment of indigenous artist Albert Namatjira, the Australian flag debate, and republicanism.[5] Liner notes for the single claimed "Truganini was the sole surviving Tasmanian Aborigine, the last of her race, when she died in 1876."[5] The Tasmanian Aboriginal Centre, representing over 7000 contemporary Tasmanians, called for the single to be boycotted as it perpetuated a 'white' myth about the extinction of Tasmanian Aborigines.[5] Their Native Title claims hinged upon establishing links with ancestral lands. Gary Morris, their manager, responded with, "My suggestion to these people is to stop shooting themselves in the foot and let a band like Midnight Oil voice its appeal to White Australia on behalf of Black Australia".[5] Critics contended that Morris disparaged Indigenous Australians' ability to represent themselves and overestimated Midnight Oil's ambassadorial powers while diminishing their errors, while some indigenous activists saw benefit in Midnight Oil's highlighting of the issues.[5] Nevertheless, "Truganini" released in March peaked at No. 10 on the ARIA singles charts,[1] No. 10 on Billboard Mainstream Rock Tracks and No. 4 on their Modern Rock Tracks charts,[3] and top thirty for the UK charts.
    -----------------------------------
    This album is fairly new to me. Upon initial listening it sounds like a pretty solid album in similar vein to the couple of albums prior.
    What are your feelings about this album?
    What are your favourite songs on this album?
    Give us your input on this album and what it means to you.
     
    JulesRules likes this.
  5. bob_32_116

    bob_32_116 Forum Flaneur

    Location:
    Perth Australia
    I only heard this album in full fairly recently and found myself a little disappointed in it. I also found it hard to say exactly why. Perhaps it was just that I found nothing much really new here - not bad songs as such, basically just more of the same. I still love Truganini, though.

    It's a shame I don't love this album more, because I really like the cover, one of their best.

    BTW it's not quoted above, but I believe Peter Garrett later issued a correction and an apology for their well-meaning but incorrect labelling of Truganini as "the last Tasmanian aborigine".
     
  6. bob_32_116

    bob_32_116 Forum Flaneur

    Location:
    Perth Australia
    I chuckled at this. It makes the article look very dated. The term "Indians" or "Red Indians" as applied to refer to Native Americans has, thankfully, all but disappeared. Apart from anything else wrong with the term, it was just obviously factually incorrect.
     
  7. mark winstanley

    mark winstanley Certified dinosaur, who likes physical product Thread Starter

    technically Native American's isn't very accurate either .... Eskimos, Mayan's, Inca's etc LOL
     
  8. mark winstanley

    mark winstanley Certified dinosaur, who likes physical product Thread Starter

    Feeding Frenzy
    Starting off with a nice piece of drum work from Hirst this song moves into a solid rock song. I like the fact the guitar in this has a bit of bite, something they seem to have moved away from. To me this is a bit of a musical return to form. The band had seemed to move into the AOR territory a bit further than I would have liked on the two previous albums.
    For me a very promising start to the album.


    Lyrics
    Well I'm as old as the hills
    And young as the day
    Nobody sees things, in quite the same way
    Computers and shovels, churches and brothels
    Mannequins and skeletons, cities and dustbowls

    Here we go here we go again
    Hear the clamour of the feeding pen
    New day new way all my friends can say

    Cyclone fences in the cybernetic orchard
    Miracle drugs, discount bulk purchase
    Sacred in the forest, fast food in the kiosk
    Cardboard dinners and the saints and the sinners

    I don't want to run and hide
    I've seen it all from either side
    Truth and fiction must collide someday

    God knows, God knows, God knows it's been fun

    Ah, sweet sensation, the oldest temptation
    Now throughout the ages, we've been a' turning all those pages
    Now each generation you've got to choose a new location
    Got to reach out, got to sync up, build up, get up, to a stronger foundation

    God knows, God knows, God knows it's been fun
     
    JulesRules and black sheriff like this.
  9. mark winstanley

    mark winstanley Certified dinosaur, who likes physical product Thread Starter

    My Country
    This is very much a song that could have come off the last two albums. There is a very nice piano riff that works well through this song and again a few sections where the guitar returns to a more edgy sound, but maybe not quite enough. This is a very good song and I remember hearing it on the radio back in the day.


    Lyrics
    Was it just a dream, were you so confused
    Was it just a giant leap of logic
    Was it the time of year, that makes a state of fear
    Methods were the motives for the action

    And did I hear you say
    My country right or wrong

    Did you save your face
    Did you breach your faith
    Women, there were children at the shelter
    Now who can stop the hail
    When human senses fail
    There was never any warning, no escape

    Did I hear you say
    My country right or wrong
    My country oh so strong
    My country going wrong
    My country right or wrong

    I hear you say the truth must take a beating
    The flag a camouflage for your deceiving
    I know, yes I know
    It's written on your soul
    I know, we all make mistakes

    This is not a case of blurred vision
    It's a case of black holes, pocket holes, soul holes

    And did I hear you say...
     
    JulesRules, Carlox and black sheriff like this.
  10. bob_32_116

    bob_32_116 Forum Flaneur

    Location:
    Perth Australia
    It annoys me that they have a song called "My Country" and other called "One Country", making it very easy to confuse the two.
     
  11. mark winstanley

    mark winstanley Certified dinosaur, who likes physical product Thread Starter

    Easy album and song guide

    Midnight Oil - 1978 Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 1 Powderworks Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 2 Head over heals Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 3 Dust Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 4 Used and Abused Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 5 Surfing with a spoon Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 6 Run by night Midnight Oil - the album thread
    Run by night live 1981 - Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 7 Nothing lost ... nothing gained Midnight Oil - the album thread

    Head Injuries - 1979 Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 1 Cold cold change Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 2 Section 5 (bus to Bondi) Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 3 Naked flame Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 4 Back on the borderline Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 5 Koala sprint Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 6 No reaction Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 7 Stand in line Midnight Oil - the album thread
    Stand in line live 1981 - Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 8 Profiteers Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 9 Is it now? Midnight Oil - the album thread

    Bird Noises EP 1980 Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 1 No time for games Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 2 Knife's edge Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 3 Wedding cake island Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 4 I'm the cure Midnight Oil - the album thread

    Live at the Melbourne Show Grounds 1980 - Midnight Oil - the album thread

    Place Without A Postcard 1981 Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 1 Don't wanna be the one Midnight Oil - the album thread
    don't wanna be the one live - Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 2 Brave faces Midnight Oil - the album thread
    Brave faces live in 1982 - Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 3 Armistice day Midnight Oil - the album thread
    Armistice day live 1982 - Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 4 Someone else to blame Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 5 Basement Flat Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 6 Written in the heart Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 7 Burnie Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 8 Quinella holiday Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 9 Love's on sale Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 10 If Ned Kelly was King Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 11 Lucky country Midnight Oil - the album thread

    10,9,8,7,6,5,4,3,2,1 - 1982 - Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 1 Outside world Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 2 Only the Strong Midnight Oil - the album thread
    Only the Strong Live Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 3 Short Memory Midnight Oil - the album thread
    Short Memory live Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 4 Read About It Midnight Oil - the album thread
    Read About It Live Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 5 Scream in Blue Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 6 U.S. Forces Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 7 Power and The Passion Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 8 Maralinga Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 9 Tin Legs And Tin Mines Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 10 Somebody's trying to tell me something Midnight Oil - the album thread

    Red Sails In The Sunset 1983 - Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 1 When the Generals Talk Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 2 Best Of Both Worlds Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 3 Sleep Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 4 Minutes To Midnight Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 5 Jimmy Sharman's Boxers Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 6 Bakerman Midnight Oil - the album thread
    Bakerman demo, with vocals Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 7 Who Can Stand In the Way Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 8 Kosciuszko Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 9 Helps Me Helps You Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 10 Harrisburg Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 11 Bells And Horns In The Back Of Beyond Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 12 Shipyards Of New Zealand Midnight Oil - the album thread

    Oils On Water - Live On Goat Island 1985 - Midnight Oil - the album thread
    Best of both worlds Midnight Oil - the album thread
    When the generals talk Midnight Oil - the album thread
    Minutes to midnight Midnight Oil - the album thread
    Sleep Midnight Oil - the album thread
    Only the strong Midnight Oil - the album thread
    Short memory Midnight Oil - the album thread
    Kosciuszko Midnight Oil - the album thread
    US forces Midnight Oil - the album thread
    Jimmy Sharman's Boxers Midnight Oil - the album thread
    Back on the borderline Midnight Oil - the album thread
    Tin legs and tin mines Midnight Oil - the album thread
    Don't wanna be the one Midnight Oil - the album thread
    Power and the passion Midnight Oil - the album thread
    Read about it Midnight Oil - the album thread
    Harrisburg Midnight Oil - the album thread
    Stand in line Midnight Oil - the album thread

    Species Deceases 1985 - Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 1 Progress Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 2 Hercules Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 3 Blossom and Blood Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 4 Pictures Midnight Oil - the album thread

    Diesel and Dust 1987 - Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 1 Beds are burning Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 2 Put down that weapon Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 3 Dreamworld Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 4 Arctic world Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 5 Warakuma Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 6 The dead heart Midnight Oil - the album thread
    The dead heart - extended version - Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 7 Whoah Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 8 Bullroarer Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 9 Sell my soul Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 10 Sometimes Midnight Oil - the album thread
    Sometimes live - bootleg - Midnight Oil - the album thread
    Sometimes live 1989 - Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 11 Gunbarrel Highway Midnight Oil - the album thread

    Blue Sky Mining 1990 = Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 1 Blue sky mine Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 2 Stars of Warburton Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 3 Bedlam Bridge Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 4 Forgotten years Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 5 Mountains of Burma Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 6 King of the Mountain Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 7 River Runs Red Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 8 Shakers and Movers Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 9 One Country Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 10 Antarctica Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 11 You May Not Be Realeased Midnight Oil - the album thread

    Scream In Blue (Live) 1992 - Midnight Oil - the album thread

    Earth And Sun And Moon 1993 - Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 1 Feeding Frenzy Midnight Oil - the album thread
    track 2 My Country Midnight Oil - the album thread

    Midnight Oil and Exxon - Midnight Oil - the album thread

    Peter Garret and Jimmy Barnes (live)
    - Dreams of ordinary men (Dragon) - Midnight Oil - the album thread
    - Locomotive Breath (Jethro Tull) - Midnight Oil - the album thread

    Rob Hirst - Beatbox - Midnight Oil - the album thread
     
  12. mark winstanley

    mark winstanley Certified dinosaur, who likes physical product Thread Starter

    Renaissance Man
    Another really good song. Sure the Oils have still got that semi-pop kind of sound that held on when they broke through, but again this song like a few others has a bit more edge back in the guitars and that helps to give the songs a bit more edge.


    Lyrics
    Well I told you about the forest and trees and the chlorophyll green
    Yes I told you the birds will endure flutter wings dance on leaves
    Hold onto dreams, hold onto dreams tonight

    Well I told you about the high pressure cell coming down on the breeze
    And I know that the things you can't see they are hard to believe
    Hold onto dreams, hold onto dreams tonight

    A new world order has been formed
    Between the cheque book and the dawn
    A new renaissance man is born

    Renaissance man are you ready
    Renaissance man
    Renaissance man are you ready
    See what a world that you can make

    Well I heard about the spirit of life is it flickering still
    Yes I heard that the dark bellied angel's come running up the hill
    Hold onto dreams, hold onto dreams tonight

    Smash and grab the women and child
    All the souls are growing wild
    Stripped so bare well the universe stares
    It's so close to home that we got to share with you
    So many genuine things surround you
    Wild weather man well it still confounds you
    Cast away the greed and death machine and bytes
    And abacus and lights and hold onto your dreams tonight

    So you found a hard won friend
    To hold your hand and hold your head
    A new renaissance to defend
    Hold onto dreams, hold onto dreams tonight

    Where are we going to be, in 3033
    What's spinning round your brain
    Are you a renaissance man or are you a renaissance woman
    If you jump out an angel will give you wings
     
    JulesRules and black sheriff like this.
  13. mark winstanley

    mark winstanley Certified dinosaur, who likes physical product Thread Starter

    Earth and Sun and Moon
    To a degree I get the feeling that the Oils realised they had slid into the popish trap over the last couple of albums. This is a fairly mellow song but still starts with a more raw feel, that reintroduces itself between the verses.


    Lyrics
    In the morning we will wake up and take to the air
    Look back at the planet - I'm glued to my chair
    Southern half is burning as we climb through the cky
    Sea birds softly falling, smoke way up high

    There's the contours of the mountains, the deserts and plains
    And a hurricane is blowing, and it turns once again
    Now there's oil spills in the water where Columbus once sailed
    And there's history and mystery and it's rolling away

    I wish you could see this great mystery
    Earth and sun and moon, human tribe, thin blue line
    Earth and sun and moon will survive

    Sediment is flowing from river to sea
    Now where are the mighty nations, no lines to be seen
    An axe upon the broken ground the sigh of the trees
    And it's floating in the ether, it brings me to my knees

    Too messed up to care
    Anyone got a wing and a prayer
    In the blink of an eye
    Thank you and goodnight

    Earth and sun and moon, human tribe, one thin blue line
    Earth and sun and moon will survive, will survive, we will survive
     
    JulesRules, Carlox and black sheriff like this.
  14. mark winstanley

    mark winstanley Certified dinosaur, who likes physical product Thread Starter

    Live on MUCH MUSIC Toronto Canada 1993
     
  15. Mondie

    Mondie Forum Resident

    one of the best threads I have seen on this fantastic forum, I must admit I struggle to take it all in. Midnight Oil is my favourite Aussie band and the best our country has ever produced, 10-1 and Red sails are their highpoints. Keep posting as I am enjoying reading other peoples interpretations and opinions of a band I have held dear for decades.
     
  16. mark winstanley

    mark winstanley Certified dinosaur, who likes physical product Thread Starter

    i think one of the best things about this for me is when someone from Scandinavia or something says that this song impacted them, or that album was great and has some cool story to tell, or they saw the Oils at blah blah with whoever ... it is really nice to find that some Aussie bands aside from INXS and LRB got some love O.S.
    Glad you're enjoying it mate
     
    JulesRules and Mondie like this.
  17. Mondie

    Mondie Forum Resident

    Very true Mark, it does add an extra dimension to see such lyrically strong songs many of which are about Australian politics/social history getting the recognition they deserve across many different cultures. Good music is just that but so much great music never gets a chance outside of Oz.
     
    mark winstanley likes this.
  18. Splungeworthy

    Splungeworthy Forum Rezidentura

    Jeez I step away for one minute and you blew by my favorite Oils album.
    Not only is Blue Sky Mining the best Oils album (IMO of course), I feel fairly comfortable putting it up there with the best rock albums of the era. Solid playing (the guitars! amazing synchronicity between Jim and Martin), great production, inescapable hooks, and the live hands of Bones Hillman.
     
  19. mark winstanley

    mark winstanley Certified dinosaur, who likes physical product Thread Starter

    Sorry mate. I'm just rolling along at two songs a day.
    Don't be afraid to go through them as you feel though!
     
    Splungeworthy likes this.
  20. mark winstanley

    mark winstanley Certified dinosaur, who likes physical product Thread Starter

    Truganina
    "Truganini" is a song by Australian rock band Midnight Oil, from their album Earth and Sun and Moon. It was inspired by Truganini, a Tasmanian Aborigine.

    The song uses a recurring Australian problem (drought) to pose the question "What for?", meaning "why did Europeans bother to colonize this harsh place". The song mentions two prominent indigenous Australians (Truganini and Albert Namatjira) whose lives were altered by European settlement and discusses current day sentiment towards the old country, namely the monarchy.

    The single's liner notes included the claim that Truganini was the "sole surviving Tasmanian Aborigine" when she died. This sparked protest by some of the 7,000 people who identify as Tasmanian Aboriginal.[1] Lead singer, Peter Garrett issued an apology.

    The band performed the song live for American audiences as the musical guest on the American television show Saturday Night Live on May 8, 1993 when Christina Applegate served as host.
    -----------
    A very recognisable song to Australian's at least, this is a good song.

     
  21. mark winstanley

    mark winstanley Certified dinosaur, who likes physical product Thread Starter

    Bushfire
    Starting with a very plainly recorded guitar with a vocal coming in, and then the regular structure of instruments coming in. Then reverting back to this for the second verse. This is a very intimate vocal, and sounds very close mic'd. Good song and an effective recording of it.
     
    JulesRules and black sheriff like this.
  22. ericthegardener

    ericthegardener Forum Resident

    Location:
    Dallas, TX
    For me Earth and Sun and Moon is the sound of Midnight Oil treading water. There's a couple of songs I absolutely can't stand (Renaissance Man, Outbreak of Love), one song that sits comfortably among the best they've ever done (Truganini), and a bunch of songs that are not bad at all but don't do much to inspire excitement. Even though most of the songs on this album have something to recommend them, the end result is very middle of the road. I thought that the previous two albums were a step down from the band's best work, but I like them both a lot more than E&S&M.

    One one hand, the recording is more warm and natural than Blue Sky Mining, and that's something that I normally prefer. But one the other hand, the performances and (particularly) the songwriting & arrangements don't strike me as particularly inspired. They are lots of individual moments that I like and I do listen to it for pleasure occasionally, but I always find myself wishing it were better.

    Still, Truganini absolutely kills me. Let it burn!
     
    Carlox, SpudOz and mark winstanley like this.
  23. mark winstanley

    mark winstanley Certified dinosaur, who likes physical product Thread Starter

    Drums of Heaven
    This album is completely new to me and the first thing that strikes me is the guitars on here have a return to some of the raw, edgy guitars on 10-1, but the songs themselves aren't all that edgy. It's like they were aiming for a middle ground between the popish stuff that had been very popular and the artistically reaching stuff that crossed a few boundaries. Upon reading folks comments on here, I'm guessing that in the minds of the fans that didn't really happen for them.
    Another good song, to my ears.
     
    JulesRules, Carlox and black sheriff like this.
  24. mark winstanley

    mark winstanley Certified dinosaur, who likes physical product Thread Starter

    Outbreak Of Love
    This song starts off with a Dear Prudence motif and again the guitars are a little more edgy and direct than the previous two albums. I seem to remember hearing this on the radio back in the day.
     
    JulesRules and black sheriff like this.
  25. SpudOz

    SpudOz Forum Resident

    This is pretty much how I would describe Earth and Sun and Moon though you've done it a lot more diplomatically than I would've written. To me, E&S&M is AOR/MOR Midnight Oil. Whereas Blue Sky Mining seemed like a reaction not to upset the newly found fans, E&S&M to me is a laid back, slick attempt to appeal to the US "soft rock" brigade. While it's not as bad as the overproduced LA corporate sound that I generally despise, it sure sounds like they are making a concerted effort to emulate that laid back sound. The anger was gone and in its place was introspection and an album that was bland and devoid of any bite. I also agree that Truganini is a latter classic Oils song but it stands out like a sore thumb against the mediocrity surrounding it. With this album I thought that the Oils were starting to lose it and were desperately appealing to a more international audience.

    As I wrote in post 442 earlier:
     
    ericthegardener likes this.

Share This Page

molar-endocrine