Discussion in 'Music Corner' started by Doctor Jimmy, Mar 2, 2018.
Silver and Gold
Chrome Dreams vol. 2
I spent a lot of time with this album, and I like or love every minute of it.
I just wish "Shots" would of been a more controlled type of kaos.
A real wasted opportunity IMO on one of the best songs Neil ever wrote.....
I was listening to a Melbourne audience tape from a couple of years ago and at some point people are yelling for T-Bone, and he goes "I don't get too many requests for T-Bone", and then I listened to a show from 1985 I think, also from Melbourne, and would you believe it, more requests for T-Bone!
"T Bone" is a "cult favourite" Neil Young song, methinks... You know yer not talking to a fair weather/"I like Harvest" Neilfan if they start talking about "T Bone".
3 of your are acoustic based, which even neil has a hard time screwing up (except 'peace trail' which could have been good but he tried to get too fancy). and many of those were old songs anyway.
the other 3: 'le noise - old songs
pill - verbose and overdone - should have been a single album
greendale - and very sorry for this - just terrible
When the material is good, for example Southern Pacific and Shots, it works. There is a lot of filler here, though, like he wanted fulfill a contract or something.
The cover, the black and red triangles, and as I recall the original LP was kind of glossy? It had a modern feel. It didn't look like a Neil Young album and certainly didn't fit a pure grunge Neil and the Horse effort. Always thought that poor match hurt the album a little.
It's a fun listen but not a high rotation thing.
Your opinion. These albums are not perfect but still better than most of his 80s stuff.
well I had heard the bootleg before Reactor came out.
I hope you arent calling Opera Star and Surfer Joe and Rapid Transit filler.
There's a part of me that absolutely loves T-Bone. Kind of like "Old King" and "Piece of Crap." Actually, Piece of Crap is an absolute classic.
I've heard Southern Pacific played love and it sounds pretty strong. The songs are good. Shots is good. Rapid Transit is good. The playing and production are shrill, though. I need to pull it out and play Surfer Joe again. This album and Hawks and Doves leave me in a quandary.
And applicable for today. Maybe Neil should revisit and reboot.
"They're just songs," said Neil Young.
I forgot: "Motor City" is fun, too.
Uh, 1 old song on Le Noise
Your opinion - and very sorry for this - just terrible
Greendale is GREAT. And so is Re-ac-tor.
Got Mashed Potatoes ain't got no T-Bone. I bought Reactor and Hawks & Doves at the same time radical to mellow Reactor is a must have.
i am very surprised at how many people like 'greendale'.
i find a mess, in every way, musically, vocally, lyrically and story wise. and there are just no hooks anywhere to be found on the entire record.
It's the most divisive title in his catalog that's for sure. People seem to either really love it or really hate it.
I thought Hawks and Doves was a disaster after Rust Never Sleeps, so I probably overvalued Reactor & played the hell out of it when it came out. Been awhile since I've wanted to hear it again, but I liked it all.
That's what I'm talking about.
See also: Landing On Water, which gets my vote for "most divisive Neil Young album". I fall in the "like" category, by the way.
Sure, and Trans is another one that people feel really strongly about one way or the other.
Love that album. I also love Hawks and Doves
southern pacific is one of my favorites. However, this is one of the Neil albums I never bonded with and never bought. Heard it thru only once. Didnt hook me for the most part. Southern Pacific - I either taped it or bought a single, if there was such... cant remember.
as mentioned, the follow up "Trans" was a real head-scratcher.
Separate names with a comma.