Discussion in 'Music Corner' started by Steve Hoffman, Aug 14, 2016.
A few of you missed this..
Steve, does it go for both the US and Japan versions of HW61? I would think so.
Thanks. I got to get Strange Days. It is still missing from my collection. Crazy prices on eBay!
Isn't the AP SACD good? I heard it was.
Sounds clinical and bottomless compared to the DCC---dang that one sounds sooooo buttery
Cool. I have the two Doors and the Van Halen CDs (and the LP release of VH as well).
My understanding is that VH's 1984 was mastered for DCC as well but for whatever reasons, was shelved. If so, was that also mastered on this rig Or did that project ever get to that stage?
The DCC Doors sound fantastic, especially the first two. I prefer the AP SACDs on the last two albums.
It kills me that they did not release 1984. It might be my favorite album of all time.
After the three Steve gave us, I would have guessed HW61 and McCartney. Both of those discs have some "wow" moments that really stand out to me as memorable even in comparison to other DCCs. I've long said the DCC Like A Rolling Stone has a certain something that the AF version doesn't.
And I own every single DCC gold disc so I've heard 'em all.
Much as like the Van Halen disc, I wouldn't have guessed that one. I never thought other iterations sounded that far out on the "solid state" bell curve.
The AP Doors LPs are great sounding. Of course, thats vinyl, not SACD. Just in case anyone was wondering (although this is not a revelation to many).
You're speaking of the AP "Strange Days"? Well, let me fill you in on something. That's pretty much how the mix sounds in its unaltered state. Clinical and bottomless. Which is interesting because Love's "Forever Changes" mixed by the same person on the same gear sounds nothing like that. Maybe Bruce was trying to get a livelier sound? I don't know.
However, the first "LEDO" by Elektra clearly documents trying to "fix" the sound of "Strange Days" by making it warmer and more natural sounding. I followed the LEDO version very carefully (since it's the cutting master for all the stereo LPs.) So the DCC version has bass and it has a nice, organic quality. I would have thought the Analogue Productions version would have done the same since Chad always loved the DCC. Who mastered the AP version? Do you know? Just curious.
I have all but VanHalen.
OK, now what are the 11 secret herbs and spices???...
I don't know how much Bruce was involved but they do say "have been remastered by Doug Sax and The Doors’ original engineer Bruce Botnick"
History is fun! Very interesting--did not know about the Elektra "fix"--you certainly spoiled us by emulating it, however I've kept the AP's as they're a more convenient way of hearing the 5.1 mixes vs. the PERCEPTION box, but maybe I'll revisit the stereo versions again as I haven't played them in a couple of years at least.
Have all of them minus Van Halen. Still enjoy those Doors quite a bit. I guess lots of research and simple mastering is best.
Separate names with a comma.