Discussion in 'Audio Hardware' started by High Fidelity, Mar 23, 2017.
The manual of the player discussed in this topic doesn't
I accept that, but the point I am trying to make is that this is a limitation that should be applied to ALL Blu Ray players. Sony, as one of the main players in the development of Blu Ray aren't going to knowingly break the rules.
Ok. What makes me wonder is how difficult it is to find information about this from the Internet. I haven't found a single source which explains this and which isn't from some forum
I suppose I am at least in part going by memory. When DVD Audio and Video first surfaced and when discussions regarding the specifications were occurring (from about 1995ish) I was reading a lot about it Hi Fi magazines and magazines such as Widescreen Review, and at some of that content will be behind a paywall and perhaps pre dates widespread internet usage.
I’m sure that the issue of downconverting high resolution audio from DVDA sources over S/PDIF was extensively discussed back then and it was always intended that quality would be capped at 48/16 or lossy Dolby Digital / DTS unless via analogue outputs or later HDMI. The same principle has been carried over to BD. It’s not just about content protection, I believe ensuring compatibility with legacy surround gear that can only handle these formats is part of the thinking.
It does, I've tried it myself. I have the Criterion edition of The Game and last Summer steelbook of The Fog released by Shout Factory, they obviously don't play on my region B X-800, once they copied with DVDFab and burned to a dual layer BD-R, they play fine.
Has anyone tried this as de-embedder: HDMI 4K Audio Extractor De-Embedder - from LINDY UK ?
I picked up a new X800 today off the shelf at a local Walmart $198 CAD or about $157 USD.
I guess they are clearing them out.
You got a bargain there. If you allow me, just some advice. Keep the buying bill and don't loose it, you may need it, or you may not. Why do I say that? Quality control on this player is a bit hit or miss, you may get one of the good ones or one of the not so good ones that may give you freezing problems with UHD BDs. It's more prone to do it with triple layer 100 Gb. discs (Close Encounters of the third Kind, Pacific Rim, Westworld season 1, Sony Edition of Blade Runner 2049...), second, quality control is not very good on some discs, specially on 3 layer discs, clean them before playing or you may experience some freezing while playing one.
And my last piece of advise, don't go on the Video Settings and compulsively set it to 4K. It will upscale all under 2160p to 2160p (BD's, DVD's etc...), you may want to check which device does a better job at upscalling to 2160p, if the Sony X-800 or your T.V. set. In my case my Samsung 49" 4K HDR sets upscales much better than the Sony X-800, it's like the X-800 applies some kind of DNR that smoothes picture making it look a bit soft and fuzzy. Choose a 1080p BD you know well and change between "Original Resolution" and "4K" and see which one looks better.
Thanks Kiko1974. Appreciated.
Don't need too, you're very welcome. Enjoy it and good luck with it.
I got my first X-800 in May,it worked reasonable well with some ocasional freezing but around a month and half stopped reading all kind of discs, I closed the tray with a BD, an UHD BD or a SACD and it was like if there was no disc inside. I took it to my local Sony service to get it serviced and I finally got a new player.
I've had the new X-800 for around 5 weeks and I haven't had a single freezing even with 3 layer discs, and I've watched Westworld season 1 3 UHD BDs twice since I got the new player and nothing, no freezing and these were the most problematic 3 layer UHD BDs I have that used to freeze once even maybe twice an episode. With the new player, no freezing even with the Westworld discs.
If your player is one of the good ones you got yourself a very reliable and great performing player at a bargain price. Enjoy it, it's picture quality playing BDs and UHD BDs is great.
One feature you may like to try is DSEE HX on audio settings, which upsamples red book 44.1/16 to 88.2/24 and at least to me this feature turned on gets CDs to sound great.
Separate names with a comma.