What happened to Blu-ray Audio?

Discussion in 'Audio Hardware' started by floyd, Mar 25, 2017.

  1. ti-triodes

    ti-triodes Forum Resident

    Location:
    NYC

    I haven't been following the whole thread, but Oppo players have problems playing BD-A's because they screw up the Persistent Storage on the players. Clear it and the BD's play fine.
     
    PhilBiker, quicksrt and Postercowboy like this.
  2. Postercowboy

    Postercowboy Member

    Location:
    Berlin
    I don't know about that. I have all kinds for HiRes formats, and sound-wise I do not have any preference.

    In the end, the major differences are in the mastering, not the medium.

    While my general preference goes to SACD, the real challenge is to find the best sounding version of a specific album, regardless of the medium.

    I just bought Elton John's GOODBYE YELLOW BRICK ROAD on BR-A on ebay. Everyone seems to agree that this is the best sounding digital version of this classic so far. Combined with a price of $14 with shipping, it would seem stupid to buy the old SACD instead. (Which is not only more expensive, it also got a lot of bad reviews as well for the sound quality.)

    Patricia Barber MODERN COOL is another example. Also a different mastering, and the BR-A pretty much corrected everything that was wrong with the SACD.
     
  3. bru87tr

    bru87tr Forum Resident

    Location:
    Lowell, MA
    Elton John's GOODBYE YELLOW BRICK ROAD on BR-A is very very loud. Can't even listen to it. There is a reason it's very cheap.
     
    PhilBiker and Tim Müller like this.
  4. Steel Horse

    Steel Horse Forum Resident

    Location:
    Uppsala, SWEDEN
    Just preordered the upcoming Steven Wilson Blu-ray Audio. The format is not dead yet. Just smells a little funny while in sleep........ :laugh:
     
    PhilBiker likes this.
  5. bru87tr

    bru87tr Forum Resident

    Location:
    Lowell, MA
    It's dead when they start going for crazy prices on ebay. A couple do, but you can still get a great deal on the more sought after ones.

    How many of you have this one ? Guns N Roses 96/24 and Dire Straits sounds quite good too.

    [​IMG]

    [​IMG]

    [​IMG]
     
  6. Postercowboy

    Postercowboy Member

    Location:
    Berlin
    So I stand corrected: ALMOST everybody agrees the BR-A sounds good... ;-)

    Frankly, I never owned any digital version of GYBR, and it's been a long time since I even listened to it last. Since all digital versions seem to be flawed one way or the other, $14 for the BR-A seemed worth the risk. And again, pretty much every other review I read was very positive. For no specific reason, I like it that entire double album is on a single BR disc. Of course, there are all kinds of different systems and different ears, and let's not forget that 'one man's owl is another man's nightingale'.

    I've also looked at Marvin Gaye - WHAT'S GOING ON on BR-A, and it is getting fairly mixed reviews. For the japanese SHM-SACD Universal used the MoFi mastering, and both versions received very good feedback. Amazon description says 'transferred from the original master tapes', which makes me think they used the MoFi tape once again. Which would of course make sense. Now I wonder, could the same mix really sound so much worse on a different medium? Has anyone actually listened to this? The SACD versions are out of print, while the BR-A is still around $20. Frankly, I don't see myself paying a collector's price for this one.
     
    bru87tr likes this.
  7. bru87tr

    bru87tr Forum Resident

    Location:
    Lowell, MA
    Marvin Gaye sounds good to my ears.
     
    Frank Field likes this.
  8. Postercowboy

    Postercowboy Member

    Location:
    Berlin
    I read several reviews that say the BR-A sounds like a super-clean CD. Not exactly what I would want from a Marvin Gaye album. Also, one reviewer on Amazon wrote about both BR-A releases: He was very happy with LET'S GET IT ON, but, in direct comparison, also extremely disappointed by WHAT'S GOING ON.

    It's not a high priority title for me anyway, so I guess I'll wait for a reasonably priced SACD to show up.
     
  9. xcqn

    xcqn Forum Resident

    Location:
    Sweden
    Yikes!

    I'm looking at that packaging thinking... why would anyone wanna buy this?

    For starters this is music and it comes in packaging that was intended for movies. It looks cheap, plasticy and like no thought was put into it AT ALL.

    I don't get why the industry is constantly doing the same misstake. Manufacture something that people can't resist. Something that looks gorgeus and takes you beyond the music itself.

    Something that you would wanna collect. Added value like a 50 pages book with insight into the recording process, interviews, posters, t-shirts, stickers. Just something.

    I'm looking at that thinking, who is this for? They are obviously targeting someone that don't give a crap about estetics and just want the damn music.

    Well, in that case i guess going to hdtracks and download the songs would be the same thing really. You are getting the music and nothing else, just like with the BR-A's.

    Rant over :D
     
    Tim Müller likes this.
  10. SquishySounds

    SquishySounds New Member

    Location:
    New York
    I remember DVD-A from about the time HD-DVD was still a thing, but I never even heard about Blu-ray audio until this forum
     
    PhilBiker likes this.
  11. bru87tr

    bru87tr Forum Resident

    Location:
    Lowell, MA
    Let's get it on does sound better.
     
  12. bru87tr

    bru87tr Forum Resident

    Location:
    Lowell, MA
    It's a demo disc. Only reason it's interesting is for the one Guns N Roses track. Wasn't for sale, lol.
     
  13. DrZhivago

    DrZhivago Forum Resident

    Location:
    Adelaide Australia
    Obligatory.



    Regards
     
    scobb likes this.
  14. xcqn

    xcqn Forum Resident

    Location:
    Sweden
    I realized that, i ment the format as a whole not being very interesting packaging wise.
     
    bru87tr likes this.
  15. marcb

    marcb Forum Resident

    Location:
    DC area
    You actually give Amazon customer reviews credibility when it comes to sound quality? That's the last place in the world I would look.
     
  16. EddieVanHalen

    EddieVanHalen Forum Resident

    Me neither, I've seen plenty of good reviews to albums that are poorly mastered plagued by brickwalling and overcompression, you know for the average guy, the louder the better.
     
    bru87tr likes this.
  17. lv70smusic

    lv70smusic Forum Resident

    Location:
    San Francisco, CA
    It depends on the review. It's clear from some reviews that the reviewer is knowledgeable about sound quality. Some people even mention their equipment in their reviews and draw comparisons to other releases of the same music. Granted, that's not true of the majority of reviews on Amazon but I don't dismiss them all out-of-hand.
     
  18. Postercowboy

    Postercowboy Member

    Location:
    Berlin
    Well, it is the last place in the world to look for me as well. However, if there are no other reviews, I do use it.
    As to credibility: It depends. I certainly couldn't care less about the 'Sounds great!' type of review.

    In this case, the reviewer owned both Marvin Gaye BR-As. He said he had been hesitant to buy LET'S GET IT ON, after WHAT'S GOING ON sounded so bad to him. This kind of direct comparison anybody can do. Other reviews confirmed this.

    So yes, from time to time I give Amazon customers credibility, especially when it comes to possible PROBLEMS with sound quality.

    In this case, I eventually decided against the WGO BR-A. I just found the MoFi SACD on german ebay for a reasonable price, so that's that.

    According to a couple of expert reviews on this forum, the japanese SHM-SACD apparently sounds even a little bit better. So I will have to live with the fact that I went for the second best... Not an easy thing to do for any true audiophile. ;-)
     
  19. marcb

    marcb Forum Resident

    Location:
    DC area
    The few which are remotely good are usually folks from this forum. And many of the half knowledgable ones get removed.
     

Share This Page