Best Picture Oscar Winners : The Good, The Bad and The Really?

I haven't watched Brooklyn either. I did watch Room. Brie Larson won an Oscar for her role.
What about The Revenant?

 

I liked it. Hard to watch in certain parts but I could buy an argument that it should've won that year.

 

I like The Conversation a real lot ,still its not as good as the other two

 

Kane should have won of course ,But How Green is still excellent even if it is a bit sappy

 

Actually that's my favorite from 2015. One of the best films I've ever seen.

 

It has a great print,its far from a great movie

 

How good is Chinatown?

 

don't agree ET is excellent ,Blade Runner would have been my choice ,but not the version I first saw in the Theatre ,which also had a crappy print,It is simply a better movie now in 4k

 

How Great should be the Question?

 

Okay. How great is Chinatown? I've never seen it before.

 

Like I always say: Not all film years are created equal.

Oh, and I too prefer Argo to Spotlight.

 

well to say its as Good as Godfather 2 should tell you how great it is ,all I can say is ,watch it

 

I agree.. Jack Nicholson is in top form and Faye Dunaway is at her bitchy best.

 

I've only watch Wings recently and it's amazing how they performed and filmed the flying sequences. Makes Top Gun look like a cartoon.

Thoroughly deserves the title for 'Best Picture' of 1928 (and all time).

 

Once Upon a Time in Hollywood is the winner this year. Hands down.

 

It's pretty great, IMO.

 

What film will receive most oscars ?

I nominate either Once Upon A Time in ..Hollywood or 1917.

 

I saw Blade Runner at Warner Bros. about three weeks before it hit theaters, and I said, "oh, jesus, is this thing gonna bomb." And it did. I liked it visually very much, but I think it's a downbeat film with a lot of weird plot problems and odd structure. I'm a huge Phillip K. Dick fan, but I think they changed enough from the original novel that it didn't work as well for me as a film. I don't dispute it's been extremely influential over time, and it's a beautiful film to look at. But an Oscar best picture? No way.

 

Not sure I'd say it deserved BP, but honestly, that's not a stellar roster of movies.

I actively disliked "Brooklyn" and I thought "MM:FR" was absurdly overrated, but the rest are... pretty good. There's not a single one that clearly stands above the rest to me...

 

Spielberg entered Trying Too Hard Mode in 1985. With a few exceptions, he never left!

 

Mad Max: Fury Road should have won. Time will correct that one.

 

...IT WAS AN EXCELLENT MOVIE.

 

2nd...

 

I agree...saw this at the movies and loved it...

 

are they sticking with the 8 nominees thing again this year...seems overkill.

I think the Conversation is the better of the three. and I love them all.....