Discussion in 'Music Corner' started by Bowie Fett, Sep 4, 2019.

  1. croquetlawns

    croquetlawns Forum Resident

    Glastonbury '70 would be a big draw!
  2. Logeroni_Pepperoni

    Logeroni_Pepperoni Active Member

    United States
    I wouldn't consider it wise to cherish any of Bowies CD releases, not even the holy grail RCA's. The rykos EQ suffers in the early Bowie period but it's alright from Young Americans (excluding the remixes) to Scary Monsters. Now you could say just EQ them as the Hoffman approved post recommends but not everyones got the equipment or money for that. Still despite my annoyance with the rykos lack of bass I still am trying to collect them for the sake of bonus tracks.
    warewolf95 likes this.
  3. nick jones

    nick jones Well-Known Member

    Glastonbury was in 1971 and probably Will be released next year
  4. kaztor

    kaztor How I feel when there is no coffee? Depresso.

    The EMI equivalents made up for the lack of bass with an adjusted EQ.

    Point is, back then at least an attempt seemed to have been made to present the Bowie catalogue in a logical manner, getting them back in print and kicked off by an anthology-type box set, to collect his work and be done with it.

    Everything afterwards is very haphazard.
    warewolf95 and croquetlawns like this.
  5. karmaman

    karmaman Forum Resident

    Not before shifting more copies by dressing it in the US cover for the David Bowie Is exhibition and then on sparkly coloured vinyl as a Paul Smith exclusive. They've left it too late for this to be called an admission of anything.

    The inclusion of the 2009 is more likely due to Tris Penna's involvement. He was co-mastering engineer on that and seems to be part of the current "archive team" along with long-term Bowie vault expert Kevin Cann). The 2009 at least attempted to sound like the Philips original (they're quoted as using it as their reference), so it presents a more accurate reference with which to juxtapose Visconti's remix.

    Of course it could simply be a sneaky way to justify the inclusion of two versions of the same album. 2009/2019 seems less blatant a milking exercise than 2015/2019.
  6. pommeprick

    pommeprick Member

    Does anyone have a list of official tracks missing from this box? I can see the single remakes of Free Festival and London Bye Ta Ta are being held over for the 1970 box, but there's mixes and demos still exclusive to the 40th anniversary 2CD, I think?
  7. NightGoatToCairo

    NightGoatToCairo Sheik Madeir

    Hampshire, UK
    I was under the impression the RYKO remasters were identical to the EMI counterparts?
  8. mr.datsun

    mr.datsun Incompletist

    Have they got the tapes? I heard the owner was sitting on all the '71 Glastonbury Festival tapes.
  9. followmehome

    followmehome Forum Resident

    I think some are just angry at themselves for falling for the overpriced pretendy "limited edition" boxets on an obsolete format, and the material then get released properly. No Bowie releases are really limited - the RSD releases surely saw a pressing increase.
    Smash likes this.
  10. karmaman

    karmaman Forum Resident

    here and there some bonus tracks differed in level, but i've yet to see any conclusive proof to back up these occasional claims that the EMIs beat the Rykos. i've only doubled up on a couple and they were identical.
    NightGoatToCairo and TonyCzar like this.
  11. Wilco

    Wilco Forum Resident

    Winnipeg, Manitoba
    Obsolete? What makes vinyl obsolete? Why the trolling?
    Ludger likes this.
  12. nick jones

    nick jones Well-Known Member

    Yes,they got the tapes and you can hear snippets of Changes and Quicksand in a BBC documentary
    TheLoveDrags and mr.datsun like this.
  13. JeffRougvie

    JeffRougvie Well-Known Member

    Yes, they were - we sent them all the masters. Until the 1999 re-do's - all EMI's doing.
  14. TonyCzar

    TonyCzar Forum Resident

    PhIladelphia, PA
    Like the 2-CD Anniversary editions of "Aladdin Sane" and "Diamond Dogs", I had to pick up the 2CD Space Oddity-40 edition used because, again, asleep at the switch in 2009 like I was in 2003/2004. I first learned of its existence here in the forums. I got it only this year or last from a brick and mortar place, used, but at a very reasonable price. So I would not say that "everyone" has the 2009 version. It's out of print and came out 10 years ago.

    (To paraphrase Alice in Wonderland, "Bowie albums come and go so quickly around here.")

    There's definitely some audacity in the pricing on CP. No argument there.

    I feel for the completists and fans of this era. There but for the grace of some of his stupidest songs go I. So I don't think it's appropriate to point at the people who bought the vinyl boxes and laugh. (You weren't doing that, but somebody else in one of these threads was getting a little troll-y.)
  15. NightGoatToCairo

    NightGoatToCairo Sheik Madeir

    Hampshire, UK
    Is it worth creating a poll to see who's in and who's out with Conversation Piece?
  16. edenofflowers

    edenofflowers A New Stereophonic Sound Spectacular!

    I definitely get it. There's always that panic of missing out if you don't buy it on release. It's a shame it was done this way, just a note of "from the forthcoming release 'Conversation Piece" would have saved a lot of bad feeling I think. It's a bit sneaky of them and I'm sure they knew what they were doing. It's a shame that things are changing in regards to legacy artists, it does feel as if the labels are pushing fans further than they have before with huge box-sets and sneaky shenanigans.
    gomen ne and pommeprick like this.
  17. Chris Bernhardt

    Chris Bernhardt Forum Resident

    Chicago IL
    I always preferred Ryko's Man Who Sold The World. It's the one I grew up on and to me it has the right amount of bass.
    mr.datsun and TMegginson like this.
  18. Logeroni_Pepperoni

    Logeroni_Pepperoni Active Member

    United States
    Yeah a good amount of people like that version. The regular ryko The Man Who Sold The World is alright but I can't stand the au20. Sounds like the regular ryko but louder and less bass. I like the 2015 remaster cause I like how it makes it heavy and moody sounding.
  19. nick jones

    nick jones Well-Known Member

  20. AlanDistro

    AlanDistro Forum Resident

    Sandy, OR
    I held off on the vinyl releases waiting for them to hit CD/digital. So I'm in for this, but hope the price comes down a bit before release day.
    TheLoveDrags likes this.
  21. mr.datsun

    mr.datsun Incompletist

    Yes. I saw that documentary. I wasn't sure whether they had the whole tape or not.
  22. SunSon

    SunSon Lughna

    Sea Of Holes
    I have never heard the original David Bowie album aka Space Oddity besides the title song until 3 years ago.
    As an album as a whole I like it and it could use a remix. I'd like to get Disc 5.
  23. Innocent Smith

    Innocent Smith Active Member

    I'm really excited about this as it seems quite comprehensive for 1968-69 (and I didn't buy the vinyl sets earlier this year so there's a lot of new material for me). I can only come up with a few officially released missing tracks.

    1. Space Oddity (Love You Till Tuesday Version)
    This is the only missing recording I'm aware of. And it's weird that a version of Space Oddity is missing from this set (and that it was also mysteriously missing from the deluxe edition of Bowie's 1967 album). The edit is on the Deram Anthology and the full-length version is in a couple odd places. You can get it digitally as part of the London Boy compilation. It's called a demo there, but isn't. Conversation Piece includes an unreleased alternate take from the same sessions on Disc 3 - Space Oddity (Morgan Studios version – alternative take).
    2. Wild Eyed Boy from Freecloud (Alternate album mix)
    3. Memory of a Free Festival" (Alternate album mix)

    These different mixes are both on the 2CD 40th anniversary deluxe edition.

    Otherwise, the 40th deluxe has the 1970 versions of London Bye Ta Ta, Prettiest Star, Memory of a Free Festival Parts 1 & 2, and an alternate stereo mix of London Bye Ta Ta. I expect they will all show up on next year's set with the likely exception of the London Bye Ta Ta alternate mix.

    There are also a ton of different edits of Space Oddity (which I personally don't care about) including the Visconti remix edit from earlier this year. And Space Oddity was released digitally as 8 different stems for remixing purposes in 2009. Also not my cup of tea.

    Can anybody come up with anything else missing?
  24. karmaman

    karmaman Forum Resident

    and these are rightly absent from the new box IMO. they were created by Tris Penna in 1987 while he familiarised himself with a mixing desk.
    you'd hope that basic integrity would be applied if these boxes aim to present an authentic document of a period.
    (while i understand some are looking forward to the TV remix, i personally consider its inclusion incongruous.)
    footprintsinthesand likes this.
  25. Vaughan

    Vaughan Forum Resident

    And thank goodness for that. This "Limited Edition" stuff really annoys me. We're music fans, and in 2019 should be able to get the music we want in the format we desire. It's ridiculous that an artist such as Bowie should not be out there on, say, CD and not Vinyl. Or Vinyl and not CD. Just crazy. Not only that, it's anti-consumer and anti-music lover, imo.

    I'm in for this box. In fact I'm excited for it. I love the Space Oddity album. Sure it's formative stuff, and Bowie went in a different direction, but that's what makes it so much fun. Letter to Hermoine is simply an amazing love song - perhaps Bowie's best. Janine could easily have fit on later albums, and Unwashed.. is a tour-de-force. Man, what an album.

    I've heard the demos from the Limited Editions (they were easy to find) and I enjoyed them too, but there's nothing like having your own copy. I'll get this on day of release.
    gomen ne, Ludger and TheLoveDrags like this.

Share This Page