Deserted Island Scenario - Led Zeppelin - you get three discs.....thats it!

III
IV
Houses Of The Holy

 

Tommy
Who's Next
Quadrophenia

 

The Song Remains the Same
II

 

Zeppelin IV
HOTH
Zeppelin II

 

Easy one for me this. For the sheer breadth of musical content - HotH & PG.

 

Led Zeppelin II (RL cut)
Led Zeppelin IV (Piros cut)
Houses of the Holy (RL cut)

If this island allowed for album splits, I’d be awfully tempted to substitute a record for the first LP of Physical Graffiti.

 

.....anna I.....anna II.......anna III. With apologies to Lawrence Welk.

 

Two, Three, sides 1 and 2 of Physical Graffiti

 

1,3......& I guess I got a spare!

 

Led Zeppelin I
Disc 1 of The Song Remains The Same, original issue
Led Zeppelin IV

I would really miss Ten Years Gone, but the replay in my head would be just fine

 

PG
IV

But I'd be meeting smugglers down by the seaside.

 

Physical Graffiti needs to be trimed down to a single album, Apart from Over The Hills & Far Away Houses of the Holy is a stinker. The Song Remains The Same isn't much better.
Presence sits at number 5.

I'm sure.

 

You nearly got it right.

 

There are two options for me. II, III, IV or III+The Song remains the Same.

 

I & Physical Graffiti .

 

Presence
Led Zeppelin 1
Led Zeppelin IV

 

I need Physical Graffiti, both discs. Just no getting around it.

Grrrrrrrrrrr I hate this so much ok ok ok it’s III, I guess. Physical Graffiti and III. Let’s get this over with.

 

• Physical Graffiti
• In Through the Out Door

 

II, III, Presence

 

Three discs.... ???

Led Zep I
Led Zep iv
Presence

 

II and Physical Graffiti

 

Led Zeppelin I
Led Zeppelin II
Physical Graffiti (CD1/Side A+B)

 

Another vote for I, II & III.
Easy choice, although it does suck to miss out on HOTH.

 

Physical Graffiti
Houses of the Holy

 

Zep I
Zep II
HOTH