Do you regard "Real Love" and "Free as a Bird" as real Beatles songs?

Discussion in 'Music Corner' started by Psychsound, Mar 12, 2017.

  1. MarkTheShark

    MarkTheShark Forum Resident

    Y'know, the ex-Beatles' own argument was always that if any one of them wasn't in it, there could not be a Beatles reunion, or it can't be called the Beatles -- hence the use of the Lennon demos.

    Which makes a lot of sense. John Lennon, Paul McCartney, George Harrison and Ringo Starr were the Beatles. End of story.

    And then I remember...
    [​IMG]
     
  2. videoman

    videoman Forum Resident

    Location:
    Lake Tahoe, NV
    THIS question again? Is it Monday already?
     
    bob60 likes this.
  3. johnny moondog 909

    johnny moondog 909 Beatles-Lennon & Classic rock fan

    Actually no. It's not me that you disagree with. You disagree with McCartney, Harrison, Starr, George Martin, Geoff Emerick, Yoko Ono, Apple Records, EMI, & millions & millions of fans who bought the records & watched the programs. I am merely agreeing with them.

    You agree only with a minority that certainly doesn't include the surviving Beatles, Lennon's widow, Their producer or engineer, their record company or most of their fans.

    Don't take it with me, take it up with the rest of the planet, because you're more well informed just please click the ignore button. I don't debate with people who become personally offensive.
     
    bob60 and Lewisboogie like this.
  4. Mike Visco

    Mike Visco Forum Resident

    Location:
    Newark, NJ
    I personally would have loved it, but I don't think it would have gone far, nor do I think George would have ever agreed to a full album.
     
    Lewisboogie likes this.
  5. rwil

    rwil Well-Known Member

    Location:
    Fayetteville, AR
    They'll eventually get to the bottom of it. They're so close, just a few hundred more replies and it'll be settled for the ages.
     
    vitorbastos123 and videoman like this.
  6. Buddy>Elvis

    Buddy>Elvis Forum Resident

    Location:
    New Zealand
    Nope, But not against their existence.
     
  7. HfxBob

    HfxBob Forum Resident

    Should have been a poll included with the thread. It looks like it would be about 60-40 in favor of yes.
     
  8. PIGGIES

    PIGGIES Forum Resident

    Location:
    UK
    What have Yes got to do with this thread ;)
     
  9. BeatleJay

    BeatleJay Active Member

    May I ask why? Despite my username I am quite a newbie to the inner workings of the Beatles. I do know George was the reason they didn't do more "John" songs in the 90s as he felt it was getting a bit morbid. But why would he have been against a full album of living collaborations?
     
  10. Mike Visco

    Mike Visco Forum Resident

    Location:
    Newark, NJ
    It's complicated, but there are about 100 threads here about the relationship between Paul and George. In the solo years they were like brothers socially, but like oil and water musically. I wish that wasn't the case.
     
    Lewisboogie likes this.
  11. vitorbastos123

    vitorbastos123 Forum Resident

    Settle for the month. Tops. Next May we will have another similar thread!
     
  12. electra glide

    electra glide New Member

    Location:
    NYC
    As much as we all want it to be but.....No...Hell No!
     
    PDK likes this.
  13. NothingBrightAboutIt

    NothingBrightAboutIt Forum Resident

    Location:
    Canada
    And even then, they weren't always in the best terms, Paul's "vegeterian leather jacket" being an example.
     
    Mike Visco likes this.
  14. PDK

    PDK One-eyed sparrow watcher...babe

    Location:
    Central Florida
    So where is this majority you cite? Where are the quotes the substantiate your alleged factual statements regarding the fans and family?

    Where was I "personally offensive"? Did I accuse you of drinkie winkie?"

    [​IMG]

    Peace.
     
  15. BeatleJay

    BeatleJay Active Member

    Thing is George wasn't very productive during the 90s in general sadly. I think he only released two or three songs throughout the entire decade?
     
  16. AFOS

    AFOS Forum Resident

    Location:
    Brisbane,Australia
    What's the story here?
     
  17. 200 Balloons

    200 Balloons Forum Resident

    If Lennon and McCartney were both alive and made new music without Harrison and/or Starr, I could possibly get behind that as new Beatles music. Subtract Lennon or McCartney and it doesn't matter how many of the other three are involved as far as I'm concerned.
     
  18. Mike Visco

    Mike Visco Forum Resident

    Location:
    Newark, NJ
    George was never afraid to tell the emperor he wasn't wearing clothes. Goes for him and John too.
     
    seacliffe301 likes this.
  19. white wolf

    white wolf Forum Resident

    Location:
    United States
    I not only consider them to be real BEATLES songs, but they are two of my favorite Beatles songs. I especially like the video of REAL LOVE.
     
    oxenholme likes this.
  20. Mike Visco

    Mike Visco Forum Resident

    Location:
    Newark, NJ
    George recorded over 20 songs in the 90s, several remain unreleased. Most of Brainwashed was recorded in the 90s. The 90s recordings include songs with Jools Holland, soundtrack music, Ravi Shankar collaborations and the Wilburies (Maxine, since released), maybe even 2 or 3 recorded with a guy named Paul...
     
  21. Mike Visco

    Mike Visco Forum Resident

    Location:
    Newark, NJ
    Possibly left somewhere unfinished include the rumored Paul George collab "All For Love', instrumental jams, "In Spite of All The danger" acoustic (rumored), Threetle/Jeff Lynne electric jams (rumor mentioned by several involved with Anthology), possible attempts at "Now and Then" and "Grow Old With Me".
     
  22. BDC

    BDC Forum Resident

    Location:
    Tacoma
    Without John being alive for his contributions, it can't be real Beatles. That said, I'm glad they did it. The songs IMO are decent. I think had John lived, at least him and Paul would of done something together before the 90s. Glaring to me, is how much more interesting the footage from the threetles on anthology would have been with Lennon there, both musically and in personality dynamic.
    Free as a bird and real love took a lot of balls to do and George Martin avoided it. I have mixed feelings, but I'm glad it was done.
     
    Drifter likes this.
  23. SJB

    SJB Beloved Parasitic Nuisance

    Location:
    Maryland
    Well, for one thing, some fans say it's not really Yes if Jon's not there....
     
    Drifter and PIGGIES like this.
  24. Joel Cairo

    Joel Cairo Video Gort Staff

    Location:
    Portland, Oregon
  25. A Saucerful of Scarlets

    A Saucerful of Scarlets Commenter Turned Viewer

    John hated many Beatles songs. That’s irrelevent.
     
    Seltarb and vitorbastos123 like this.

Share This Page