Discussion in 'Visual Arts' started by BeatleJWOL, Nov 6, 2019.
I will pay actual money to see this film.
the mind boggles
Wow, Vidiot, you must have REALLY disliked those prequels! Personally I'm inclined to cut Lucas a bit of slack - at least he tried to do something a bit different with them from the original/classic trilogy.
Can't disagree with you though about CGI Tarkin and Leia - they really do suck BIG time.....
They have to start someplace. I'm sure the technology is bad now, but it will improve. In 50 years, this may all be routine.
It'll be like that early '80s movie Looker, where they make digital copies of the stars in their primes and then dispose of the puny flesh and blood originals.
Never saw it. Is it good?
Well, it sounds like a dull movie that needs all the help it can get to attract viewers.
I doubt it will be that convincing. It's good marketing though.
I saw it over 30 years ago, and recall it being OK in a TV movie sort of way. Here's the Wikipedia description, which suggests my memory was a bit off (it was models being scanned and killed, but close enough): Looker - Wikipedia
Here is a ghastly CGI re-creation of Jack Lord from an episode of the new Hawaii Five O. To me, it looks like a re-animated corpse. I suspect that zombie James Dean won't look much more lively than poor old digital Jack Lord did.
I wonder how many people under 60 have even heard of James Dean. I bet the rights were cheap.
Major Disappointment: Last Night’s Memorial Concert For Tom Petty Only Had Enough Money For A Hologram Of His Foot
Yeah, that is just sad.
Indeed I did. I think they would have greatly benefitted from better writers. I think George Lucas is a great man who changed the world, particularly in the world I'm in (digital post-production for picture and sound), but story and character are not his strengths.
what in gods name......
Makes the resurrected Peter Cushing from Rogue One look like a Star Trek holodeck hologram.
its an abomination....if I didn't know I wouldn't of thought it was Jack lol, just some weird undead cyborg
Too dark to watch.
I remember watching this on TV and the scene was quite dark, possibly to obscure the implausibility of this questionable visual stunt. I couldn't find a better example of the scene on Youtube. I'll let it go at this. Will the real Jack Lord please stand up?
I'm quite mixed about this, from a technological perspective I think it's interesting enough to have a look but it is a bit weird that you're effectively casting someone to play James Dean who is playing someone else. I think this stuff makes more sense if you are using it for characters that would otherwise require re-casting or if you need to finish off their scenes. The tech is definitely getting better year after year. For the next Indiana Jones film, they could use Harrison Ford and have him play a younger version of himself perhaps in his early 50s or something. You could even remake those Doctor Who episodes that were lost and wiped if anyone could be bothered putting up the money to make it happen.
ack...go with a double or look-a-like ...that's so plastic and fake...sad times indeed!
The film Tron Legacy benefits from the same live actor being used to bring Flynn into future...revitalized Flynn is more realistic...not as bad visually...but these other current projects...ack!
They almost got Jack Lord's toupee right.
One issue which I don't see addressed that much is this:
As a species, we have several millenia of built-in perception about what is "real" and what isn't, even when we deliberately suspend disbelief.
It's like looking at an otherwise average person and 'knowing' immediately that something is very wrong with him/her...it's survival, going back to the caves.
The Uncanny Valley is when you get "close to reality" and discomfort ensues. My question is, what if it's technically perfect, will it then feel human?
Is it then possible, through a continuous onslaught of films, commercials and TV shows (and apps) to actually beat down the natural instincts of humans enough for us to enjoy a performance like this in a film without even thinking about the manipulation involved? As in: even the old lizard brain says "OK, I can fully immerse myself in the acting, the character and nothing else"?
Give it a few years. It will become indistinguishable unless you are an expert.
This Person Does Not Exist
Separate names with a comma.