Gort Gary said it'd be okay for me to run this thread as long as I didn't name names. I bought 2 Elton John CDs from an overseas seller. They were listed as being in "Very Good" shape but weren't - they had large scuffs/scratches on them. I expressed disappointment to seller and he denied there was any damage at all to CDs. Sent a picture of the marks and he said it didn't matter because the marks were on the playback side. (There are obvious scratches on playback side of CDs too, but the most blatant damage is on the front.) He said damage didn't matter because CDs played. I told him that as a collector, I want CDs in good shape and these clearly weren't "Very Good". He offered no compromise in terms of a partial refund so I pursued return through eBay's system. Then all hell broke less. He went literally crazy. This started slowly, with simple "I REFUSE THIS RETURN" emails, but Wednesday night, he went on a rampage and sent me twelve incoherent, rambling emails in a span of 12 hours. Sample: "Both CDS, you said THEY DO PLAY FINE THEY DO PLAY FINE THEY DO PLAY FINE THEY DO PLAY FINE THEY DO PLAY FINE THEY DO PLAY FINE THEY DO PLAY FINE THEY DO PLAY FINE THEY DO PLAY FINE THEY DO PLAY FINE THEY DO PLAY FINE THEY DO PLAY FINE THEY DO PLAY FINE your words... ... THEY DO PLAY FINE.. . if they do play fine, making claims that the cds, are heavily scratched, damaged, numerous scratches, massive scratches, and so forth is DECEIVING, MISLEADING, customer service people, ... ...making the impression that they don't play is just, REVOLTING.. my stomach cant stand it." I reported the harassment to eBay and they've been helpful. Today I got THIS email from him: "===TOUCH MY MONEY AND I'LL REPORT THIS TO THE POLICE==" Yeah, because police continents away are gonna go after $20 from a guy in the US! The case was supposed to "escalate" today - and the seller apparently filed a countercomplaint/claim against me last night - but I chatted with eBay today and they promised to shut it down and get me the refund. I've been on eBay for decades and never experience a seller as unhinged as this guy! Anyone else have anything like this happen to them?