Live on Saturdays: Video Reviews and Summaries

Discussion in 'Music Corner' started by riskylogic, Feb 15, 2020.

  1. mark winstanley

    mark winstanley Pick up a fast car, burn my name in the road

    I may need to check this out.
    For some reason I have always avoided it
  2. riskylogic

    riskylogic Forum Resident Thread Starter

    You really should - It's one I'd figure you on having already.
    PhoffiFozz and mark winstanley like this.
  3. riskylogic

    riskylogic Forum Resident Thread Starter

    Acoustic In Concert


    Live album by Simple Minds
    Released June 2017
    Recorded 10 November 2016 at London's Hackney Empire
    Genre Rock
    Length 79:00
    Label Eagle Rock Entertainment
    Producer Simple Minds

    Acoustic in Concert is the sixth live album by Scottish rock band Simple Minds, released in June 2017. On the eve of the Acoustic album release on 11 November 2016, Simple Minds took to the stage at London's Hackney Empire to perform a special show for the BBC's Radio 2 In Concert series. The show comprised acoustic versions of some of their greatest hits and best-loved tracks along with cover versions of some of the songs that shaped them. The album release date in June 2017 was set to coincide with the UK leg of the Acoustic Live '17 tour

    Simple Minds

    Jim Kerr – vocals
    Charlie Burchill – guitar
    Ged Grimes – bass and backing vocals
    Gordy Goudie – guitar, harmonica and backing vocals
    Cherisse Osei – percussion
    Sarah Brown – backing vocals
    Catherine Davies a.k.a. The Anchoress – backing vocals
    Steve Harley – special guest

    Track Listing
    No. Title Length
    1. "New Gold Dream (81-82-83-84)" 7:05
    2. "See the Lights" 4:52
    3. "Glittering Prize" 4:14
    4. "Stand by Love" 4:26
    5. "Waterfront" 5:47
    6. "Andy Warhol" (David Bowie cover) 3:26
    7. "Chelsea Girl" 4:23
    8. "Someone Somewhere in Summertime" 5:30
    9. "Dancing Barefoot" (Patti Smith cover) 4:01
    10. "Speed Your Love to Me" 3:47
    11. "Promised You a Miracle" 4:49
    12. "Don't You (Forget About Me)" 5:57
    13. "Sanctify Yourself" 5:49
    14. "Long Black Train" (Richard Hawley cover) 3:19
    15. "Alive and Kicking" 6:36
    16. "Make Me Smile (Come Up and See Me)" (Steve Harley & Cockney Rebel cover) 4:59

    Version Control
    Three formats carried the entire gig, including a Blu-ray, DVD and double DVD-CD package (the CD and the DVD are housed in a slimline jewel case with eight-page booklet). I have the CD-DVD combo, which was dumb – I could have gotten the bluray from Amazon for just a little more.

    The Concert
    As a result of my sloppy shopping, it’s only DVD quality – but I actually might not notice if it weren’t the fact that I’m watching right after a couple of blurays. It’s easy to tell if you pause it though – the resolution just isn’t as good. The lighting is a bit on the bright side. It has DTS in addition to Dolby Digital; that’s good enough for me. However, I will complain about the surround; there isn’t any to speak of. Just a tiny bit of reverb – those acoustic guitars should ruling the rears, but they’re not. The center channel is hardly used either. I’d probably switch it to stereo, but that is DD only.

    "New Gold Dream (81-82-83-84)"
    From New Gold Dream. After Kerr makes some introductory remarks, the concert starts off with an introduction to drummer Cherisse Osei. She plays standing up and she works very hard at it. There is a camera that shows her playing from the back; the “BBC Radio butt cam” as it were. That’s the camera that divulges that she is working the foot pedals with high-heeled shoes on, standing up!!! Eventually, the rest of the band wanders out onto the stage and they play New Gold Dream. Osei may be working very hard, but I don’t know about Kerr and Burchill. Burchill is sitting, and Kerr’s voice just isn’t as deep as it used to be.

    Since we get both a Cherisse Osei workout video and one of the better songs of the concert, it would be silly to use the clip anywhere else:

    "See the Lights"
    From Real Life. Nothing wrong with this rendition, Kerr carries the tune by himself

    "Glittering Prize"
    From New Gold Dream. The two backup singers, Brown and Davies, step in on this one – they provide the additional vocal range that Kerr can no longer deliver himself. It sounds quite different from the original, of course.

    "Stand by Love"
    From Real Life. Same story. Burchill can make his acoustic guitar sound almost electric.

    From Sparkle in the Rain. New Gold Dream and Sparkle and the twin towers of the SM catalog in my book. Lots of songs from the former, but this is the only one from the latter. I’m guessing Kerr’s voice isn’t up for it. But Brown comes in to sort of make up for it. Nice rendition.

    "Andy Warhol"
    David Bowie cover. No, this isn’t the same song as “Killing Andy Warhol” that appeared on Néapolis. Davies takes over on lead vocals. Aka “The Anchoress”, I have one of her albums. Kerr with backing vocals. A very nice rendition.

    "Chelsea Girl"
    From Life in a Day. The background vocals are terrific. For the first time, I think this is an improvement on the original. But it doesn’t sound like a Simple Minds song anymore either.

    "Someone Somewhere in Summertime"
    From New Gold Dream. Great song, but I can’t say this is an improvement.

    "Dancing Barefoot"
    Patti Smith song, covered by Simple Minds on Neon Lights. Brown on lead vocals. I think this is my favorite track on here – both Brown and the acoustic guitars sound great. Kerr conducts from the back.

    "Speed Your Love to Me"
    From New Gold Dream. Kerr is a mere shadow of his former self on this one. The backup singers to a good job of picking up the vocal slack, but it’s not the same.

    "Promised You a Miracle"
    From New Gold Dream. Brown is co-lead, and the result is nice; but compared to the original version it’s hardly recognizable.

    "Don't You (Forget About Me)"
    The big hit single. Kerr takes the mike back and all the old fogies in the audience all get up to dance for this one. The nonsurround mix is so bad that the crowd noise comes mostly from the front. La la la la la la la ugh. An all around facepalm.

    "Sanctify Yourself"
    From Once Upon a Time. This is much better; the backup singers go gospel, and it works. It doesn’t hurt that this album has a female backup singer. End of set.

    "Long Black Train"
    Richard Hawley cover. Brown co-lead. Grimes comes forward to play a string bass.

    "Alive and Kicking"
    From Once Upon a Time. Brown and Davies fill in for Robin Clark again, and the crowd joins in too.

    "Make Me Smile (Come Up and See Me)"
    Steve Harley & Cockney Rebel cover. Steve Harley comes out with an acoustic guitar, and takes the lead vocal. Kerr conducts from the back again.

    Well, in this case the answer to the question “Can they still play?” is “No, not really”. It’s the younger female musicians that make the show worth watching. The set list is pretty impressive, but these renditions generally make me want to run for the originals. The high point of the concert was a non-Simple Minds song sung by someone other than Kerr – that kind of sums it up. But I’ll take what I can get.

    Music – 2 (-1 for acoustic malarkey)
    Sound quality – 3
    Video presentation – 2 (+1 for new talent, -1 for old talent)
    Video quality – 2 (3 for bluray)
    Surround – 1
    mark winstanley likes this.
  4. mark winstanley

    mark winstanley Pick up a fast car, burn my name in the road

    For some reason the Sub always got bypassed. I have the album, but never visited the movie.
  5. Grooverider

    Grooverider Well-Known Member

    Brownsburg, IN
    I really enjoyed reading this review! I did see Porcupine Tree in a small venue in Cincinnati when they were touring “Fear of a Blank Planet”! They did that entire album with video accompaniment plus several pieces from earlier albums! It was WICKED! Since his Porcupine days, I have really appreciated Wilson’s solo projects even more! I have most of them and most of those are on vinyl! These would include “To The Bone” on a white vinyl, half speed mastered, double record 45rpm set! The sound of that is phenomenal! My favorite of his though would have to be “Hand. Cannot. Erase.”! I’m also very impressed with the Yes box set he did the remix for! They actually are better sounding than the originals and I’m very picky when it comes to Yes music! They even featured fresh new Roger Dean artwork!
    riskylogic likes this.
  6. riskylogic

    riskylogic Forum Resident Thread Starter

    Yes, I saw the FOABP tour - in Baltimore I think. There's a pretty good concert video for that too - Anesthetize. I have it, but haven't done a review for it yet. I did cover Arriving Somewhere... a few weeks ago, which is pretty awesome, especially from an audio standpoint.
    Grooverider and mark winstanley like this.
  7. mark winstanley

    mark winstanley Pick up a fast car, burn my name in the road

    U2 360° at the Rose Bowl

    Video by
    3 June 2010
    Recorded 25 October 2009
    Venue Rose Bowl (Pasadena, California)
    Genre Rock
    Length 131 minutes
    Label Mercury, Interscope
    Director Tom Krueger
    Producer Katherine Allen, Ned O'Hanlon

    U2360° at the Rose Bowl is a 2010 concert film by Irish rock band U2. It was shot on 25 October 2009 at the Rose Bowl in Pasadena, California, during the band's U2 360° Tour.[1] The Rose Bowl concert featured a sold-out crowd of 97,014 people, breaking the US record for single concert attendance for one headline act. It was live streamed over the Internet via YouTube, and was later released on DVD and Blu-ray on 3 June 2010 in the United States, 7 June in the United Kingdom, and 8 June in Canada.[2]

    Additional performers[36]
    • Terry Lawless – keyboards, programming
    1. "Get On Your Boots" 3:50
    2. "Magnificent" Bono, The Edge U2, Brian Eno, Daniel Lanois 5:35
    3. "Mysterious Ways" 4:37
    4. "Beautiful Day" 7:19
    5. "I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For" 5:38
    6. "Stuck in a Moment You Can't Get Out Of" Bono, The Edge 4:40
    7. "No Line on the Horizon" U2, Eno, Lanois 4:17
    8. "Elevation" 3:38
    9. "In a Little While" 4:00
    10. "Unknown Caller" U2, Eno, Lanois U2, Eno, Lanois 5:53
    11. "Until the End of the World" 4:56
    12. "The Unforgettable Fire" 4:45
    13. "City of Blinding Lights" 5:20
    14. "Vertigo" Bono, The Edge 4:23
    15. "I'll Go Crazy If I Don't Go Crazy Tonight" 5:25
    16. "Sunday Bloody Sunday" 6:36
    17. "MLK" 1:02
    18. "Walk On" 6:37
    19. "One" (Preceded by recorded speech by Desmond Tutu) 6:59
    20. "Amazing Grace" / "Where the Streets Have No Name" 6:59
    21. "Ultraviolet (Light My Way)" 5:14
    22. "With or Without You" 5:36
    23. "Moment of Surrender" U2, Eno, Lanois 7:38
    I don't really have much of an opening spiel here. I haven't watched this in ages. I have had the bluray for this for a long time, and I have watched it, but not for a long time.
    Thank to @GodShifter 's U2 album thread, I have had an old flame rekindled, and am discovering songs and albums that had been really, kind of ignored by me. It has been a great journey that has left me questioning myself about why I stopped with the band ... but anyway ... that's all I have for the moment, because I don't really remember much about this at all.

    It is a bluray, and it has a 5.1 track ... aside from that :shrug:

    We open with a pretty neat digital graphic, of good quality, that leads into the band entering stage.
    Get your boots on is a fairly new song for me. It comes over well and the band sound very good.
    Bono's voice is loud and clear from the centre speaker.
    They have messed something up here in the 5.1 mix though. I just referenced the stereo track to see what the deal was, and sure enough in the stereo mix , we have a nice solid bottom end, the 5.1 mix is almost bereft of bottom end, and it is a terrible shame, because for the most part they have mixed it quite well.... not amazing, but quite well, with some audio in the sides.
    We're currently on Mystetious ways, and suddenly out of nowhere some synth bass powers out of the sub ....
    Again on Beautiful Day we have a fairly empty bottom end, and then in the middle some synth bass powers out of the sub.
    Towards the end Bono sings some lines from in God's Country, and the sub has bass in it.... I wonder if it some mastering error.
    Aside from this bottom end inconsistency it sounds pretty good, and we get a pretty decent usage of the rear speakers.
    The picture quality is very good.
    Still haven't found comes over well, it has a nice Stand by Me coda with plenty of crowd involvement.
    Edge pulls out the acoustic and we get Stuck in a moment.
    No line on the horizon is also a song I am very unfamiliar with.
    That bottom end issue is terribly disappointing. Bono is in fine voice, the band are tight, the 5.1 mix is actually pretty good, but the bottom end is missing.
    The stereo sound is very good and with the 5 channel effect it sounds much better, more full in frequency range.
    So disappointing.

    This is an excellent concert, and the band are great, but the 5.1 is very disappointing, and even though the mix is good, the sound is lacking.
    If 5.1 doesn't interest you this is a great disc.

  8. riskylogic

    riskylogic Forum Resident Thread Starter

    Road Movie


    Live Performance by R.E.M.
    Released August 25, 1996
    Recorded November 18–21, 1995
    Venue The Omni, Atlanta, Georgia, United States
    Genre Alternative rock
    Length 90:00
    Label Warner Reprise Video
    Director Peter Care

    Road Movie is a documentary-style film by rock group R.E.M., released on both VHS and DVD, charting the conclusion of the band's 1995 worldwide tour in support of Monster, their album released the previous year. Directed by Peter Care, the ninety-minute effort features nineteen songs (all but one a montage) performed over the final three nights (November 18, 19 and 21) of the tour, at The Omni in Atlanta, Georgia. The set-list reads very much like a complete R.E.M. show—gigs on the Monster tour were opened by either "I Took Your Name" or "What's the Frequency, Kenneth?" (with the former taking precedence in this case), while the last song of the night was invariably "It's the End of the World as We Know It (And I Feel Fine)" (as it is here). The film is a companion piece to the Tourfilm documentary (with a synonymous title), which chronicles the band's 1989 tour on the back of the previous year's album Green.


    Bill Berry – drums, percussion, bass, vocals
    Peter Buck – guitar, bass
    Mike Mills – bass, keyboards, guitar, vocals
    Michael Stipe – lead vocals

    Additional musicians
    Amanda Brown – violin
    Nathan December – guitar
    Scott McCaughey – guitar, keyboards

    Track Listing
    All songs written by Bill Berry, Peter Buck, Mike Mills and Michael Stipe.

    1. Intro – 0:19
    2. "I Took Your Name" (unedited from the second night) – 3:56
    3. "What's the Frequency, Kenneth?" – 3:42
    4. "Crush with Eyeliner" – 4:37
    5. "Undertow" – 5:15
    6. "The Wake-Up Bomb" – 5:10
    7. "Revolution" – 3:08
    8. "Losing My Religion" – 4:47
    9. "Binky the Doormat" – 5:23
    10. "Orange Crush" – 3:55
    11. "Strange Currencies" – 4:27
    12. "Tongue" – 4:42
    13. "Man on the Moon" – 5:43
    14. "Country Feedback" – 6:21
    15. "Find the River" – 4:21
    16. "The One I Love" – 3:23
    17. "Star 69" – 3::25
    18. "Let Me In" – 4:08
    19. "Everybody Hurts" – 5:52
    20. "It's the End of the World as We Know It (And I Feel Fine)" (mostly from the final night) – 5:03

    Version Control
    This was originally released on VHS in 1996, and the following year on DVD. I have the DVD. It’s out of print, but used copies are dirt cheap.

    The Concert
    This is another one I’ve had sitting on the shelf for maybe 20 years, and I don’t remember anything about it. That’s not a good sign. The set list looks pretty good though. I’m a little worried about the documentary to concert ratio. Hopefully, there won’t be too much of the former. It’s top-notch for VHS video and stereo only. They are playing in a basketball arena; I don’t think the acoustics are very good.

    "I Took Your Name"
    From Monster. Great start; all song, no documentary. There a strobe light that’s often coming straight at the camera – that’s annoying. Berry and his drums are in back everyone else in front

    "What's the Frequency, Kenneth?"
    From Monster. Another complete song – nice. The strobe has been dialed back a bit.

    "Crush with Eyeliner"
    From Monster. Theirs is a large projection screen in back and another on the right with semi-psychedelic imagery, and another excellent complete song.

    From New Adventures in Hi-Fi. Well, I don’t like this song that much. Might be a good time for some documentary. Screen still going with barely discernable images. Nope, all song.

    "The Wake-Up Bomb"
    From New Adventures in Hi-Fi. Another decent song, and I’m beginning to think there is no documentary.

    Monster bonus track. I don’t think I’ve heard this song before; I like it.

    "Losing My Religion"
    From Out of Time. Stipe takes off his jacket because it’s time to get down to business – they are going to play my favorite song. Buck switches to banjo, Amanda Brown comes out with a violin, and the other guest musicians are playing electric and acoustic guitar. Screen is blank, no strobe at all now either.

    "Binky the Doormat"
    From New Adventures in Hi-Fi. Buck back on electric guitar, Brown still on stage with violin – other two guys gone. Screen showing flowers.

    "Orange Crush"
    From Green. Back to a foursome with major strobe action again. Great song and performance.

    "Strange Currencies"
    From Monster. Amanda Brown back out, and Buck has a banjo again. Strobes gone, xrays on the screens.

    From Monster. A reflector orb (I guess there’s a name for those things) descends down behind Stipe’s head. Mills and McCaughey both on keyboards, Buck on bass. Stipe singing with his high pitched voice.

    "Man on the Moon"
    From Automatic from the People. The foursome back to the their regular instruments, plus an extra acoustic guitarist (December, I think). Another great song.

    "Country Feedback"
    From Out of Time. The screen projectors don’t always hit the screen; seems like they go off into the audience sometimes, which must have been annoying. Anyway, we’ve got a bunch of large projected faces and a song I can’t get excited about. Mills is on keyboards, one of the other guys is on bass, along with another acoustic guitar. Buck long guitar solo.

    "Find the River"
    From Automatic from the People. Brown back with violin, and double keyboards. Buck with 12-string acoustic.

    "The One I Love"
    From Document. Yay, another rock song with an extra electric guitar – the other two guys are usually off in the dark and I can’t tell which is which.

    "Star 69"
    From Monster. There’s only the four them I think – the strobes are going again.

    "Let Me In"
    From Monster. Another one of the R.E.M. quasi-ballads that just don’t work for me. The projector is running; seems to be some welding going on; lots of orange anyway.

    "Everybody Hurts"
    From Automatic from the People. More balladeering. The screen is a study in blue this time. Amanda back with violin, and two extra guitars.

    "It's the End of the World as We Know It (And I Feel Fine)"
    From Document. Well, they end on high note – this is one of my favorites. General mayhem on the screen. One extra guitar. Berry on background vocals – usually it’s just Mills. The strobes come back.

    Well that was a pleasant surprise. I have no idea why the wiki entry describes this as a ‘documentary-style film’. It’s all concert performance, no interviews, and no nuthin else. False advertising usually works to the benefit of the seller, but in this case I don’t think it does. I didn’t like all of the songs, but that’s just the way it is with me and R.E.M. I do wish “Bang and Blame” plus something from Murmer could have been on there. The audio and video aren’t great, but still what I would expect from 1995 performance in a sports arena, and it was a pretty good show.

    Music – 2
    Sound quality – 2
    Video presentation – 3
    Video quality – 1
    Surround – 1
  9. riskylogic

    riskylogic Forum Resident Thread Starter

    Symphonic Live


    Live Performance by Yes
    Released 18 June 2002
    Recorded 22 November 2001
    Venue Heineken Music Hall, Amsterdam, Netherlands
    Genre Progressive rock, symphonic rock
    Length 194:00 (including bonus material; concert just under 150 minutes)
    Label Eagle Vision Eagle Records
    Producer Perry Joseph

    Symphonic Live is a video and live album by the English progressive rock band Yes, released on DVD and a single CD on 18 June 2002 by Eagle Vision and subsequently on two CDs and on Blu-ray by Eagle Records. The album documents the group's performance at the Heineken Music Hall in Amsterdam on 22 November 2001 during their Yessymphonic Tour, supporting their nineteenth studio album Magnification, which also featured an orchestra. The tour featured Yes performing on stage with an orchestra; Symphonic Live features the European Festival Orchestra conducted by Wilheilm Keitel.

    Keyboardist Rick Wakeman was invited by the band to perform at this concert, but this did not happen because of scheduling conflicts. In his place was Tom Brislin.


    Jon Anderson – vocals, acoustic guitar, percussion
    Steve Howe – guitars, lap steel guitar, backing vocals
    Chris Squire – bass guitar, backing vocals, harmonica, percussion
    Alan White – drums, backing vocals, keyboards

    Additional musicians
    Tom Brislin – keyboards, backing vocals, percussion
    European Festival Orchestra, Wilhelm Keitel – conductor

    Perry Joseph – producer
    Aubrey Powell – director
    Bob Cesca – digital artwork

    Track Listing
    No. Title Writer(s) Length
    1. "Overture" 2:30
    2. "Close to the Edge" Jon Anderson, Chris Squire, Bill Bruford, Steve Howe, Rick Wakeman 20:30
    3. ""Long Distance Runaround" Anderson, Squire, Bruford, Howe, Wakeman 5:29
    4. "Don't Go" Anderson, Howe, Squire, Alan White 4:29
    5. "In the Presence Of" Anderson, Squire, Howe, White 11:04
    6. "The Gates of Delirium" Anderson, Howe, Squire, White, Patrick Moraz 23:30
    7. " Lute Concerto in D, 2nd Movement/ Mood for a Day" Vivaldi (arr. Howe), Howe 6:26
    8. "Starship Trooper” Anderson, Howe, Squire 12:18
    9. "Magnification" Anderson, Howe, Squire, White 7:23
    10. "And You and I" Anderson, Bruford, Howe, Squire, Wakeman 11:16
    11. ""Ritual (Nous Sommes du Soleil)" Anderson, Howe, Squire, White, Wakeman 28:21
    12. "I've Seen All Good People" Anderson, Squire 7:21
    13. "Owner of a Lonely Heart" Trevor Rabin, Trevor Horn, Squire, Anderson 5:49
    14. "Roundabout" Anderson, Squire, Bruford, Howe, Wakeman

    Version Control
    There are many versions of this. The bluray I have was released in 2011; it seems to be out of print and a little pricey, but the DVD is still available new.

    The Concert
    I have had this for a while, and I already know it’s awesome. The picture and sound quality are great and so is the music and the show. The only minor let down is the surround which is very good but not exceptional; Anderson gets the center channel and the rear channels get lots of action especially from the orchestra, but there is no discrete mixing to the back.

    I have no idea what the European Festival Orchestra is or was. A google search turned up a facebook page for a German outfit, but it doesn’t seem to be the same. I’m thinking it’s basically a group of music students who were brought together for the concert who are having the time of their lives. The lead cellist seems to be the favorite target of the camera. They look pretty young for the most part - their average age must be about half that of the Yes band members. OTOH, the guest keyboardist, Tom Brislin,is closer to their age. He has also played with Camel, and is now a member of Kansas.

    The concert is part of a tour for the Magnification album; three tracks are from that. The rest of the songs are stone cold classics.

    Starts out with animation; presumably with a soundtrack delivered by the orchestra.

    "Close to the Edge"
    From Close to the Edge. They start off with the shortest of the three 20+ min songs. Howe, Anderson, and Squire are in front, Brislin amd White are behind them, and then the orchestra is at the back of the stage. There are some animated sequences spliced in; not from Roger Dean I don’t think, but in the same ballpark. Seems to feature a fleet of alien ships that make crop circles. Anyway, the back speakers are dominated by strings and horns. Anderson has a battery of instruments – chimes, other percussion, and a keyboard that he plays when not singing. Spends a lot of time with the chimes on CTTE. Brislin does a fine job of subbing for Wakeman. Sounds fantastic.

    “Long Distance Runaround"
    From Fragile. The orchestra starts it off. The band comes in after about a minute, Howe’s acoustic guitar gets a little play in the back along with the strings and horns.

    "Don't Go"
    From Magnification. A short poppy song that they got too much in the habit of making. But, I like this one; it’s over soon enough. An animated care takes a trip across the screen, which seems silly and out of place. Brief used of split screen. I’d characterize the use of the back as mostly reverb.

    "In the Presence Of"
    From Magnification. A longer semi-epic piece from the new album. Starts off with Alan White on Jon’s keyboards, but he quickly moves back to his drum set. How starts off with acoustic guitar – he must play something like 10 different guitars during the course of the concert. Squire gets by with just one bass guitar. Jon picks up his one and only guitar too. The crop circlers make another appearance. Strings plus some guitar reverb from Howe’s pedal steel slide guitar in the back. The violinists get a chance to do some plucking.

    "The Gates of Delirium"
    Well this is just freaking awesome. The song takes up the entire first side of Relayer is awesome anyway, but with an orchestra backup it’s sublime. It’s an antiwar song, and there is a bunch of WWI video and WWII animation spliced in that I could do without, but that’s a minor complaint.

    It’s on Youtube in three parts, here is 2:

    " Lute Concerto in D, 2nd Movement/ Mood for a Day"
    Steve Howe plays solo. The second song is from Fragile.

    "Starship Trooper”
    From The Yes Album. The band is back, but the orchestra is still taking a break – which means the rears need something else to do: Background vocals and crowd clapping in the rear. Squire with fantastic solo. Howe takes over and the Orchestra come back.

    From Magnification. Jon Anderson has a guitar. Some animation superimposed over the concert video.

    10. "And You and I"
    From Close to the Edge. Starts with computer animated figure with a soundtrack provided by Howe at first and then with the rest of the band. Lots of guitar reverb in the back. Eventually we get back to the concert and the orchestra starts up too. The figure pops back in occasionally afterward.

    “Ritual (Nous Sommes du Soleil)"
    From Tales from Topographic Oceans. OK, now for the last epic. But this isn’t just the regular epic, it’s an extended 28 minute version that never would have fit on one side of an LP. Chimes from both Anderson and the orchestra. Strings and background vocals in the back. Brislin seems to be getting some of the vocal parts that Howe normally takes. Both Howe and Squire get a workout – there’s an extended jamb from Squire that accounts for a good chunk of the extra length. The stage crew bring out some extra drums for Brislin, Anderson, and Squire to play during the percussion heavy segment that largely features Alan White; horns and percussion from the orchestra in the back. After another round of singing, Anderson finished with a guitar in his hand, and we’ve got Howe reverb and strings in the back. This is also glorious.

    "I've Seen All Good People"
    From Fragile. Starts out acappela, with all vocals in front. Then Howe has a mandolin, left front, keyboards far left (a bit to the back), Squire vocals continue on right. Drums, bass, and orchestra come in eventually, and Howe switches to acoustic guitar; hornes, strings, and guitar reverb in back. Then another round of mostly acapella followed by a very brief full band and orchestra finale. End of set.

    "Owner of a Lonely Heart"
    From 90125. Steve Howe starts it off. I think it was this song made him want to go off and start Asia. Brislin with backing vocals along with Squire, and he gets a solo. No orchestra and the back is pretty much silent.

    From Fragile. Howe starts it off again. The orchestra comes out to the front, between first and second rows, to dance. The girls are all in the middle and get most of the camera love. Just a little reverb in the back. A big wind down, and that’s it.

    This disc goes a long way towards removing the sting of the disappointment of Yessongs. It’s only 2001, so they’re not all the way over the hill yet, and they’ve got an orchestra, and yet we still get a bluray with DTS-MA. It’s also true that they had to sub in a new keyboard player for Kaye, Wakeman, Moraz et al. But if you are searching for a modern disc from a prog rock legend with as few compromises as possible, this one is pretty hard to beat. If you don’t have time to sit through the entire two and a half hour concert, just spending 73 minutes with the three long tracks is not a bad way to go.

    Music – 3
    Sound quality – 3
    Video presentation – 3
    Video quality – 3
    Surround – 2
  10. Åke Bergvall

    Åke Bergvall Forum Resident

    Karlstad, Sweden
    R.E.M.'s Road Movie is also part of the Blu-ray in the recent Monster package. The audio has not been remixed into Hi-res as far as I can tell, so it will sound (and look) the same as on the DVD.
    Last edited: May 17, 2020
    riskylogic likes this.
  11. Grooverider

    Grooverider Well-Known Member

    Brownsburg, IN
    Indeed! I have both of those videos and they are awesome! I have nearly all of the PT albums! I have “Fear” on CD, Vinyl and 5.1 audio! For a while I was quite the Steve Wilson fanatic collecting and listening to his stuff every day! Still love it but exploring new (to me) stuff now.
    riskylogic likes this.
  12. riskylogic

    riskylogic Forum Resident Thread Starter



    Live Performance by Alison Krauss & Union Station
    Released November 5, 2002 (CD); DVD released in 2003
    Recorded April 29, 2002 & April 30, 2002
    Venue The Louisville Palace, Louisville, Kentucky
    Genre Bluegrass
    Length 100:30
    Label Rounder
    Producer Alison Krauss & Union Station

    Live is the eleventh album and the first live album by Alison Krauss and Union Station. All of the songs except "Down to the River to Pray" (performed at Austin City Limits) were recorded at The Louisville Palace on April 29–30, 2002.

    Alison Krauss - Vocals, fiddle
    Jerry Douglas - Resonator guitar, vocals
    Dan Tyminski - Guitar, mandolin, vocals
    Ron Block - Guitar, banjo, vocals
    Barry Bales - Bass, vocals
    Larry Atamanuik - Drums

    Track Listing
    1. Let Me Touch You For Awhile
    2. Choctaw Hayride
    3. The Lucky One
    4. Baby, Now That I've Found You
    5. Bright Sunny South
    6. Every Time You Say Goodbye
    7. Tiny Broken Heart
    8. Cluck Old Hen
    9. Stay
    10. Broadway
    11. Ghost In This House
    12. Forget About It
    13. Faraway Land
    14. A Tribute To Peador O'Donnell/Monkey Let The Hogs Out
    15. The Boy Who Wouldn't Hoe Corn
    16. Take Me For Longing
    17. I Am A Man Of Constant Sorrow
    18. Maybe
    19. We Hide & Seek
    20. But You Know I Love You
    21. When You Say Nothing At All
    22. New Favorite
    23. Oh, Atlanta

    Version Control
    This is available as a double CD, a two DVD set with extra bonus material, and a 2CD+DVD set. The latter is still available new. I have the two DVD set.

    The Concert
    Even though the opening screen looks a little fuzzy, once the concert starts up it seems to be normal video quality for a modern DVD. It also has DTS surround – which as good as a DVD gets. The concert was performed just after the release of New Favorite – they play just about every song off the album.

    “Let Me Touch You For Awhile”
    From New Favorite. We’ve got Douglas, Krauss, Tyminski, and Block lined up in front, standing on a carpet laid on the stage, wit a couple of standing lamps in the back – going for the living room look, I suppose. Bales is hanging out in back with the drum set no one is using yet. The theater is a piece of work. It’s got Greco-Roman sculpture lining the walls, gothic facades, and the ceiling has blue lighting that makes it seem like it’s outdoors.

    Douglas is playing dobro; which I’d characterize as a lap guitar that lays flat, but is played standing up. Tyminski and Block have acoustic guitars. Krauss has a violin, but she mostly just sings real good.

    However, let’s scratch surround – nothing from the center channel, and the rears have crowd noise and only a tiny bit of reverb.

    “Choctaw Hayride”
    From New Favorite. Krauss just plays violin, Block switches to banjo. An instrumental with Tyminski as lead.

    “The Lucky One”
    From New Favorite. Back to three guitars and Krauss singing.

    “Baby, Now That I've Found You”
    A The Foundations cover, appears on an AK & US compilation. Krauss lead vocals, Tyminski backing.

    “Bright Sunny South”
    From New Favorite. Tyminski lead vocals, Block on banjo.

    “Every Time You Say Goodbye”
    From Every Time You Say Goodbye. Krauss back on lead, Block still with banjo.

    “Tiny Broken Heart”
    Cover of 1956 song not on any previous albums. Tyminski lead vocals, Bales backing.

    “Cluck Old Hen”
    From Every Time You Say Goodbye. Instrumental, Krauss serious with the violin for the first time.

    From Forget About It. Now we find out what the drum set is for – Atamanuik comes out. Krauss on vocals, Block leads with acoustic guitar; Tyminski with a mini guitar of some sort and backing vocals.

    Cover found on Now That I've Found You. Krauss still lead vocals, Tymiski backing and normal acoustic guitar.

    “Ghost In This House”
    From Forget About It. Slow ballad, Krauss lead vocals, Tyminski and Bales backing,

    “Forget About It”
    Cover from Forget About It. Krauss still singing, Tyminski backing vocals and his mini guitar again, maybe it’s a mandolin; sounds like it. I’m going to call it a mandolin whether it is or not.

    “Faraway Land”
    From Ron Block solo album. Block lead guitar and vocals, Tyminski with mandolin. Krauss plays violin.

    “A Tribute To Peador O'Donnell/Monkey Let The Hogs Out”
    It’s Douglas’ turn to take the stage, he plays two traditional tunes solo on one of his dobros.

    “The Boy Who Wouldn't Hoe Corn”
    From New Favorite. This is a song that has lyrics, but it seems that Douglas is playing it as a solo instrumental. No wait, Dan Tyminski comes out to sing, and then the rest of the band comes out too – well except for the drummer.

    “Take Me For Longing”
    From New Favorite. The band segues straight in to this one, which has Krauss on lead. This is a nice representative twofer:

    “I Am A Man Of Constant Sorrow’
    Union Station are the Soggy Bottom Boys – this is from O Brother Where Art Thou? Tyminski sings while Krauss gets a few licks in with her violin too.

    From Forget About It. After Krauss gives Bales a hard time, she sings another ballad. The drummer is back, and Tyminski has the mandolin.

    “We Hide & Seek”
    Instrumental piece; Tyminski leads off with the mandolin, Block has a banjo, and Krauss is busy with the violin. There’s a whole lotta pickin goin on.

    “But You Know I Love You”
    Kenny Rogers cover. Krauss lead vocals, Tyminski and Block backing. Not very bluegrassy.

    “When You Say Nothing At All”
    From an Allison Krauss solo album. Slow song; Krauss vocals, Tyminski lead guitar.

    “New Favorite”
    From New Favorite. A very pretty slow song. Krauss vocals, more drums than usual, and really nice dobro work from Douglas.

    “Oh, Atlanta”
    A Bad Company song covered on Now That I've Found You. A southern rock song, Atamanuik goes wild. No, not really. But still, this is as close as they going to get to a rock song; with a bluesy guitar solo from Block.

    "Down to the River to Pray"
    Plays during the closing credits, I think this is taken from the O Brother Where Art Thou? soundtrack.

    This is off my beaten path, but I still like it a lot. There isn’t very much else in my music collection that has even a tinge of bluegrass. Ozark Mountain Daredevils comes to mind; I’ve got lots of that. I’ve got compilations for Charlie Daniels and Marshall Tucker, but that's a stretch perhaps. Then bluegrass has some overlap with English and Irish folk, and I have a bunch of that, albeit usually played with electric guitars. The big show in the concert is that Krauss has lots of stories to tell. Many of the chapters on the DVD are taken up just by her telling a story, usually about one of her bandmates. It’s a very enjoyable show even if you’re only casually interested in bluegrass. Seems like the acoustic guitars would sound a little better with surround though.

    Music – 2 (that is as high as bluegrass gets on my scale)
    Sound quality – 3
    Video presentation – 3 (+1 for exceptional banter)
    Video quality – 2
    Surround – 1
    Last edited: May 23, 2020
    weekendtoy and mark winstanley like this.
  13. riskylogic

    riskylogic Forum Resident Thread Starter

    Vehicle of Spirit


    Live Performance by Nightwish
    Released December 16, 2016 (Europe) / January 6, 2017 (North America)
    Recorded July 31, 2015 at Ratina Stadion, Tampere, Finland
    December 19, 2015 at Wembley Arena, London
    Length 181:06
    Label Nuclear Blast

    Vehicle of Spirit is a video and audio release from Finnish symphonic metal band Nightwish that features two shows recorded during the Endless Forms Most Beautiful World Tour. It also includes various other songs recorded around the world.

    Floor Jansen – female vocals
    Tuomas Holopainen – keyboards
    Emppu Vuorinen – guitars
    Kai Hahto – drums
    Marco Hietala – bass, male vocals
    Troy Donockley – Uilleann pipes, tin whistle, bouzouki, additional vocals, additional guitars

    Track Listing

    The Wembley Show
    No. Title Lyrics Music Length
    1. "Shudder Before the Beautiful" Tuomas Holopainen Holopainen 6:58
    2. "Yours Is an Empty Hope" Marco Hietala · Holopainen Holopainen · Hietala 5:47
    3. "Ever Dream" Holopainen Holopainen 5:10
    4. "Storytime" Holopainen Holopainen 4:52
    5. "My Walden" Holopainen Holopainen · Hietala 5:15
    6. "While Your Lips Are Still Red" Holopainen Holopainen · Hietala 5:05
    7. "Élan" Holopainen Holopainen 4:27
    8. "Weak Fantasy" Hietala · Holopainen Holopainen · Hietala 6:19
    9. "7 Days to the Wolves" Holopainen Hietala · Holopainen 7:16
    10. "Alpenglow" Holopainen Holopainen 4:56
    11. "The Poet and the Pendulum" Holopainen Holopainen 14:00
    12. "Nemo" Holopainen Holopainen 4:53
    13. "I Want My Tears Back" Holopainen Holopainen 7:13
    14. "Stargazers" Holopainen Holopainen 5:11
    15. "Ghost Love Score" Holopainen Holopainen 10:36
    16. "Last Ride of the Day" Holopainen Holopainen 4:58
    17. "The Greatest Show on Earth" (feat. Richard Dawkins) Holopainen Hietala · Holopainen 22:37

    The Tampere Show
    No. Title Lyrics Music Length
    1. "Shudder Before the Beautiful" Holopainen Holopainen 7:05
    2. "Yours Is an Empty Hope" Hietala · Holopainen Holopainen · Hietala 5:41
    3. "Amaranth" Holopainen Holopainen 4:24
    4. "She Is My Sin" Holopainen Holopainen 5:11
    5. "Dark Chest of Wonders" Holopainen Holopainen 4:36
    6. "My Walden" Holopainen Holopainen · Hietala 5:08
    7. "The Islander" Holopainen Hietala 5:55
    8. "Élan" Holopainen Holopainen 4:27
    9. "Weak Fantasy" Hietala · Holopainen Holopainen · Hietala 6:23
    10. "Storytime" Holopainen Holopainen 5:47
    11. "Endless Forms Most Beautiful" Holopainen Holopainen 5:10
    12. "Alpenglow" Holopainen Holopainen 5:03
    13. "Stargazers" Holopainen Holopainen 5:10
    14. "Sleeping Sun" Holopainen Holopainen 4:45
    15. "Ghost Love Score" Holopainen Holopainen 10:41
    16. "Last Ride of the Day" Holopainen Holopainen 4:54
    17. "The Greatest Show on Earth" Holopainen Holopainen · Hietala 20:55

    Version Control
    The two-disc set is available on both DVD and Bluray. Amazon. I have the 2-bluray European version. The dimensions of the bluray set I have is different from anything else in my collection, which is a bit annoying.

    The Concerts
    Since the majority of the songs are the same, I am just going to run through the Wembley concert in it’s entirety. I will also cover the six songs from the Tampere concert that are different.

    It’s got PCM surround, how cool is that? The video is a little grainy for a bluray, but I guess it’s still better than a good DVD.


    "Shudder Before the Beautiful"
    Main vocalists Hietala (also plays bass) and Jansen are front center. Guitarist Vuorinen is also in front, and he roams around. In the rear from left to right, it’s Holopainen on keyboards, Hahto a little further back on drums, and multinstrumentalist Donockley. It’s a large stadium and it’s pretty packed. Lots of blue spotlights from behind as we start out.

    The first song is from the 2015 album Endless Forms Most Beautiful. By that time Nightwish were (and are) best classified as symphonic metal, which means that Holopainen is doing his best to imitate and orchestra using synthesizers, and everyone else is playing as fast as they can. Jansen is lead. Surroundwise, , there’s a wall of sound in front that utilized the front channel, and the reverb in the back is dominated by guitar and synth.

    "Yours Is an Empty Hope"
    From Endless Forms Most Beautiful. A head banger with Hietala as lead. Jansen backing vocals and hair twirling. The spotlights are supplemented by flame throwers. Not a very catchy tune really.

    "Ever Dream"
    From Century Child. Jansen starts off with a melody and the crowd sings along in the back. They’re pretty good actually, but Floor is better.

    From Imaginaerum. The light behind the stage go off, and a large screen that backs the entire stage comes on, and there’s a rather impressive video show going on behind the band. More singing from the crowd – they are giving the rear speakers a good reason to be there.

    "My Walden"
    From Endless Forms Most Beautiful. A Celtic ballad; Donockley introduces the song and starts off on vocals, before switching to his Uilleann pipes. The screen is showing North Sea coastline I reckon, there’s a windmill in there too; I guess because Floor is Dutch. She and Donockley are both new members of the band; the rest are all Finnish.

    "While Your Lips Are Still Red"
    From Amaranth EP. Hietala leads off with Holopainen piano, then Donockley on guitar, Jansen backing. Winter scenery on the screen.

    From Endless Forms Most Beautiful. Another Celtic-tinged tune. There’s a blatant Ayreon ripoff of Nightwish Celtery, also featuring Jansen, on The Source. Donockley with tin whistle.

    "Weak Fantasy"
    From Endless Forms Most Beautiful. Another symphonic head banger. Hahto starts it off. Floor loses her leather jacket and shows off her tattoos. Donockley with bouzouki.

    "7 Days to the Wolves"
    From Dark Passion Play. There’s a folk ballad in there somewhere behind the wall of sound. I wonder if Floor has to do any special workout exercises to do all that hair whirling.

    From Endless Forms Most Beautiful. More Celtery; sort of a cross between Enya and Rush.

    "The Poet and the Pendulum"
    From Dark Passion Play. A heavy metal opera starring Floor. Has several quiet interludes where Holopainen demonstrates his ability to emulate an orchestra with more than a little keyboard programming I imagine. Jansen shows off the upper part of her immense vocal range. Donockley sits this one out. The screen show has a pendulum theme.

    From Once. Opera over, Holopainen leads off a mere song for Floor to sing. Donockley is back to play whistle.

    "I Want My Tears Back"
    From Imaginaerum. Donockley on pipes. Hietala colead vocals with Jansen. The flame throwers are back.

    From Oceanborn. Floor is third vocalist for Nightwish. I haven’t heard the original version of this early song, but I guessing the first vocalist was a soprano because Jansen singing way up high again.

    "Ghost Love Score"
    From Once. Another mini-opera with lots of pseudo-orchestral interludes. Floor and everything else goes up in smoke and flames at the end. Flames on the screen, the flame throwers are running again, and there’s a smoke machine:

    "Last Ride of the Day"
    From Imaginaerum. A roller coaster ride on the screen with a soundtrack to go with it.

    "The Greatest Show on Earth"
    From Endless Forms Most Beautiful. Is this the first prog metal epic? It’s the only 20+ minute example I know of, but then I’m not really an expert. Lots of work from Donockley, and the rest of the band too as usual. Narration from Richard Dawkins, and Jansen does a little narration too; she sings relatively little on this. The screen gives some visual lessons in evolutionary biology. Since the end is all programmed, the band can take their bows while the song finishes up with live narration from Richard Dawkins (I imagine this is usually taped). It was a great show anyway.


    From Dark Passion Play. This concert from earlier in the tour is also in a packed stadium, but there’s a few empty seats. It’s “nightime”, but it’s also Finland in July so it’s still broad daylight. Floor speaks a little Finnish. She has a similar outfit design as at Wembley, But it’s Finnish blue and white instead of all black, plus she’s got some blue facepaint. Besides the screens behind the stage, there are two large vertical screens on either side of the screen, showing band members; mostly Jansen.

    This third song is warmup headbanger, also with some audience participation. Absolutely nothing in the rear speakers. Wait, why was I so enthused about the PCM surround?

    "She Is My Sin"
    From Wishmaster. Fast-paced metal with Jansen’s soaring vocals.

    "Dark Chest of Wonders"
    From Once. Hietala introduces the song in Finnish, but we’ve got subtitles. More symphonic that the two previous older songs. None of the video on these songs have been as impressive as they were at the full Wembley concert. The fact that it is daytime doesn’t help.

    "The Islander"
    From Dark Passion Play. This breaks up “My Walden” and “Elan” instead “While Your Lips are Still Red”. There a secondary stage protruding into the crowd (e.g. like Secret Word Live) and Hietala is out there by himself. He introduces the song in Finnish and then sings the solo piece in English while playing the guitar part of his double necked beast. Hahto, Jansen, Donockley and eventually come back out on the main stage to help.

    "Endless Forms Most Beautiful"
    From Endless Forms Most Beautiful. Kinda weird this one got left out of the Wembley concert. It’s relatively short but still combines all the elements that make Nightwish exceptional.

    "Sleeping Sun"
    From Angels Fall First. Jansen goes out on the runway near the end of the concert as it’s starting to get dark. This is an early song, and Floor is a soprano. The screen is showing stars.

    I don’t know if I need any more Nightwish concert videos, but I’m glad to have one. Even 90 minutes of this stuff is a lot to take in one sitting. There’s a newer one that has more of their earlier stuff, but I think I like the emphasis on Endless Forms. Both shows are visually spectacular, but the Wembley one is better. The title track from Endless is the main bennie of the second disc. The center channel is used to bolster the wall of sound in front, and there is a little reverb in the back and some crowd vocals in surround on a couple songs in the first disc, but don’t really think that is worth a point – it sounds pretty much the same in stereo.

    Music – 2
    Sound quality – 3
    Video presentation – 3
    Video quality – 3
    Surround – 1

    They have a new album out that I just ordered, along with a video version of Imaginaerum that I figure on reviewing on this thread at some point.
    mark winstanley likes this.
  14. mark winstanley

    mark winstanley Pick up a fast car, burn my name in the road

    So I ended up getting this. I am certainly a fan of the Church.
    The Church were somewhat an oddity when they came out at the turn of 1980. The Aus music scene was dominated by hard rock, and particularly pub rock, and the Church had a sort of retro-pop thing going on.
    Survival in the Aus music scene was dependent on being a good draw at the pubs, by being a very good live band. During the seventies and eighties Aus had some of the best live bands in the world because of this.... sadly the live venues were starting to dry up by the nineties.....

    Here we get the band covering three specific albums.
    I think their grounding in the Aus live scene shows, and we get very good tight renditions of all the material.
    Very enjoyable set.
    Thanks for the heads up Risky!
    riskylogic likes this.
  15. riskylogic

    riskylogic Forum Resident Thread Starter

    New Blood - Live In London


    Live Performance by Peter Gabriel
    Released 21 Oct 2011
    Recorded 23–24 March 2011
    Venue Hammersmith Apollo, London
    Genre Symphonic rock
    Length 141:14
    Label Real World/Virgin
    Director – John Metcalfe
    Producer – Peter Gabriel

    Live Blood is a live album and video by the English rock musician Peter Gabriel. Recorded at the HMV Hammersmith Apollo, London on 23 and 24 March 2011, the concert featured Gabriel singing with the New Blood Orchestra and vocalists Ane Brun, Melanie Gabriel, Sevara Nazarkhan and Tom Cawley.

    The setlist included songs from his previous orchestral covers album Scratch My Back and new orchestral arrangements of his solo songs, most of which went on to appear on the studio album New Blood. A single CD version of Live Blood formed part of the New Blood Deluxe Edition DVD released in 2011. The concerts were filmed in 3D.

    The orchestral versions were arranged by John Metcalfe with Peter Gabriel except "Signal To Noise" which was arranged by Peter Gabriel and Will Gregory and "The Book of Love", which was arranged by Nick Ingman. The songs were conducted by Ben Foster, who is best known for his work on the BBC science fiction series Doctor Who, except "In Your Eyes" which was conducted by John Metcalfe.

    Bass Clarinet – Jon Carnac
    Bassoon – Sarah Burnett
    Celesta – John Metcalfe
    Cello – Caroline Dale, Chris Worsey, Ian Burdge, Jacqueline Thomas, Nick Roberts
    Cello [Principal] – Will Schofield*
    Clarinet – Jon Carnac
    Concertmaster – Louisa Fuller
    Conductor – Ben Foster (tracks: 1-19, 21-22), John Metcalfe (tracks: 20)
    Double Bass – Ben Russell, Richard Pryce, Steve Rossell
    Double Bass [Principal] – Chris Laurence
    Flute – Eliza Marshall
    French Horn – Phil Woods
    French Horn [Principal] – Nigel Black
    Oboe – Alun Darbyshire
    Percussion – Joby Burgess, John Metcalfe, Rob Farrer
    Piano – Tom Crowley
    Piccolo Flute – Eliza Marshall
    Trombone – Dan Jenkins, Mark Frost
    Trombone [Principal] – Tracy Holloway
    Trumpet – Dan Newell*
    Trumpet [Principal] – Andy Crowley
    Tuba – David Powell
    Viola – Helen Kamminga, Ian Rathbone, Jon Thorne (3), Paul Cassidy, Reiad Chibah
    Viola [Principal] – Fiona Bonds
    Violin – Alison Dods, Cathy Thompson, Charles Mutter, Clare Hayes, Debbie Widdup, Emma Parker, Ian Belton, Ian Humphries, Jeremy Morris, Kathy Shave, Natalia Bonner, Odile Ollagnon, Rita Manning, Roland Roberts
    Violin [Principal] – Martin Burgess
    Vocals – Ane Brun , Melanie Gabriel, Peter Gabriel, Sevara Nazarkhan (track 20)

    Track Listing
    # Title Length
    1. "Intruder" 5:59
    2. "Wallflower" 7:29
    3. "The Boy in the Bubble" (written by Paul Simon & Forere Motloheloa) 4:35
    4. "Après Moi" (written by Regina Spektor) 5:16
    5. "The Drop" 2:58
    6. "Washing of the Water" 4:20
    7. "The Book of Love" (written by Stephin Merritt) 3:54
    8. "Darkness" 6:34
    9. "The Power of the Heart" (written by Lou Reed) 6:36
    10. "Biko" Peter Gabriel 3 (Melt) 6:54
    11. "San Jacinto" 7:44
    12. "Digging in the Dirt" 6:01
    13. "Signal to Noise" 8:46
    14. "Downside Up" 6:29
    15. "Mercy Street" 6:47
    16. "The Rhythm of the Heat" 6:54
    17. "Blood of Eden" 6:31
    18. "Red Rain" 7:11
    19. "Solsbury Hill" 6:15
    20. "In Your Eyes" 8:27
    21. "Don’t Give Up" 8:32
    22. "The Nest that Sailed the Sky" 6:48

    Version Control
    Many versions of this were released at the outset – there’s a CD, a DVD, a bluray, a 3D bluray, and various combo sets. I have the bluray, which I bought in February for under $10. However, apparently quarantine demand has driven the current price up to more like $15. Amazon.

    The Concert
    The video and audio quality are both great. We’ve got the orchestra in back, Gabriel is front and a bit to left. The other two vocalists on the right and they sing facing Gabriel rather than the audience, which seems odd, but I guess they’re the choir. Over on the far right is Tim Crowley on a piano.

    I’ve got lots of rock concerts with backing orchestras or string sections, but that’s not what this is. It’s just an Orchestra with three vocalists and a piano. Basically NOT a rock concert.

    From Peter Gabriel 3 (Melt). Gabriel, Brun, and Melanie Gabriel walk out onto the stage while the orchestra starts up. They are playing a modern score, that you wouldn’t recognize as the song were it not for the fact that Gabriel comes out and starts singing.

    There are a large horizontal in screen in front of the stage that doubles as the curtain, plus one large screen above and behind the orchestra.

    For surround, Gabriel is in the center channel and the orchestra is mostly in front, but there is a little reverb in the back. Brun and Melanie are mixed left and right (not sure which is which) and partly to the rear – so often only their voices are heard in the rear speakers.

    From Peter Gabriel 4 (Security). Crowley leads of on piano, and the orchestra plays a much more subdued and melodic score than on the first song. After spending most of the song singing in unison with Gabriel, Brun and Melanie sing a chorus by themselves

    "The Boy in the Bubble"
    From Scratch My Back. Paul Simon cover. Gabriel’s last album was a cover album, where all of the songs were written by other artists. Supposedly there was going to be another album where the same artists were going to do Gabriel songs, but it never happened. That sort explains this concert though – not only is he doing cover versions of his own songs, he’s doing covers of the covers that he did on Scratch My Back. Anyway, Gabriel sings this one solo, with accompaniment from piano and a few woodwinds.

    "Après Moi"
    From Scratch My Back. Regina Spektor cover. Brun and Melanie are back and the orchestra is busier this time, mostly strings.

    "The Drop”
    From Up. Back to his own material. Starts out with Gabriel and woodwinds. Brun and Melanie chip in briefly.

    "Washing of the Water"
    From Us. Gabriel and strings this time. Melanie sings the female part of the song on her own, without Brun. She comes from the center channel instead of one of the sides. The back screen has been showing abstract shapes up to this point, but on this song it shows the faces of both Gabriels while they are singing. The one large screen in split into three separate fields.

    "The Book of Love"
    From Scratch My Back. A Magnetic Fields cover. Just strings from the orchestra, and still just Melanie. The back screen and front screens have coordinated graphics for the first time, which produces some 3D imagery; I think some of it may be added during video editing.

    From Up. Horns, woodwinds, and strings, and they get a little punchy. Brun comes back, and she and Melanie are singing from the sides again.

    "The Power of the Heart"
    From Scratch My Back. Lou Reed cover. Gabriel starts out with piano, horns come in, then strings. No backing vocals.

    From Peter Gabriel 3 (Melt). Starts out with string bass and single drum, then all three vocalists, then woodwinds. The screen shows candles and pictures of Stephen Biko.

    "San Jacinto"
    From Peter Gabriel 4 (Security). Starts off with piano and strings, then Gabriel and backing vocals. Piano gives way to horns and woodwinds. Monkey eyes on the screen.

    "Digging in the Dirt"
    From Us. Starts with metronome, then woodwinds, then Gabriel, then strings horns and backing vocals from Brun and Melanie. The absence of percussion is palpable.

    "Signal to Noise"
    From Up. Gabriel and strings start it up. Then Brun and Melanie; Brun gets some screen time with 3D effects. Then a drum, a few horns, and lots more strings. There’s also some post-performance 3D graphics added. Spectacular finish from the orchestra.

    "Downside Up"
    From OVO. Starts off with bassoon and strings. Then Melanie solo, who then joined by Gabriel and Brun. The video goes upside down briefly. Then Gabriel introduces the bass and drum players, which seems ridiculous. I’ve been enjoying the music on its own merits without worrying too much about whether or not it sounds like the original, because usually it doesn’t. But when Chris Laurence starts plucking his double bass, I just have to chuckle: Wait, this guy is supposed to replace Tony Levin? I think not.

    "Mercy Street"
    From So. Starts with xylophone and some violin plucking, then Gabriel, then background vocals, then horns, flute solo,

    "The Rhythm of the Heat"
    From Peter Gabriel 4 (Security). Starts of with some pretty cool video, and Gabriel proves he can still belt it:

    "Blood of Eden"
    From Us. Starts with piano and Gabriel, then strings; Brun and Nazarkhan sing the female part in unison.

    "Red Rain"
    From So. Starts off with horns and strings, Gabriel, and a holographic projector – looks like the same thing that Wilson used in Home Invasion, or maybe it’s added during video production. A xylophone carries the beat.

    "Solsbury Hill"
    From Peter Gabriel 1 (Car). Piano, woodwinds and strings start it off, horns join in later. Besides singing, Gabriel fools around with one of the hanging cameras that are projecting images onto the screen. Brun and Melanie just dance, sort of, until singing a bit at the end.

    "In Your Eyes"
    From So. The front screen starts out lowered; it is then raised again to expose the stage. The strings start up and another vocalist (Nazarkhan) walks out; she’s mixed to the center channel too. The screen goes down and up again – it is semi-transparent.

    "Don’t Give Up"
    From So. The bass section and the woodwinds start it up. Gabriel sings the male part, while Brun takes the female part. This song is good at illustrating about what works well in this concert and what doesn’t. The orchestra is excellent at playing the notes for the slow first part of the song, but not so much with the rocking finale; it’s almost pitiful.

    "The Nest that Sailed the Sky"
    From OVO. All instrumental, with Gabriel at the piano (not sure if he actually plays or not). Some pretty awesome graphics that must have been added during video production.

    It’s a somewhat familiar setlist, but this is the symphonic version. I don’t think he could top Secret World Live and Growing Up Live (I haven't gotten to that one yet), so it’s just as well that Gabriel decided to do something completely different if he’s going to play mostly the same songs anyway. If you can get over the fact that it is not a rock concert and the original versions are usually better, it’s pretty good. However, to like it you probably have to both be somewhat familiar with the originals and also be ready for something different. There are lots of pretty amazing visual images, many of which must have been added during video production; I'd guess the 3D version is pretty cool. Thanks to the use of the rear speakers for background vocals, there’s a enough surround for a point.

    Music – 2
    Sound quality – 3
    Video presentation – 3
    Video quality – 3
    Surround – 2
  16. riskylogic

    riskylogic Forum Resident Thread Starter

    A Night in London


    Video by Mark Knopfler
    Released 1996
    Recorded BBC Building, London, 15 April 1996
    Length 94 minutes
    Label Universal

    A Night in London is a live concert video by Mark Knopfler released on VHS tape and Laserdisc in 1996 by PolyGram Music and on DVD in 2003 by Universal Music. The setlist includes songs from Knopfler's first solo album, Golden Heart, along with well-known Dire Straits numbers and film themes composed by the artist.

    Mark Knopfler – vocals, guitar
    Richard Bennett – guitar
    Guy Fletcher – keyboards, backing vocals, acoustic guitar
    Jim Cox – keyboards, backing vocals
    Glenn Worf – bass, backing vocals
    Chad Cromwell – drums
    Paul Franklin – pedal steel guitar
    Sonny Landreth – guitar
    Jools Holland – piano
    Dónal Lunny – bouzouki
    Liam O'Flynn – uilleann pipes
    Seán Keane – violin
    Máirtín O'Connor – accordion
    Sonia Slany – violin
    Jules Singleton – violin
    Jocelyn Pook – viola
    Dinah Beamish – cello

    Track Listing
    # Title Length
    1. "Darling Pretty" – 5:39
    2. "Walk of Life" – 5:21
    3. "Imelda" – 5:50
    4. "Father and Son" – 3:23
    5. "Golden Heart" – 4:53
    6. "Rüdiger" – 7:17
    7. "Cannibals" – 7:07
    8. "Je Suis Désolé" – 7:23
    9. "Last Exit to Brooklyn" – 2:16
    10. "Romeo and Juliet" – 7:49
    11. "Done with Bonaparte" – 5:08
    12. "A Night in Summer Long Ago" – 5:46
    13. "Brothers in Arms" – 8:30
    14. "Going Home" – 5:02
    15. "Are We in Trouble Now" – 6:03
    16. "Gravy Train" – 7:15

    Version Control
    This was first released on VHS in 1996, and then on DVD in 2003. It is still available new (Amazon), and used copies are cheap (Discogs). I somehow ended up with a PAL version, which means I had to watch it on my computer with headphones. Good thing it’s only stereo anyway.

    The Concert
    It’s VHS video with a 4:3 screen, and Dolby Digital stereo.

    It’s a very small venue / recording studio. There doesn’t seem to be a stage per se. Knopfler is standing in an open space (there is a slightly raised circular stage of sorts) along with the bass player Worf and another guitar player that I will assume is Bennett. All the other musicians are arranged in a semi-circle around them. There is a small audience of maybe 200 people, some of whom are behind the band. The picture on the cover seems to be completely fraudulent. Knopfler is not wearing a head band or a red shirt, nor does he have a red guitar, and he has short gray hair instead of long brown hair.

    "Darling Pretty”
    From Golden Heart. Starts off with a bouzouki, an accordion, and small flute – I don’t see any small woodwinds listed in the credits, and it sounds like we’re in for some Irish folk. Then Bennett starts off with an acoustic guitar, and bass, drums and Knopfler comes in with electric guitar and vocals – and it’s not Irish folk any more, just typical Knopfler folk-rock.

    "Walk of Life"
    From Dire Straits Brothers in Arms. OK, he has a red guitar now. Sounds pretty much like the original version, but maybe more piano. Franklin with long pedal steel solo at finish.

    From Golden Heart. This is a bit of a rocker – probably my favorite song from the album. The computer program I’m using shows the audio bit rate – 224 Kbps. It’s basically an mp3, and since I amusing headphones I can really tell.

    "Father and Son"
    From Cal soundtrack. Another Irish intro, and they keep playing this time – Knopfler joins in on guitar.

    "Golden Heart"
    From Golden Heart. Starts out as guitar duet with Bennett, with Knopfler vocals. Bass, drums, and the string section join in.

    From Golden Heart. Starts off with strings, then all three guitar players join, Worf’s bass sounds like a string bass, drums and piano.

    From Golden Heart. Sonny Landreth takes a place in the center with Knopfler, Bennett and Worf who really has a string bass now. Franklin has left – don’t need two slide guitar players. Landreth starts out with the lead, but eventually the drums kick in and Knopfler starts singing and playing. some southern boogie, i.e. sounds like Dire Straits.

    "Je Suis Désolé"
    From Golden Heart. Also sounds like a Dire Straits song, Making Movies era I’d say. Worf can sing backing vocals in French too. Lots of tasty guitar work from both Knopfler and Landreth.

    "Last Exit to Brooklyn"
    From Last Exit to Brooklyn soundtrack. Another string intro, with Worf on string bass, Bennett acoustic.

    "Romeo and Juliet"
    From Dire Straits Making Movies. Knopfler has his steel guitar, and we’re still in making movie mode, but this is a low budget version. Sounds like there’s some strings, but they’re not playing; methinks there’s some keyboard programming at work.

    "Done with Bonaparte"
    From Golden Heart. Wait, while we weren’t looking, the Irish guys have all been moved into the center. They lead things off and carry the song, and Knopfler sings and he still has his shiny guitar. Even though they’ve been banished to the back circle, Bennet and Worf are still playing too.

    "A Night in Summer Long Ago"
    From Golden Heart. We've got uileann pipes just like that guy in Nightwish plays; the Irish guys are still front and center, but Knopfler has traded in his shiny guitar for an electric one – but it’s not red.

    "Brothers in Arms"
    From Dire Straits Brothers in Arms. Well damn, the Irish guys get kicked to the back somewhere, and the string section takes their place. But the bass player in the back is still Worf, and the drummer imitates the Union Station guy. PG maybe could have learned a thing or two here; let’s give him a lesson:

    "Going Home"
    From Local Hero soundtrack. The string section takes another turn in the spotlight. This was the closer on Alchemy.

    "Are We in Trouble Now”
    From Golden Heart. The cameos are over, and Works and Bennett are back. No vocals; just strings, drums, bass, and guitar. Oh, Franklin is back with the pedal steel too.

    "Gravy Train"
    From Wag the Dog soundtrack. Before the song starts, Knopfler warns one of the keyboard players not to hurt himself (I don’t think he did). Landreth is back, and we’re rocking. A spectacular display of fretwork to finish things off.

    Possibly excepting the last track, this is a much lower key and folksy performance than Alchemy; it’s more in the neighborhood of Union Station than Dire Straits. But if you’re a fan of Knopfler’s solo albums (and the first one in particular) it’s pretty much essential.

    Music – 2
    Sound quality – 2
    Video presentation – 2
    Video quality – 1
    Surround – 1

    This concert has some common elements with all of the other three that I've posted this weekend. It's got uilleann pipes like Nigthwish, a tinge of bluegrass and first class picking and fretwork like Allison Krauss and Union Station, and it has a remake of an old rock classic with classical instrumentation like Peter Gabriel.
    mark winstanley likes this.
  17. Guy Smiley

    Guy Smiley America’s Favorite Game Show Host

    Sesame Street

    Regarding the follow up album of others covering Gabriel, it did happen. Just a lot later than PG planned.

    The original idea was to release the album, titled And I’ll Scratch Yours, at same time as Scratch My Back. Unfortunately, many of the artists returning the favor by covering PG were late with their tracks, and a few (Most notably Bowie, Neil Young, Ray Davies, and Radiohead) declined to cover a PG song at all.

    Anyhow, PG released a handful of singles over a period of time instead and then finally released the album in 2013 with a few other artists brought in to replace those who declined to participate:

    And I'll Scratch Yours - Wikipedia

    I’d kind of like to see this concert (Maybe I’ll look for some You Tube clips), but at the time I really didn’t care for what I heard from PG’s album. Everything sounded so dour and downbeat to me.

    Likewise, I had a chance to see a concert from this tour when PG made a stop in my town. But the idea of Peter Gabriel without percussion and guitars seemed so wrong.

    I credit him for always trying new things, but I couldn’t wrap my head around this. Further, it was a summer festival show where there are lots of people and lots of rowdy folks drinking. I kind of expected a disaster in the making, with this show and that crowd, so I passed. My loss, I’m sure. I saw him on the Growing Up tour though, which was wonderful, and I have Secret World Live, so that will suffice.
  18. riskylogic

    riskylogic Forum Resident Thread Starter

    Live! at the Rainbow


    Live Performance by Bob Marley and the Wailers
    Released 1978
    Recorded Summer, 1977
    Venue Rainbow Theatre, London
    Genre Reggae
    Length 90:00
    Label Universal Records, Island Records
    Director – Keef
    Producer – Scott Millaney

    Live! At the Rainbow is a concert performance filmed at the Rainbow Thetaer in London in the summer of 1977, after the release of the album Exodus.

    Bob Marley – Vocals, Rhythm Guitar
    Julian (Junior) Marvin – Lead Guitar
    Aston Barrett – Bass
    Tyrone Downie – Keyboards
    Carlton Barrett – Drums
    Alvin Patterson – Percussion
    Judy Mowatt, Marcia Griffiths, Rita Marley (aka the I Threes) – Backing Vocals

    Track Listing
    1. Trenchtown Rock
    2. Them Belly Full (But We Hungry)
    3. I Shot The Sheriff
    4. Rebel Music (3 O'clock Roadblock)
    5. Lively Up Yourself
    6. Crazy Baldhead
    7. War / No More Trouble
    8. The Heathen
    9. No Woman, No Cry
    10. Jamming
    11. Get Up, Stand Up
    12. Exodus
    Version Control
    This was originally released on VHS in 1978. A two disc DVD version was first released in Europe in 2004; the second disc has a 100 minute documentary on the life of Bob Marley. I have the U.S. version that was released in 2005, which I bought recently. Amazon. I am just going to cover the concert.

    The Concert
    I used to have a VHS copy of this and it was one of my favorites. So I’m glad to have it on DVD even if the video is no better; it’s still a 4:3 screen with VHS resolution. The audio is ostensibly better – it’s got a DTS 5.1 soundtrack. As for the surround, the rear speakers are pretty much silent. The center channel is used, but not discretely – so it still pretty much sounds like stereo.

    “Trenchtown Rock”
    From African Herbsman. Marley in up front in the middle. The formidable background trio are also in front, over on the right. Everyone else is in back. Mostly just see the vocalists on this song. Lots of double imaging - two shots of Marley at the same time, Marley and the trio at the same time, Marley and percussion at the same time.

    “Them Belly Full (But We Hungry)”
    From Natty Dread. The formidable trio lead it off. Marley roams the stage during keyboard and guitar solos; the trio dance in place.

    “I Shot The Sheriff”
    From Burnin’. Bass and drums lead it off. Marley does most of the singing, the formidable trio do most of the dancing, Marvin does all of the guitar playing.

    “Rebel Music (3 O'clock Roadblock)”
    From Natty Dread. Marley mostly runs the show; Marvin gets a solo.

    “Lively Up Yourself”
    From Burnin’. Marvin starts it up; he comes up to the front of the stage for a bit. The formidable trio can sing and dance at the same time. Marley sings for a while, then Marvin plays some more – he goes up front while Marley goes back to play in the rhythm section. The Marley put his guitar down to concentrate on dancing, runs a lap around the stage.

    All the songs are great, but this video is the best at showing the whole band:

    “Crazy Baldhead”
    From Rastaman Vibration. Marley has his guitar back, and he sings too. The vocalists get most of the camera attention, lots of double imaging again. Long run of back and forth between Marley and the formidable I Threes.

    “War / No More Trouble”
    From Rastaman Vibration and Catch a Fire. Marley and the trio are still the show – Marley goes over to sing with them for a bit.

    “The Heathen”
    From Exodus. Marley takes a tour with his guitar; over to play with the formidable trio, then the rhythm section, and then he dances in place. After another round of singing, Marvin takes over while the trio keep singing.

    “No Woman, No Cry”
    From Rastaman Vibration. Marvin leads off with solo, Downie and the keyboards get some focus. Marley takes over, but Marvin finishes.

    From Exodus. Mostly Marley and the trio, with lots of double imaging.

    “Get Up, Stand Up”
    From Burnin’. Marley with lots of double imaging. The crowd joins in – and they’re in front. There ain’t no surround.

    From Exodus. Barrett and the rest of the rhythm section lay it down. Lots of shots of the whole band. When they aren’t singing, Marley and the trio concentrate on dancing. The vocalists all make an exodus while the rest of the band carries on without them.

    Correct me if I’m wrong, but I’m thinking this is the finest reggae performance caught on video ever. The video quality isn’t great by modern standards, but for something recorded over 40 years ago, it’s quite good. If you’re not a Bob Marley or reggae fan already, watching this concert is a good way to become one. Yes there is a 5.1 mix, but I wouldn't call it surround.

    Music – 3
    Sound quality – 3
    Video presentation – 3
    Video quality – 1
    Surround – 1
    mark winstanley, SG47 and Guy Smiley like this.
  19. riskylogic

    riskylogic Forum Resident Thread Starter

    Like I said in the review, it works better for some songs than others. Fortunately, he had the good sense to not even attempt to cover songs like "Sledgehammer" and "Steam".
    Guy Smiley likes this.
  20. riskylogic

    riskylogic Forum Resident Thread Starter

    Time for another index update. Here is a synopsis of my current rating system that has been modified slightly since the opening post:

    1) Music Quality. This is loosely tied to my collection of about 4000 stereo titles. A 3 means top 10%, a 2 is in the next 40%, a 1 is bottom half.

    2) Visual performance. This is also completely subjective, and since I don’t have a frame a reference, I am basically just winging it.

    3) Sound Quality. I am giving everything that is DTS or better a 3. Dolby Digital gets a 2, even though you may not notice the difference unless you are listening on a pretty good system. A 1 means there are obvious problems with the audio, no matter what you are listening on.

    4) Video quality. 3 is bluray quality, 2 is DVD, 1 is VHS, 0 is Archival Footage. Longer explanation here. Note that it’s the quality of the actual video that matters, not the format itself; putting an old VHS recording on a bluray does not increase the score.

    5) Surround Quality. 3’s are rare on this thread, but I give them for either discrete mixing in the back or for center channel use plus ambience (more than just reverb) in the back. Use of the center channel or use of the rears for more than just reverb is good enough for a 2. Stereo is 1, Mono is 0.

    Ranges indicate either that the rating is version dependent, or that the content varies. The reviews are mine unless other attribution is given. The highlighted link for the reviews and ratings are different if the initial review is from Mark or someone else, or if I have changed the ratings for some reason.

    AC/DC – Let There Be Rock / Live Performance and Concert Documentary (@mark winstanley)
    Anathema – A Moment in Time / Live Performance / Rating: 11
    Ayreon - Electric Castle Live and Other Tales / Live Performance / Rating: 13

    Band, The – The Last Waltz / Live Performance and Concert Documentary / Rating: 12-14
    Beatles, The – A Hard Day’s Night / Movie / Rating: 11
    Beatles, The – Help! / Movie / Rating: 9-12
    Beatles, The – Yellow Submarine / Movie / Rating: 15
    Beck, Jeff – Performing This Week... Live At Ronnie Scott's / Live Performance / Rating: 14
    Blackfield – NYC: Live in New York City / Live Performance / Rating: 11
    Blue Öyster Cult – Live 1976 / Live Performance / Rating: 7

    Camel – Live At The Royal Albert Hall / Live Performance / Rating: 12
    Cave, Nick – Once More With Feeling / Concert Documentary (@mark winstanley)
    Church, The – Future Past Perfect / Live Performance / Rating: 11
    Clapton, Eric – The Cream of Eric Clapton / Video Collection / Rating: 10*

    Dead Can Dance – Yulunga and Other Stories / Video Collection / Rating: 9-12
    Dire Straits – Alchemy / Live Performance / Rating: 13*
    Dream Theater – Distance Over Time / Video Collection /Rating: 12*
    Dylan, Bob – No Direction Home / Concert Documentary (@mark winstanley)
    Eurythmics – Sweet Dreams - The Video Album / Video Collection / Rating: 8

    Gabriel, Peter – Secret World Live / Live Performance / Rating: 13
    Gabriel, Peter – Play / Video Collection / Rating: 11-13*
    Gabriel, Peter – New Blood - Live In London / Live Performance / Rating: 13

    Genesis – Pop Shop Live TV 1972 / Studio Performance / Rating: 8*
    Gentle Giant – The Power and the Suite / Video Collection / Rating: 13
    Gilmour, David – Live in Gdańsk / Live Performance / Rating: 11
    Gilmour, David – Live at Pompeii / Live Performance / Rating: 13
    Glass, Philip – Koyaanisqatsi / Movie / Rating: 13

    Hendrix, Jimi – Band of Gypsys: Live at The Fillmore East / Concert Documentary / Rating: 8*
    Iron Maiden – Flight 666 / Concert Documentary (@mark winstanley)

    King Crimson – Déjà Vrooom / Live Performance / Rating: 11

    King Crimson – Meltdown: Live in Mexico City / Live Performance / Rating: 14
    Knopfler, Mark – A Night in London / Studio Performance / Rating: 8
    Kraftwerk – 3D 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 / Video Collection / Rating: 13
    Krauss, Allison & Union Station – Live! / Live Performance / Rating: 11

    Mannheim Steamroller – Fresh Aire 8 / Video Collection / Rating: 9*
    Marillion – Fish Tales / Video Collection / Rating: 9-10*
    Marillion – Recital of the Script / Live Performance / Rating: 11*
    Marley, Bob & The Wailers – Live! at the Rainbow / Live Performance / Rating: 11
    Nightwish – Vehicle of Spirit / Live Performance / Rating: 12

    Pink Floyd – Devi/ation 1970 / Video Collection / Rating: 4
    Pink Floyd – The Wall / Movie / Rating: 10
    Porcupine Tree – Arriving Somewhere... / Live Performance / Rating: 13 - 14
    Presley, Elvis – That's The Way It Is (@mark winstanley)

    R.E.M – Road Movie / Live Performance / Rating: 9
    Roxy Music – The High Road / Live Performance / Rating: 12
    Rush – Exit ..... Stage Left / Live Peformance (@mark winstanley)

    Santana – Santana IV Live At The House Of Blues Las Vegas / Live Performance / Rating: 13
    Simple Minds – Acoustic In Concert / Live Performance / Rating: 1o
    Springsteen, Bruce - The River Tour / Live Performance (@mark winstanley)

    Talking Heads – Stop Making Sense / Live Performance / Rating: 11-13
    Tangerine Dream – The Video Dream Mixes / Video Collection: Rating: 7
    Tool – Vicarious / Video / Rating: 10
    Townsend, Devin – Ocean Machine – Live / Live Performance (@mark winstanley) / Rating: 10-12

    U2 – Under a Blood Red Sky / Live Performance (@mark winstanley) / Rating: 12
    U2 – 360° at the Rose Bowl / Live Performance (@mark winstanley)
    U2 – Live in Paris / Live Performance (@mark winstanley)
    Ultravox – Rage in Eden / Live Performance (@mark winstanley) / Rating: 13

    Various Artists – Woodstock / Live Performance and Concert Documentary / Rating: 12*
    Various Artists – Baraka / Movie / Rating: 12

    Wilson, Steven – Home Invasion / Live Performance / Rating: 15
    Wishbone Ash – Live Dates 3 / Live Performance / Rating: 13

    Yes – Yessongs / Live Performance / Rating: 6*
    Yes – Symphonic Live / Live Performance / Rating: 14

    Zappa, Frank – The Torture Never Stops / Live Performance / Rating: 8
    Zimmer, Hans – Live in Prague / Live Performance (@thetman) / Rating: 15

    * One point deducted from original rating as a result of video rating scale adjustment.

    Comments on any of the above are always welcome.
    mark winstanley likes this.
  21. mark winstanley

    mark winstanley Pick up a fast car, burn my name in the road

    Another one I have looked at often and never pulled the pin on.
    riskylogic likes this.
  22. mark winstanley

    mark winstanley Pick up a fast car, burn my name in the road

    Albert Lee ‎– Tearing It Up
    Label: AIX Records ‎– AIX 85054
    Format: Blu-ray, Stereo, Multichannel
    Country: US
    Released: 26 Jun 2012
    Genre: Rock
    Style: Country Rock, Rock & Roll


    Recorded December 18, 2006 at Zipper Auditorium in the Colburn School Of Performing Arts, Los Angeles, California.

    1 I’m Ready Written By – Joe Robichaux, Pearl King, Ruth Durand
    2 Rock Around With Ollie Vee Written By – Sonny Curtis
    3 Hangin' On Written By – Buddy Mize, Ira Allen
    4 Restless Written By – Carl Perkins
    5 Brand New Heartache Written By – Boudleaux & Felice Bryant
    6 'Till I Gain Control Again Written By – Rodney Crowell
    7 Sleepless Nights Written By – Boudleaux & Felice Bryant
    8 Luxury Liner Written By – Gram Parsons
    9 Evangelina Written By – Hoyt Axton, Kenneth Higginbotham
    10 Rock Of Your Love Written By – John Hiatt
    11 Country Boy Written By – Albert Lee, Ray Smith, Tony Colton
    12 Don’t Written By – Leiber & Stoller
    13 Dimming Of The Day Written By – Richard Thompson
    14 Tear It Up Written By – Dorsey Burnette, Johnny Burnette, Paul Burlison
    This is a quality product, and it is really going to depend on whether you like Albert Lee or not.
    Albert Lee is an exceptional guitarist who tends to lean towards Country, Country Rock, but he also likes a bit of old time rock and roll, as some of the songs up there clearly point to.
    Albert has played with everyone and is probably among the most liked and respected guitarists going around.
    He has recorded with
    1971 Jon Lord of Deep Purple's, Gemini Suite
    The Crickets in 1974 with Sony Curtis and Jerry Alison, via an introduction from Rick Grech.
    Replaced James Burton in Emmylou Harris's band in 1976.
    In 1978 he joined Eric Clapton and he appears on one of my favourite live albums, Eric Clapton At Budokan from 1980.
    In 1983 Albert was responsible for the Everly Brothers reunion concert and was the musical director. He played with the Everly Brothers regularly for about twenty years.

    Lee has had a remarkable career, and although he has never particularly had a ton of commercial success with his many solo albums, he is highly regarded as one of the great guitarists, and all round good guys of the music industry.
    I was lucky enough to see Albert live in the nineties with Steve Morse and Steve Vai, and what a gig that was.
    One of the interesting things about this disc is what a very good singer Albert is as well.

    It is still available through AIX records for about $35 Albert Lee – Tearing It Up – AIX Records
    Also it is on discogs for about $30 Albert Lee - Tearing It Up

    From an audio perspective the disc has 2, 5.1 mixes. A stage mix, and an audience mix both dolby true hd 96/24. We also have a stereo 96/24 pcm mix.

    Stage mix
    We have the drummer on the right side.
    The pianist is from the left side around to the front.
    The pedal steel guitarist is on the right side.
    Albert is left front .
    Bass is in front.

    Audience mix
    Drums across the front
    Piano left side around to front.
    Pedal steel just to the right
    Albert up front left
    Bass in front

    The audience mix is more up front, but the piano and the pedal steel move into the sides.

    The quality of the players is extremely high. The recording is a sort of live in the studio type recording.

    I prefer the stage mix, even though the drums are over on the right side. It has a nice wide live representation of what is happening on the stage.

    Albert was obviously influenced by the Everly's because his singing reminds me a lot of them.
    On Sleepless nights we get Albert on the piano and singing, and it is just as impressive.

    If you like Albert, country/rock, rock and roll, this is good stuff.

    Unfortunately there aren't any youtube videos, but if you go to the Aix link - Albert Lee – Tearing It Up – AIX Records - there is the Luxury Liner clip there.
    Last edited: May 25, 2020
    riskylogic likes this.
  23. weekendtoy

    weekendtoy Rejecting your reality and substituting my own.

    Northern MN
    I have this one on SACD and it's the finest sounding live album I have. I believe it was one of the first live albums recorded straight to DSD.
    mark winstanley and riskylogic like this.
  24. riskylogic

    riskylogic Forum Resident Thread Starter

    Live In Paris '79


    Live Performance by Supertramp
    Released 2012
    Recorded 29 November 1979
    Venue Pavillon de Paris, Paris, France
    Genre Progressive rock, pop rock, art rock
    Length 133 min
    Executive-producer – Dave Margereson, Geoff Kempin, Terry Shand
    Film Director – Peter Clifton

    Paris is a live album by the English rock band Supertramp, released in 1980. It was recorded on Supertramp's Breakfast in America tour in Paris, France, with most of the tracks taken from a 29 November 1979 show at the Pavillon de Paris, a venue which was once a slaughterhouse. The album was originally going to be called Roadworks. Paris reached number 8 on the Billboard 200 in late 1980 and went Gold immediately, while the live version of "Dreamer" hit the US Top 20. The Live In Paris '79' releases contain recordings performed on the 3rd night on 1st December 1979 of a four show series played between 29th November and 2nd December 1979.

    In 2010, Clifton was contacted to finish editing the initial three videos, aiming to later release a concert film out of the Paris concert. The footage was delivered to Roger Hodgson before a concert in Sydney. Once Supertramp manager Dave Margereson and Eagle Rock Entertainment offered to cover the post-production costs, Clifton worked on finishing the film, doing his initial work in Australia. By the time he moved to London to conclude the project, Clifton found out his original idea to feature heavily footage of Paris, adding a story akin to his work in The Song Remains the Same, was nixed by the band, who edited most of what he had done without consent to instead showcase more of the group. The sound was remixed by Peter Henderson and Supertramp's original sound engineer Russel Pope from the original multi-tracks.

    The concert film was released on 27 August 2012 under the title Live In Paris '79, with editions in both DVD and Blu-ray Disc. Hodgson would later express his disapproval with the finished project, saying the rest of the band made most decisions regarding the DVD without asking his input and avoiding giving correct songwriting credit to himself or Davies. The DVD was repackaged in 2015 with the full show on two CDs and correct songwriting credit on the rear packaging.

    Rick Davies – lead and backing vocals, acoustic and Wurlitzer pianos, Hammond Organ, Elka and Oberheim synthesizers, Hohner Clavinet, harmonica, tambourine;
    Roger Hodgson – lead and backing vocals, acoustic and electric guitars, pianos, synthesizers, bells;
    John Helliwell – saxophones, clarinet, synthesizers, percussion, backing vocals, spoken intros;
    Dougie Thomson – bass, backing vocals on "Fool's Overture", "Bloody Well Right" and "Two of Us";
    Bob Siebenberg (as Bob C. Benberg) – drums, percussion, backing vocals on "Two of Us".

    Track Listing
    1. French Touch (Intro)
    2. School
    3. Bloody Well Right
    4. The Logical Song
    5. Goodbye Stranger
    6. Breakfast In America
    7. Hide In Your Shell
    8. Asylum
    9. Even In The Quietest Moments
    10. Give A Little Bit
    11. Dreamer
    12. Rudy
    13. Take The Long Way Home
    14. Another Man's Woman
    15. Child Of Vision
    16. Fool's Overture
    17. Two Of Us
    18. Crime Of The Century
    19. From Now On (Credits)

    Version Control
    Both DVD and bluray versions of this are still available. Amazon. I have the UK bluray.

    The Concert
    Since this was transferred directly from film to a digital format in the 21st century, it’s better than VHS and it’s widescreen, but I can’t really say it’s up to the modern bluray standards, so let’s call it DVD quality. However, some segments are worse than that; the shots from the camera behind the audience are very grainy.

    Even though there is a 5.1 track, the center channel isn’t used at all, and there is just crowd noise and a tiny bit of reverb in the back. The stereo track is perhaps better.

    The stage is set up with drums in the back – Siebenberg is completely invisible behind the cymbals. Bass player Thomson is just in front of the drums at start, but he tends migrate to wherever the other front guys aren’t. There are multiple sets of keyboards over on the left, including an actual piano; Hodgson is always over there. Davies is sometimes over there too, but when he is playing guitar he is over on the right. Helliwell introduces all the songs and he is usually front and center – there is also a set of keyboards right-center that he uses. I’ll also point at this juncture that all five band members sing high-pitched at some point, and that seems to be the norm, the main exception is that Hodgson often sings in his normal voice. Hodgson is a high-range tenor, so he can sing those notes in his normal voice, but I think everyone else is singing falsetto.

    “School “
    From Crime of the Century. After an opening sequence featuring a Charlie Chaplin clown going into the concert, Davies leads things off with a harmonica seated at the small front keyboard (I’m going to call this Keyboard One) because he and Hodgson both use it. Helliwell selects the clarinet. Over on the right, Hodgson sings first with guitar in hand. Thomson starts out at the keyboard behind the piano (Keyboard Two) before retreating to his bass playing position. Davies moves back to the actual piano, and provides backing vocals. Hodgson sings in semi-normal voice at end

    “Bloody Well Right”
    From Crime of the Century. Davies starts out at Keyboard One. He sguints while he is playing. Hogdson and Davies are co-leads, Hodgson normal voice, Davies high pitched and guitar. Heliwell on his keyboards, then sax. Hodgson falsetto too at the end. Out of my three choices, I’m going to go with this one because I like Supertramp better when Hodgson is on guitar:

    “The Logical Song”
    From Breakfast in America. Hodgson is on Keyboard One singing falsetto. Heliwell with brilliant sax and backing vocals.

    “Goodbye Stranger”.
    From Breakfast in America. Davies is on Keyboard One, singing both normal and falsetto. Heliwell on Keyboard Two, also backing along with Davies over on the right with guitar. That leaves Thomson to be front and center. Heliwell has a tambourine, and Hodgson can be an awesome guitar player when he gets around to it.

    “Breakfast in America”
    From Breakfast in America. Heliwell tries to explain why breakfast in America is better to the Parisians in French. Hodgson is on the piano and lead vocals while Davies occupies the Keyboard Two position. Heliwell is front and center playing clarinet while Thomson wanders over to the right.

    “Hide In Your Shell”
    From Crime of the Century. Hodgson moves up to Keyboard One and lead vocals, Davies still on Two and backing vocals, while Heliwell is on his own keyboards, and backing vocals. At the end of the song three more background vocalists come on back right (Two male, one female), and they are all singing at a pretty high pitch.

    From Crime of the Century. Davies on piano and lead normal voice vocals. Hodgson on guitar and a short backing vocal, Heliwell keyboards and sax, and we get to see a bit of Siebenberg. A monkey clown with a banana comes out on stage during the finishing piano solo.

    “Even in The Quietest Moments”
    From Even in the Quietest Moments. Hodgson with acoustic guitar and lead vocals, Heliwell clarinet.

    "Give A Little Bit"
    From Even in the Quietest Moments. Hodgson with acoustic guitar and lead vocals, Heliwell a little guitar then sax, Davies tambourine and Keyboard Two.

    From Crime of the Century. Hodgson on Keyboard One and lead vocals, Davies Keyboard Two and backvocals, Heliwell backing vocals - while lounging on the piano at one point.

    From Crime of the Century. Davies on piano with lead vocals. Heliwell on keyboards and clarinet, Hodgson guitar. When the song starts cooking, the concert video is replaced by B&W time lapse train photography (like the old Cure “Jumping Someone Else’s Train” video). I don’t know if they did that originally, or whether the DVD video editors were to make up for bad film. Anyway, when the song slows down, the concert video comes back.

    “Take The Long Way Home”
    From Breakfast in America. Davies on piano and lead vocals; Hodgson harmonica at Keyboard Two position, then keyboards and backing vocals; Heliwell keyboards, backing vocals, and clarinet.

    "Another Man's Woman"
    From Crisis? What Crisis? Davies on piano with lead vocals. Davies over on right with guitar and backing vocals. Heliwell sax and backing vocals. Awesome piano and guitar duet from Davies and Hodgson, but can’t a find a video.

    “Child Of Vision”
    From Breakfast in America. Davies on Keyboard One and lead vocals, Hodgson piano and backing vocals, Heliwell keyboards and sax.

    “Fool's Overture”
    From Even in the Quietest Moments. Hodgson on piano and lead vocals. We get some B&W video spliced in again with a Churchill sample, and after that’s over, there’s another set of keyboards over on the right (that makes five if you’re counting) that Hodgson is playing with bass and drums. There are some clowns milling about. Heliwell comes in with sax, Davies is on piano. An interlude with more spliced in video, and the stage is filled with clowns when we get back to the concert – including the Charlie Chaplin and monkey clowns encountered earlier.

    “Two Of Us”
    From Crisis? What Crisis? Hodgson goes solo with guitar and vocals, except the other four guys chime in with a falsetto chorus. An abbreviated version of the song.

    “Crime Of The Century”
    From Crime of the Century. Davies on piano and lead vocals, Hodgson on guitar. The concert video gives way to a gorgeous aerial video of the Eiffel Tower at night, which is then replaced by semi-animated Crime of the Century cover art.

    “From Now On”
    From Even in the Quietest Moments. Plays while the credits roll.

    How many decent concert videos are there of prog heroes at the height of their career? Not very many. I feel very lucky to have this. Even though it’s the end of the Breakfast of America tour, they play seven out of eight songs from Crime of the Century, which is their best album. I would have liked more from Crisis though. I am sooo glad the band squashed the idea to “include a story” with the concert.

    Music – 3
    Sound quality – 3
    Video presentation – 3
    Video quality – 2
    Surround – 1
    jamesc, Hymie the Robot and Jagger69 like this.
  25. riskylogic

    riskylogic Forum Resident Thread Starter

    Magical Mystery Tour


    Movie by The Beatles
    Genre Surreal comedy
    Written by The Beatles
    Directed by The Beatles
    Starring The Beatles
    Narrated by John Lennon
    Composer(s) The Beatles
    Country of origin United Kingdom
    Original language(s) English
    Producer(s) Dennis O'Dell
    Cinematography Richard Starkey M.B.E.
    Editor(s) Roy Benson
    Running time 52 minutes

    Magical Mystery Tour is an English made-for-television musical film directed by and starring the Beatles. It is the third film that starred the band and depicts a group of people on a coach tour who experience strange happenings caused by magicians. The premise was inspired by Ken Kesey's Further adventures with the Merry Pranksters and the then-popular coach trips from Liverpool to see the Blackpool Lights. Paul McCartney is credited with conceptualising and leading the project.

    Much of Magical Mystery Tour was shot in and around RAF West Malling, a decommissioned military airfield in Kent, and the script was largely improvised. Shooting proceeded on the basis of a mostly handwritten collection of ideas, sketches and situations. The film is interspersed with musical interludes, which include the Beatles performing "I Am the Walrus" wearing animal masks and the Bonzo Dog Doo-Dah Band performing Vivian Stanshall and Neil Innes' "Death Cab For Cutie"

    The script of Magical Mystery Tour was largely improvised. The Beatles gathered together a group of people for the cast and camera crew, and told them to "be on the coach on Monday morning". Ringo Starr recalled: "Paul had a great piece of paper – just a blank piece of white paper with a circle on it. The plan was: 'We start here, and we’ve got to do something here …' We filled it in as we went along."

    The film originally aired on BBC1, in black-and-white, on Boxing Day, 26 December 1967.[3] A colour transmission followed on BBC2 on 5 January 1968.[4] It was poorly received by critics and audiences,[5] although its accompanying soundtrack was a commercial and critical success. The film received an American theatrical release in 1974 by New Line Cinema, and in select theatres worldwide in 2012 by Apple Films.

    In the order of appearance on the soundtrack:

    1. Magical Mystery Tour
    "Magical Mystery Tour" was written as the main theme song shortly after McCartney conceived the idea for the film. In Hunter Davies' contemporary account of the 25 April session, McCartney arrived with the chord structure but only the opening refrain ("Roll up / Roll up for the mystery tour"), necessitating a brainstorming discussion the following day to complete the lyrics. Like "Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band", the song serves to welcome the audience to the event and uses a trumpet fanfare.

    2. Your Mother Should Know
    "Your Mother Should Know is a song in the music hall style similar to McCartney's "When I'm Sixty-Four" from Sgt. Pepper. Its lyrical premise centres on the history of hit songs across generations. He originally offered it for the Our World broadcast, but the Beatles favoured Lennon's "All You Need Is Love" for its social significance. McCartney later said he wrote the song as a production number for Magical Mystery Tour, where it provides the film's closing, Busby Berkeley–style dance sequence. In author Doyle Greene's view, the lyrics advocate generational understanding in the manner of "She's Leaving Home" but, unlike in the latter song, to the point of "maternal authority and youth compliance", and contrast sharply with the confrontational message of the EP's next track.

    3. I Am the Walrus
    "I Am the Walrus" was Lennon's main contribution to the film, written partly during his acid trips, and lyrically inspired by Lewis Carroll's poem "The Walrus and the Carpenter" from Through the Looking Glass. The impetus came from a fan letter Lennon received from a student at his former high school, Quarry Bank, in which he learned that an English literature teacher there was affording the Beatles' lyrics scholarly interpretation. Bemused by this, Lennon set out to write a lyric that would confound analysis from scholars and music journalists. In addition to drawing on Carroll's imagery and Shakespeare's King Lear, he reworked a nursery rhyme from his school days, and referenced Edgar Allan Poe and (in the vocalised "googoogajoob"s) James Joyce. Author Jonathan Gould describes "I Am the Walrus" as "the most overtly 'literary' song the Beatles would ever record", while MacDonald deems it "[Lennon's] ultimate anti-institutional rant – a damn-you-England tirade that blasts education, art, culture, law, order, class, religion, and even sense itself".

    4. The Fool on the Hill
    McCartney wrote the melody for "The Fool on the Hill" during the Sgt. Pepper sessions but the lyrics remained incomplete until September. The song is about a solitary figure who is not understood by others,but is actually wise. In Everett's interpretation, the fool's innocence leaves him adrift from and unwilling to engage with a judgmental society. McCartney said the idea was inspired by the Dutch design collective the Fool, who derived their name from the tarot card of the same name, and possibly by the Maharishi. A piano ballad, its musical arrangement includes flutes and bass harmonicas, and a recorder solo played by McCartney.

    5. Flying
    "Flying" is an instrumental and the first Beatles track to be credited to all four members of the band. It was titled "Aerial Tour Instrumental" until late in the sessions and appears in the film over footage of clouds and outtakes from Stanley Kubrick's Dr. Strangelove. The track is a 12-bar blues and set to what music historian Richie Unterberger terms a "rock–soul rhythm". It consists of three rounds of the 12-bar pattern, led first by guitars, then Mellotron and organ, and finally a chanted vocal chorus.

    6. Blue Jay Way
    "Blue Jay Way" was named after a street in the Hollywood Hills of Los Angeles where Harrison stayed in August 1967. The lyrics document his wait for music publicist Derek Taylor to find his way to Blue Jay Way through the fog-ridden hills, while Harrison struggled to stay awake after the flight from London to Los Angeles. MacDonald describes the song as Harrison's "farewell to psychedelia", since his subsequent visit to Haight-Ashbury led to him seeking an alternative to hallucinogenic drugs and opened the way to the Beatles' embrace of Transcendental Meditation.

    Version Control
    There many different versions of this movie. I upgraded DVD with Dolby Digital stereo to a bluray currently for sale because it has a new 5.1 soundtrack.

    The Movie
    It’s 4:3 video, but I’d still call it DVD quality. Not that it matters; it’s a terrible movie. But let’s see if there are any rippable surround tracks in there. It’s DTS-MA HD, so the sound quality has the potential to be very good.

    "Magical Mystery Tour"
    On Chapter 1, the song runs during the opening credits, which is fine, but unfortunately the movie starts up before the song is over which means we have some dialog in the middle of it. Surroundwise, we’ve got lead vocals in the center channel and background vocals in surround – so only background vocals in the back. Editing needed at end.

    "The Fool on the Hill"
    The song's sequence on Chapter 2 in Magical Mystery Tour involved a dedicated film shoot, featuring McCartney on a hillside overlooking Nice, in the South of France, which added considerably to the film's production costs. Piano on left, flute on right both mixed partially to the back, lead vocals in center channel. Needed to edit a few seconds out at the beginning, and about two minutes at the end.

    On Chapter 5, with video of mountains that I’m pretty sure are nowhere near the English countryside. Guitar bass and drums all on left, second guitar and mellotron on right. Vocals in surround. Mellotron in surround at end. Needed editing at both the beginning and end

    "I Am the Walrus"
    On chapter 8 the Beatles put on a good show; definitely the best video:

    Lead vocals in center, piano left, strings on right. The last ha-ha-ha is the rear speakers – first discrete mix in the back so far. Needed editing at the end.

    "Blue Jay Way"
    On chapter 10 George is meditating in front of a keyboard facsimile, with lots of multiple imaging. Organ and drums left, lead vocals center, cello on right. Needed editing at the end.

    "Your Mother Should Know"
    On chapter 13 the Beatles are dancing at the ball, and Paul is singing. Piano left, lead vocal center, organ, drums and bass right. Background vocals in surround. Extraneous second and a half at the beginning, otherwise clean.

    Let’s not beat around the bush. This is the worst Beatles movie by far. At least it doesn’t last very long. But I still splurged for the bluray for one reason only – it’s got a new surround mix. As it turns out, it’s more like the first two movies than Yellow Submarine – there only one instance of discrete mixing to the back. The audio quality is excellent, and the 5.1 mix does use the center channel for lead vocals, and other instruments and background vocals are often mixed partially to the back. I still ended up with a decent surround mix of the UK soundtrack EP. The first track is the only one marred by movie dialog.

    Music -2
    Sound quality – 3
    Video presentation – 1
    Video quality – 2, but who cares
    Surround – 2
    Guy Smiley, Jagger69, jamesc and 2 others like this.

Share This Page