Perceived band hierarchy on SHF?

Discussion in 'Music Corner' started by Crimson jon, Mar 16, 2019.

  1. Crimson jon

    Crimson jon Forum Resident Thread Starter

    Location:
    Houston
    What is the hierarchy on this site based on all of the threads over the years as far as you can tell?

    I see it something like this in terms of popularity...

    Beatles..no surprise
    Stones...no surprise
    Zeppelin...no surprise
    Floyd ...of course they are amazing
    Queen...very surprising to me

    Then we get to bands like:
    Beach boys...other than pet sounds surprising

    The kinks...very surprised they are so popular here

    The byrds...also shocked to see the love they get

    Bands like Radiohead get mentioned a fair amount which is great since I love them.

    What other bands' popularity on this forum surprise you? I know I've missed some.
     
  2. Dan Steely

    Dan Steely Never Gonna Do It Without The Fez On

  3. supermolland

    supermolland Forum Resident

    Location:
    boston
    I'd rank them in the order -

    Souther
    Furay
    Hillman
     
    Davmoco, Mark B., funknik and 13 others like this.
  4. qwerty

    qwerty A resident of the SH_Forums.

    Other bands that come to mind that have a large following here:

    King Crimson
    The Who

    Genesis, McCartney, Steely Dan, Dylan, Fleetwood Mac, Springsteen, Prince, etc. have strong representation.

    It's the "classic rock" period. No surprise to see this clustering.
     
  5. Vaughan

    Vaughan Forum Resident

    Well, the list given by the OP isn't surprising at all. I mean, it's all classic rock. Coming from the UK, Queen being there isn't a surprise - they were hugely popular.

    Still, setting aside the classic bands I just don't like, and even considering those I do, I find the must fun in reading/posting about the truly lesser bands.

    And someone needs to mention Yes.

    :D
     
    Mr. H, CrazyCatz, SirMarc and 3 others like this.
  6. Crimson jon

    Crimson jon Forum Resident Thread Starter

    Location:
    Houston
    Yes good call...being a crimson freak I have seen more love on this site than I have seen on some others. I was used to get people bashing me for loving what they consider a pretentious self indulgent group.
     
    Maranatha5585 and qwerty like this.
  7. old school

    old school Senior Member

    King Crimson
    Jethro Tull
    Pink Floyd
    Bob Dylan
    Love
    Allman Brothers
    Emerson Lake & Palmer
    Yes
    Genesis
    Gentle Giant
    The Who
    Deep Purple
    Led Zeppelin
    UFO
    Mountain
    Robin Trower
    Cream
    Black Sabbath
    Rainbow
    Humble Pie
    Jimi Hendrix Experience
    Traffic
    Jeff Beck Group
    Savoy Brown
    Groundhogs

    Just for starters so many more great ones.
     
    Last edited: Mar 16, 2019
  8. Ron Stone

    Ron Stone Offending Member

    Location:
    Deep Maryland
    I was surprised to discover the difference in stature enjoyed by Queen in the rest of the world. In the USA, they were "just" another successful '70s band that squeezed out some hits in the '80s after a stylistic makeover, not terribly different than Heart, Genesis and Aerosmith. You know, on that second tier but nowhere as big as the Beatles, Stones or Zeppelin. But they are considered among the titans in the rest of the world.
     
  9. boboquisp

    boboquisp For real...

    Location:
    NE Ohio
    Don't forget The Monkees and Steely Dan
     
  10. Frittenköter

    Frittenköter Forum Resident

    Location:
    Germany
    The Queen sound is very different from that of Heart, Genesis or Aerosmith. No other band sounds like them.
     
    dumangl, Fullbug and mark winstanley like this.
  11. Ron Stone

    Ron Stone Offending Member

    Location:
    Deep Maryland
    I meant similar -- or "not terribly different" -- in career arc, critical stature and historical importance . . .

    In the USA, Queen is not one of the great bands like the Beatles, Stones or Zeppelin, nor are they critically acclaimed like David Bowie.

    Their first US revival in WAYNE'S WORLD was as hopelessly silly kitsch: note the other song featured in that film was "YMCA" by the Village People. However, their second revival due to BOHEMIAN RHAPSODY may change public perception to match that of the rest of the world.
     
    Last edited: Mar 16, 2019
  12. Frittenköter

    Frittenköter Forum Resident

    Location:
    Germany
    ok
     
  13. All Down The Line

    All Down The Line Forum Resident

    Location:
    Australia
    Yes I was surprised about the Monkees popularity here.
     
  14. Black Magic Woman

    Black Magic Woman Sorry for my english

    Location:
    Chile
    Jimi Hendrix. I didn’t know he was so big with american baby boomers.
     
    Day_Tripper2019 likes this.
  15. JozefK

    JozefK Forum Resident

    Location:
    Dixie
    Rush. I had successfully blocked Geddy Lee's unbearable shrieking out of my mind until the last few years, when I realized they were still quite popular online.

    Lack of popularity:

    1. Steely Dan. They had similar fans to Rush, who regarded them as somehow greater than mere rock. But while Rush kept their fan base, SD could not.

    2. Doo Wop. It's hardly ever discussed on here. A surprise, as it was once the most collected rock genre. i guess its fan base died off w/o transferring interest to a new generation, the way garage punk, rockabilly, and even honky tonk did.
     
  16. neilpatto

    neilpatto Forum Resident

    Location:
    Leeds, UK
    The Doors and Creedence Clearwater Revival are particularly big on this forum, no doubt linked to our host's significant work on their respective catalogues.
     
    Stone Turntable and Welshman like this.
  17. Terrapin Station

    Terrapin Station Forum Resident

    Location:
    NYC Man
    Re the first couple posts in the thread, the Kinks, Byrds, Dead, etc. shouldn't be surprising given that so many older folks post here--people who were at least in their teens, if not older, at the time when those bands were first making their mark. There are a lot of posters here who are centered on 60s music, and lots of posters from both the US and UK. So any artist that was hip/popular in either area during the 60s shouldn't be surprising in terms of the praise they get on the board.

    What I think is more surprising in that regard is when there's an artist who was hip/popular in the 60s who seems to get knocked a lot here. For example, Janis Joplin.
     
    Crimson jon, Aurora and 905 like this.
  18. DPK

    DPK Forum Resident

    Location:
    Lexington, SC
    Abba
     
    jamiesjamies and john lennonist like this.
  19. spaulding

    spaulding Hoi Polloi

    Location:
    The Windy City
    Monkees
    Monkees
    Monkees
     
  20. mark winstanley

    mark winstanley Pick up a fast car, burn my name in the road

    I think there is a fairly broad coverage of bands and music, which is great.
    The Beatles seem to be the most posted band, infiltrating threads they really don't have much to do with lol
     
    SirMarc, rmath84, Crimson jon and 3 others like this.
  21. Graham Morrissey

    Graham Morrissey Forum Resident

    As a newcomer to the board, the Queen love is constantly surprising. People here are prepared to say they like bands, even if they clash with the laws of musical snobbery. I love this! I wouldn't put Queen anywhere near the top 50 of best bands ever*, but I still smile at the memory of Live Aid or the Radio Gaga video and, although I shed more than half my vinyl collection at one stage, I still treasure Queen's Greatest Hits.

    The other surprise seems to be a dismissal of the post-punk years. Haven't you lot heard of the Smiths?
     
    Davmoco and mbrownp1 like this.
  22. HfxBob

    HfxBob Forum Resident

    Who would he be MORE popular with?
     
  23. JozefK

    JozefK Forum Resident

    Location:
    Dixie
    Queen is one of those bands that was very popular, then they waned and I forgot about them. Then I turned around for a moment and when I turned back, it was Wayne's Rhapsody and bigger than the Beatles and GOAT frontman.

    A similar case is Journey, who I'd forgotten completely when "DSB" suddenly came back from the dead and they had the GOAT frontman too. All these acts always seem to have a shrieking GOAT frontman.
     
  24. spacecoyote

    spacecoyote Astral Resident

    Location:
    Florence, NJ
    “The Elton John Band”, with Dee Murray, Nigel Olsson, and then Davey Johnstone, and then Ray Cooper.
     
  25. Sear

    Sear Forum Resident

    Location:
    Tarragona (Spain)
    Steely dan

    I never cared for them, by the way
     

Share This Page