Dismiss Notice
We are making some updates and reconfigurations to our server. Apologies for any downtime or slow forum loading now or within the next week or so. Thanks!

Were tracks from Gilmour’s eponymous album ever considered for a Pink Floyd release ?

Discussion in 'Music Corner' started by Absjc, May 4, 2021.

  1. Absjc

    Absjc Well-Known Member Thread Starter

    Location:
    Kent
    I’ve always wondered whether Gilmour ever presented tracks from his first solo album to the other members of Floyd as possible material ? Tracks like ‘There is No Way Out Of Here’ & ‘I Can’t Breathe Anymore’ always had a very Floydian style and would have been perfect for further development within the band.
    Anyone have any info on this ?
     
  2. Squealy

    Squealy Forum Hall Of Fame

    Location:
    Vancouver
    David didn't write "There's No Way Out of Here" so he wouldn't have been presenting it to Pink Floyd.
     
    Mr. Siegal, PhR and Devin S like this.
  3. Devin S

    Devin S Just slightly ahead of my time

    People either forget this fact or are unaware of it. Gilmour produced the album Too Many Crooks for the band Unicorn in '76. He heard the song and liked it so much that he ultimately recorded it himself. And improved it immensely as you can hear from listening to the original.
     
    Dingo, zinan, hi_watt and 4 others like this.
  4. vegafleet

    vegafleet Forum Resident

    I always listen to it as if it was a PF glorified demo from Gilmour. I know it isn't but it has such a Floydian vibe, it would have been a good PF album, especially after adding Rick's textures.
     
  5. rockclassics

    rockclassics Forum Resident

    Location:
    Arkansas, USA

    I always liked the Unicorn version. But David’s version is improved and I do like it better.
     
  6. AntLantic

    AntLantic Forum Resident

    Location:
    USA
    Some of it sounds like 74-77 PF. Signs of Life and Comfortably Numb are of course from that general era.
     
  7. Nimby

    Nimby Rotten hound of the burnie crew

    Location:
    Lewis, Scotland.
    In my "what if" list of music possibles, I wonder what if both this album and Rick Wright's "Wet Dream" solo album had instead been offered to the band, leading to a Pink Floyd album that wouldn't have been The Wall, and to Rick staying in the band.
     
  8. mcnpauls

    mcnpauls Forum Resident

    Location:
    Europe
    I have read interviews with Waters saying that Gilmour and Wright both kept the material to themselves that led to their respective solo albums, rather than offering it as the basis for songs to be worked up for Pink Floyd
     
    fallbreaks, Absjc and hi_watt like this.
  9. mark winstanley

    mark winstanley Certified dinosaur, who likes physical product

    Love Dave's first solo album ... I think it may be the most Floyd-like of all the solo albums...
     
  10. Dave

    Dave Esoteric Audio Research Specialist™

    Location:
    B.C.
    I agree, but I think there's still some possible Floydian aspects to About Face with tracks like Until We Sleep, Near The End, All Lovers Are Deranged and Let's Get Metaphysical.
     
    mcnpauls and Slim Zooms like this.
  11. erikdavid5000

    erikdavid5000 Forum Resident

    Fair complaint on Roger's part, but I wonder if at some point, neither Dave or Rick wanted their material to end up as songs about WW2 lol.
     
  12. Slim Zooms

    Slim Zooms Forum Resident

    Thanks for posting this. Great track.
    I like this version too but it’s right up David’s street. :righton:
     
  13. PhR

    PhR Well-Known Member

    Location:
    Finland
    I like the original as much as Dave's version, sometimes even more. It has that just right downbeat mood (not that Gilmour made it more cheery...). "Too Many Crooks" is a great album.
     
    hi_watt, pdenny and Rooster_Ties like this.
  14. PhR

    PhR Well-Known Member

    Location:
    Finland
    As much as I love Roy Harper "Short And Sweet" was not improved when he recorded his version for "Unknown Soldier" two years later. But at least Andy Roberts got a gig as a surrogate Floyd member for the later "The Wall" tour (replacing Snowy White) when Gilmour heard his playing on that track.
     
    mcnpauls and Slim Zooms like this.
  15. Sevoflurane

    Sevoflurane Forum Resident

    He didn't have to tweak "Raise My Rent" too much to get the guitar part for "What Do You Want From me?", did he?
     
    Sluggy and Larry Schmidt like this.
  16. Billy Infinity

    Billy Infinity Forum Resident

    Location:
    Philadelphia
    Yup. I had heard Pulse years before I'd heard David Gilmour, and my mind was blown the first time I heard "Raise My Rent".
     
    Mr.Sean, Sevoflurane and BeatleJWOL like this.
  17. tug_of_war

    tug_of_war Sassafras & Moonshine

    In my "what if" it even exists...

    • Mihalis
    • Against The Odds
    • Short And Sweet
    • Waves
    • Pink's Song
    • Mediterranean C
    • So Far Away
    • Mad Yanni's Dance
    • It's Deafinitely
    • I Can't Breathe Anymore
    Let's say the label wanted a new record that year but Roger was still busy writing The Wall so David and Rick got a chance to breathe a little...
     
    Big Pasi, Rufus McDufus and mcnpauls like this.
  18. reddyempower

    reddyempower Forum Resident

    Location:
    columbus, oh, usa
    Unaware myself, until just now. Thanks!
     
    Devin S likes this.
  19. MetalGuruMessiah

    MetalGuruMessiah Forum Resident

    Location:
    Texas
    I do love this song and it does sound like a song that might have been written and performed by Pink Floyd.

    Video featuring the heartbreaking whale that's been alone in a bathtub for over 50 years . Sorry humans haven't been better to you, Lolita.



    From Wiki: Lolita lives alone. Recall that orcas are highly social animals that usually live together for life in multigenerational family groups. Since Hugo's death in 1980, she's lived alone. ... After Hugo's death, the Miami Seaquarium required Lolita to continue performing without her companion.
     
    linklinc likes this.
  20. StingRay5

    StingRay5 Important Impresario

    Location:
    California
    Interesting. I hadn't known where that song came from. Gilmour's a much more expressive singer than the guy in Unicorn, but he didn't really change the arrangement all that much.
     
  21. mwheelerk

    mwheelerk I want to know God's thoughts the rest are details

    Location:
    Gilbert Arizona
    All I know is that it is a great album, a wonderful album, a favorite album of mine...

    [​IMG]

    David Gilmour ‎– David Gilmour
    Label:
    Columbia ‎– CK 35388
    Format:
    CD, Album, Reissue, Japan
    Country:
    US
    Released:
    1984
     
  22. M2225

    M2225 Caesar's Lab

    Location:
    Helsinki, Finland
    I was so disappointed "There's No Way Out of Here" was not written by himself
     
    Mr.Sean, pantofis and Slim Zooms like this.
  23. fallbreaks

    fallbreaks Forum Resident

    Well there wasn’t a lot of room for their material, though, was there? By 1973-74, they’d mostly developed the material that would appear on their next two albums Wish You Were Here and Animals, and then Roger presented demos for both The Wall and Pros and Cons of Hitchhiking at the same time and asked them to choose which project they wanted to do next after Animals. I’d guess Rick and David probably felt like their song ideas were surplus to requirements.
     
    M2225, Mr.Sean and erikdavid5000 like this.
  24. yesteryear

    yesteryear Wild Honey Laureate

    Location:
    Dallas, Texas
    Didn't one of those songs become the basis for the track of Dogs or another song on Animals?
     
  25. Larry Schmidt

    Larry Schmidt Well-Known Member

    I think Mihalis has a bit of the same strumming pattern as Dogs/Gotta Be Crazy does at one point and Deafinitely sounds a lot like Sheep/ Raving and Drooling. But I think those songs were written at least a few years before Gilmour's solo album came out. I think Short and Sweet kind of resembles Run Like Hell and the end of Sheep, just somewhat similar chords.
     

Share This Page

molar-endocrine