Beatles: Best, Worst, Overrated, and Underrated on every album

Very funny thread. Will do later

 

Please Please Me
Best: There's a Place
Worst: Ask Me Why
Overrated: Love Me Do
Underrated: Anna (Go To Him)

With the Beatles
Best: All My Loving
Worst: Little Child
Overrated: Boys
Underrated: Devil in her Heart

A Hard Days Night
Best: If I Fell
Worst: Tell Me Why
Overrated: Cant Buy Love
Underrated: I’ll Be Back

Beatles For Sale
Best: Baby's In Black
Worst: Kansas City
Overrated: Kansas City
Underrated: Babys In Black

Help
Best: Yesterday
Worst: Another Girl
Overrated: Help
Underrated: Act Natch

Rubber Soul
Best: Nowhere Man
Worst: What Goes On
Overrated: In My Life
Underrated: You Wont See Me

Revolver
Best: E. Rigby
Worst: LoveYou Too
Overrated: Yellow Sub
Underrated: Im Only Sleeping

Sgt Pepper
Best: A Day In The Life
Worst: Getting Better
Overrated: hdhdhdjdkd
Underrated: She Leave Home

Magical Mystery Tour
Best: Strawberry Fields Forever
Worst: All U Need is Love
Overrated: All U Need is Love
Underrated: Mother Know

The Beatles
Best: Savoy Truffle
Worst: Do It In Road
Overrated: Birthday
Underrated: Sexy Sadie

Abbey Road
Best: You Never Give Me Your Money
Worst: Maxwell’s Silver Hammer
Overrated: Come Together
Underrated: Octopuses Garden

Let It Be
Best: Long Wind Road
Worst: Dig It
Overrated: Dig Pony
Underrated: I Me Mine

Feels like homework

 

Only the ones I know enough

Rubber Soul:
Best - Drive My Car
Worst - Think For Yourself
Overrated - You Won't See Me
Underrated - Norwegian Wood

Abbey Road:
Best - I Want You
Worst - Oh Darling
Underrated - Maxwell's Silver Hammer
Overrated - side 2

 

I do, but it is so subjective that it ends up being worthless. And you can probably find several hundred other threads where all these albums are discussed over and over again.

 

Please Please Me
Best: Please Please Me
Worst: Chains
Overrated: Twist & Shout
Underrated: Anna (Go To Him)

With the Beatles
Best: It Won't Be Long
Worst: Devil In Her Heart
Overrated: You Really Got A Hold On Me
Underrated: Not A Second Time

A Hard Days Night
Best: Can't Buy Me Love
Worst: I'll Cry Instead
Overrated: Tell Me Why
Underrated: I’ll Be Back

Beatles For Sale
Best: No Reply
Worst: Kansas City/Hey Hey Hey
Overrated: Baby’s In Black
Underrated: What You're Doing

Help
Best: Help
Worst: Dizzy Miss Lizzie
Overrated: It's Only Love
Underrated: I Need You

Rubber Soul
Best: Norwegian Wood
Worst: What Goes On
Overrated: Girl
Underrated: If I Needed Someone

Revolver
Best: Eleanor Rigby
Worst: Love You To
Overrated: I'm Only Sleeping
Underrated: Good Day Sunshine

Sgt Pepper
Best: A Day In The Life
Worst: Getting Better
Overrated: With A Little Help From My Friends
Underrated: She's Leaving Home

Magical Mystery Tour
Best: Penny Lane
Worst: Your Mother Should Know
Overrated: Strawberry Fields Forever
Underrated: The Fool On the Hill

The Beatles
Best: While My Guitar Gently Weeps
Worst: Revolution #9
Overrated: Happiness Is A Warm Gun
Underrated: Revolution #1

Yellow Submarine
Best: It's All Too Much
Worst: All Together Now (nice song but minor)
Overrated: Yellow Submarine
Underrated: Only A Northern Song

Abbey Road
Best: Something
Worst: Maxwell’s Silver Hammer
Overrated: Come Together
Underrated: You Never Give Me Your Money

Let It Be
Best: Get Back
Worst: Dig It
Overrated: Across The Universe
Underrated: I Me Mine

Past Masters 1
Best: She Loves You
Worst: Bad Boy
Overrated: Long Tall Sally
Underrated: This Boy/Yes It Is

Past Masters 2
Best: Paperback Writer
Worst: You Know My Name
Overrated: Hey Jude
Underrated: Old Brown Shoe

 

Please Please Me
Best: Twist and Shout
Worst: Chains
Overrated: Love Me Do
Underrated: Misery

With the Beatles
Best: All I've Got to Do
Worst: Devil in Her Heart
Overrated: All My Loving
Underrated: Little Child

A Hard Day's Night
Best: And I Love Her
Worst: When I Get Home
Overrated: Can't Buy Me Love
Underrated: Things We Said Today

Beatles For Sale
Best: I'll Follow the Sun
Worst: Kansas City/Hey, Hey, Hey, Hey
Overrated: Rock and Roll Music
Underrated: Every Little Thing

Help
Best: Ticket to Ride
Worst: Dizzy Miss Lizzy
Overrated: Yesterday
Underrated: I've Just Seen a Face

Rubber Soul
Best: In My Life
Worst: What Goes On
Overrated: Drive My Car
Underrated: Wait

Revolver
Best: Here, There and Everywhere
Worst: Love You To
Overrated: Tomorrow Never Knows
Underrated: She Said She Said

Sgt Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band
Best: Lovely Rita
Worst: Within You Without You
Overrated: A Day in the Life
Underrated: Good Morning, Good Morning

Magical Mystery Tour
Best: Strawberry Fields Forever
Worst: Your Mother Should Know
Overrated: Magical Mystery Tour
Underrated: Baby, You're a Rich Man

The Beatles
Best: While My Guitar Gently Weeps
Worst: Revolution 1
Overrated: Birthday
Underrated: Long, Long, Long (there are a lot of underrated songs on this album)

Yellow Submarine
Best: Hey Bulldog
Worst: Only a Northern Song
Overrated: Yellow Submarine
Underrated: It's All Too Much

Abbey Road
Best: Golden Slumbers
Worst: Her Majesty
Overrated: Oh! Darling
Underrated: Sun King

Let It Be
Best: Let It Be
Worst: One After 909
Overrated: The Long and Winding Road
Underrated: Dig a Pony

Past Masters, Volume One
Best: I Feel Fine
Worst: Matchbox
Overrated: I Want to Hold Your Hand
Underrated: This Boy

Past Masters, Volume Two
Best: Hey Jude
Worst: You Know My Name (Look Up the Number)
Overrated: Rain
Underrated: The Inner Light

 

Please Please Me
Best: I Saw Her Standing There
Worst: Chains
Overrated: Do You Want To Know A Secret
Underrated: There's A Place

With the Beatles
Best: All My Loving
Worst: Hold Me Tight
Overrated: I Wanna Be Your Man
Underrated: It Won't Be Long

A Hard Days Night
Best: A Hard Day's Night
Worst: When I Get Home
Overrated: You Can't Do That
Underrated: I’ll Be Back

Beatles For Sale
Best: Eight Days A Week
Worst: Mr. Moonlight
Overrated: Kansas City
Underrated: What You're Doing

Help
Best: Yesterday
Worst: You Like Me Too Much
Overrated: Tell Me What You See
Underrated: I've Just Seen A Face

Rubber Soul
Best: In My Life
Worst: What Goes On
Overrated: Girl
Underrated: The Word

Revolver
Best: Tomorrow Never Knows
Worst: Love You To (but only because I have to pick something)
Overrated: She Said She Said
Underrated: For No One

Sgt Pepper
Best: A Day In The Life
Worst: Fixing A Hole (but only because I have to pick something)
Overrated: Getting Better
Underrated: Lovely Rita

Magical Mystery Tour
Best: Strawberry Fields Forever
Worst: Flying
Overrated: Your Mother Should Know
Underrated: Baby You’re A Rich Man

The Beatles
Best: Back In The USSR
Worst: Revolution #9
Overrated: Yer Blues
Underrated: Martha My Dear

Yellow Submarine
Best: Hey Bulldog
Worst: All Together Now
Overrated: It's All Too Much
Underrated: Only A Northern Song

Abbey Road
Best: Here Comes The Sun
Worst: Maxwell’s Silver Hammer
Overrated: Oh Darling
Underrated: Octopuses Garden

Let It Be
Best: Let It Be
Worst: Dig A Pony
Overrated: Get Back
Underrated: Two Of Us

Past Masters 1
Best: I Feel Fine
Worst: Sie Lieb Diecth
Overrated: From Me To You
Underrated: I'll Get You

Past Masters 2
Best: Hey Jude
Worst: You Know My Name
Overrated: Don't Let Me Down
Underrated: The Inner Light

 

Please Please Me
Best: Twist and Shout
Worst: Love Me Do
Overrated: Love Me Do
Underrated: There's a Place

With the Beatles
Best: Money (That's What I Want)
Worst: Till There Was You
Overrated: Don't Bother Me
Underrated: All I've Got to Do

A Hard Days Night
Best: If I Fell
Worst: When I Get Home
Overrated: Can't Buy Me Love
Underrated: I'll Be Back

Beatles For Sale
Best: I Don't Want to Spoil the Party
Worst: Mr. Moonlight
Overrated: Eight Days a Week
Underrated: I Don't Want to Spoil the Party

Help!
Best: Ticket to Ride
Worst: Dizzy Miss Lizzy
Overrated: Yesterday
Underrated: I've Just Seen a Face

Rubber Soul
Best: In My Life
Worst: What Goes On
Overrated: Michelle
Underrated: If I Needed Someone

Revolver
Best: Tomorrow Never Knows
Worst: Yellow Submarine
Overrated: Here, There and Everywhere
Underrated: Got to Get You into My Life

Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band
Best: A Day in the Life
Worst: When I'm Sixty-Four
Overrated: Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds
Underrated: Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band (Reprise)

Magical Mystery Tour
Best: Strawberry Fields Forever
Worst: Your Mother Should Know
Overrated: Penny Lane
Underrated: Baby, You're a Rich Man

The Beatles
Best: Dear Prudence
Worst: Honey Pie
Overrated: While My Guitar Gently Weeps
Underrated: Everybody's Got Something to Hide Except Me and My Monkey

Yellow Submarine
Best: It's All Too Much
Worst: Yellow Submarine
Overrated: All Together Now
Underrated: Side 2

Abbey Road
Best: Here Comes the Sun
Worst: Maxwell's Silver Hammer
Overrated: Something
Underrated: The End

Let It Be
Best: Across the Universe
Worst: Maggie Mae
Overrated: Get Back
Underrated: I've Got a Feeling

Past Masters 1
Best: Yes It Is
Worst: Komm, gib mir deine Hand & Sie liebt dich (tie)
Overrated: Love Me Do
Underrated: Bad Boy

Past Masters 2
Best: Paperback Writer
Worst: Get Back
Overrated: Get Back
Underrated: The Inner Light

 

That's not on Past Masters 2

 

Please Please Me
Best: Please Please Me
Worst: Love Me Do
Overrated: Love Me Do
Underrated: There's a Place

With the Beatles
Best: Not a Second Time
Worst: Till There Was You
Overrated: Money
Underrated: Not a Second Time

A Hard Day's Night
Best: And I Love Her
Worst: When I Get Home
Overrated: If I Fell
Underrated: Tell Me Why

Beatles For Sale
Best: Eight Days a Week
Worst: Everybody's Trying To Be My Baby
Overrated: Kansas City/Hey-Hey-Hey
Underrated: What You're Doing

Help
Best: Help!
Worst: Dizzy Miss Lizzy
Overrated: You've Got To Hide Your Love Away
Underrated: Another Girl

Rubber Soul
Best: Norwegian Wood
Worst: What Goes On
Overrated: If I Needed Someone
Underrated: Run For Your Life

Revolver
Best: I'm Only Sleeping
Worst: Doctor Robert
Overrated: Doctor Robert
Underrated: I Want To Tell You

Sgt Pepper
Best: A Day In the Life
Worst: With A Little Help From My Friends
Overrated: With a Little Help From My Friends
Underrated: Lovely Rita

Magical Mystery Tour
Best: Strawberry Fields Forever
Worst: Your Mother Should Know
Overrated: All You Need Is Love
Underrated: Blue Jay Way

The Beatles
Best: Helter Skelter
Worst: Revolution 1
Overrated: While My Guitar Gently Weeps
Underrated: Long, Long, Long

Yellow Submarine
Best: Hey Bulldog
Worst: Only a Northern Song
Overrated: Only a Northern Song
Underrated: Pepperland

Abbey Road
Best: Come Together
Worst: Her Majesty
Overrated: Here Comes the Sun
Underrated: Maxwell's Silver Hammer

Let It Be
Best: Dig a Pony
Worst: One After 909
Overrated: Let It Be
Underrated: Two Of Us

Past Masters, Volume One
Best: She Loves You
Worst: Matchbox
Overrated: Love Me Do
Underrated: Yes It Is

Past Masters, Volume Two
Best: Don't Let Me Down
Worst: Across the Universe
Overrated: Across the Universe
Underrated: You Know My Name

 

Anyone who puts A Day In the Life or Strawberry Fields as worst or underrated can fight me.

 

Please Please Me
Best: I Saw Her Standing There
Worst: Love Me Do
Overrated: Love Me Do
Underrated: Do You Want To Know A Secret?

With the Beatles
Best: Roll Over Beethoven
Worst: Till There Was You
Overrated: Hold Me Tight
Underrated: Don't Bother Me

A Hard Days Night
Best: A Hard Days Night
Worst: When I Get Home
Overrated: Can't Buy Me Love
Underrated: You Can't Do That

Beatles For Sale
Best: Eight Days a Week
Worst: Mr Moonlight
Overrated: I'll Follow The Sun
Underrated: Everybody's Trying to Be My Baby

Help!
Best: Help!
Worst: Act Naturally
Overrated: Yesterday
Underrated: I Need You

Rubber Soul
Best: Think For Yourself
Worst: What Goes On
Overrated: Michelle
Underrated: If I Needed Someone

Revolver
Best: Tomorrow Never Knows
Worst: Doctor Robert
Overrated: Here, There and Everywhere
Underrated: And Your Bird Can Sing

Sgt Pepper
Best: A Day In The Life
Worst: Getting Better
Overrated: Fixing a Hole
Underrated: Within You Without You

Magical Mystery Tour
Best: Strawberry Fields Forever
Worst: Flying
Overrated: The Fool on the Hill
Underrated: Blue Jay Way

The Beatles
Best: Savoy Truffle
Worst: Good Night
Overrated: Rocky Raccoon
Underrated: Long, Long, Long

Yellow Submarine
Best: Hey Bulldog
Worst: All Together Now
Overrated: All You Need Is Love
Underrated: It's All Too Much

Abbey Road
Best: Here Comes The Sun
Worst: Sun King
Overrated: You Never Give Me Your Money
Underrated: Because

Let It Be
Best: Let It Be
Worst: Dig It
Overrated: The Long and Winding Road
Underrated: Dig a Pony

Past Masters 1
Best: I Feel Fine
Worst: Love Me Do
Overrated: From Me To You
Underrated: I Call Your Name

Past Masters 2
Best: Revolution
Worst: You Know My Name and The Ballad of John and Yoko
Overrated: Hey Jude and We Can Work It Out
Underrated: Old Brown Shoe

 

Why not:

Please Please Me
Best: Anna
Worst: Chains
Overrated: Twist & Shout
Underrated: There's a Place

With the Beatles
Best: It won't be long
Worst: Little Child
Overrated: Roll Over Beethoven
Underrated: Not a Second Time

A Hard Days Night
Best: If I Fell
Worst: Tell Me Why
Overrated: Cant Buy Love
Underrated: I’ll Be Back

Beatles For Sale
Best: No Reply
Worst: Kansas City
Overrated: Eight Days a Week
Underrated: Babys In Black

Help
Best: The Night Before
Worst: it's only live
Overrated: Yesterday
Underrated: Tell me what you see

Rubber Soul
Best: In My Life
Worst: What Goes On
Overrated: Nowhere Man
Underrated: You Wont See Me

Revolver
Best: Here There Everywhere
Worst: Dr Robert
Overrated: Revolver in general
Underrated: Tomorrow Never Knows

Sgt Pepper
Best: Lucy
Worst: Benefit of Mr Kite
Overrated: A Day in the Life
Underrated: Within You....

Magical Mystery Tour
Best: Strawberry Fields Forever
Worst: All U Need is Love
Overrated: Hey Bulldog
Underrated: Your Mother Should Know

The Beatles
Best: While My Guitar...
Worst: Do It In Road
Overrated: Birthday
Underrated: Savoy Truffle

Abbey Road
Best: I Want You
Worst: Maxwell’s Silver Hammer
Overrated: Here Comes the Sun
Underrated: Polythene Pam

Let It Be
Best: Get Back
Worst: Two of Us
Overrated: Long & Winding....
Underrated: Across the Universe

 

Oh what the hell, I still have another four hours till quittin' time anyway:

Please Please Me
Best: I Saw Her Standing There
Worst: Boys
Overrated: Twist & Shout
Underrated: Misery

With the Beatles
Best: All My Loving
Worst: Devil In Her Heart
Overrated: It Won't Be Long
Underrated: Please Mister Postman

A Hard Days Night
Best: Can't Buy Me Love
Worst: When I Get Home
Overrated: If I Fell
Underrated: I’ll Be Back

Beatles For Sale
Best: No Reply
Worst: What You're Doing
Overrated: I'm A Loser
Underrated: Mr Moonlight

Help!
Best: You've Got To Hide Your Love Away
Worst: Tell Me What You See
Overrated: Help!
Underrated: I Need You

Rubber Soul
Best: Norwegian Wood
Worst: You Won't See Me
Overrated: In My Life
Underrated: The Word

Revolver
Best: Taxman
Worst: I Want To Tell You
Overrated: Here There And Everywhere
Underrated: Dr Robert

Sgt Pepper
Best: Fixing A Hole
Worst: Lovely Rita
Overrated: She's Leaving Home
Underrated: Within You Without You

Magical Mystery Tour
Best: I Am The Walrus
Worst: Blue Jay Way
Overrated: Baby You're A Rich Man
Underrated: The Fool On The Hill

The Beatles
Best: Dear Prudence
Worst: Revolution 9
Overrated: While My Guitar Gently Weeps
Underrated: Honey Pie

Yellow Submarine
Best: Hey Bulldog
Worst: All Together Now
Overrated: It's All Too Much
Underrated: Only A Northern Song

Abbey Road
Best: You Never Give Me Your Money
Worst: I Want You (She's So Heavy)
Overrated: Here Comes the Sun
Underrated: Oh! Darling

Let It Be
Best: I've Got A Feeling
Worst: The Long And Boring Song
Overrated: Get Back
Underrated: One After 909

Past Masters Vol 1
Best: I'm Down
Worst: Sie Liebe Dich/Komm Gib Mir Deine Hand (tie)
Overrated: She Loves You
Underrated: Yes It Is

Past Masters Vol. 2
Best: Hey Jude
Worst: Lady Madonna
Overrated: Revolution
Underrated: Old Brown Shoe

 

Underrated: "Wait"

Purely for the line "... and I've been good, as good as I can be..."

It's the one line that is absolutely about being a Beatle, on tour. It means, he's not been good at all!

 

All opinions.

It's always sounded like the love theme of a bad afternoon soap to me. My wife agrees with you.

We're all right in our own way.

 

That was great. Never seen it.

 

Looks like quite a slog, but also irresistible. I'll play!


Please Please Me
Best: Please Please Me
Worst: Baby It's You
Overrated: Love Me Do
Underrated: Anna (Go To Him)

With the Beatles
Best: Devil In Her Heart
Worst: I Wanna Be Your Man
Overrated: Roll Over Beethoven
Underrated: Not A Second Time

A Hard Days Night
Best: You Can't Do That
Worst: Any Time At All
Overrated: And I Love Her
Underrated: I’ll Cry Instead

Beatles For Sale
Best: I'll Follow the Sun
Worst: Mr. Moonlight
Overrated: Kansas City
Underrated: Baby's in Black

Help
Best: Help
Worst: Tell Me What You See
Overrated: Yesterday
Underrated: It's Only Love

Rubber Soul
Best: In My Life
Worst: What Goes On
Overrated: Michelle
Underrated: I'm Looking Through You

Revolver
Best: For No One
Worst: Love You To
Overrated: Got to Get You into My Life
Underrated: I Want to Tell You

Sgt Pepper
Best: A Day In The Life
Worst: Being For the Benefit of Mr Kite
Overrated: She’s Leaving Home
Underrated: Nothing here is underrated, quite the contrary!

Magical Mystery Tour
Best: Strawberry Fields Forever
Worst: Flying
Overrated: Penny Lane
Underrated: I Am the Walrus

The Beatles
Best: Sexy Sadie
Worst: Revolution 9
Overrated: Birthday
Underrated: Long Long Long

Yellow Submarine
Best: Hey Bulldog
Worst: It's All Too Much
Overrated: Yellow Submarine
Underrated: All Together Now

Abbey Road
Best: You Never Give Me Your Money
Worst: Her Majesty
Overrated: Come Together
Underrated: Octopus' Garden

Let It Be
Best: Dig a Pony
Worst: For You Blue
Overrated: I Me Mine
Underrated: I've Got A Feeling

Past Masters 1
Best: She Loves You
Worst: Love Me Do
Overrated: I Call Your Name
Underrated: I'm Down

Past Masters 2
Best: Don't Let Me Down
Worst: You Know My Name
Overrated: Hey Jude
Underrated: Lady Madonna

 

Neither of these songs are on Past Masters 2

 

Please Please Me
Best: Baby It's You
Worst: Love Me Do
Overrated: I Saw Her Standing There
Underrated: Boys

With the Beatles
Best: All I've Got To Do
Worst: I Wanna Be Your Man
Overrated: All My Loving
Underrated: Please Mr. Postman

A Hard Days Night
Best: Things We Said Today
Worst: When I Get Home
Overrated: And I Love Her
Underrated: Tell Me Why

Beatles For Sale
Best: I Don't Want To Spoil The Party
Worst: Honey Don't
Overrated: No Reply
Underrated: Eight Days A Week

Help
Best: Ticket To Ride
Worst: Tell Me What You See
Overrated: You've Got To Hide Your Love Away
Underrated: The Night Before

Rubber Soul
Best: Nowhere Man
Worst: The Word
Overrated: Norwegian Wood
Underrated: If I Needed Someone

Revolver
Best: And Your Bird Can Sing
Worst: Doctor Robert
Overrated: Eleanor Rigby
Underrated: I Want To Tell You

Sgt Pepper
Best: A Day In The Life
Worst: When I'm 64
Overrated: With A Little Help From My Friends
Underrated: Good Morning Good Morning

Magical Mystery Tour
Best: I Am The Walrus
Worst: Flying
Overrated: The Fool On The Hill
Underrated: Blue Jay Way

The Beatles
Best: Dear Prudence
Worst: Wild Honey Pie
Overrated: While My Guitar Gently Weeps
Underrated: Savoy Truffle

Yellow Submarine
Best: Hey Bulldog
Worst: All Together Now
Overrated: It's All Too Much
Underrated: Only A Northern Song

Abbey Road
Best: Something
Worst: Maxwell's Silver Hammer
Overrated: Come Together
Underrated: I Want You (She's So Heavy)

Let It Be
Best: I've Got A Feeling
Worst: The Long And Winding Road
Overrated: Across The Universe
Underrated: Get Back

Past Masters 1
Best: I Feel Fine
Worst: I'll Get You
Overrated: From Me To You
Underrated: Long Tall Sally

Past Masters 2
Best: We Can Work It Out
Worst: The Inner Light
Overrated: Rain
Underrated: Paperback Writer

 

1. Please Please Me
   Best: I Saw Her Standing There
   Worst: Love Me Do
   Overrated: Love Me Do
   Underrated: Anna (Go To Him)
   
   With the Beatles
   Best: All My Loving
   Worst: I Wanna Be Your Man
   Overrated: I Wanna Be Your Man
   Underrated: All I’ve Got To Do
   
   A Hard Days Night
   Best: I Should Have Known Better
   Worst: You Can’t Do That
   Overrated: And I Love Her
   Underrated: I’ll Be Back
   
   Beatles For Sale
   Best: I’ll Follow The Sun
   Worst: What You’re Doing
   Overrated: Eight Days A Week
   Underrated: Baby’s In Black
   
   Help
   Best: You’re Going To Lose That Girl
   Worst: You Like Me Too Much
   Overrated: Yesterday
   Underrated: Another Girl

Rubber Soul
Best: In My Life
Worst: What Goes On
Overrated: If I Needed Someone
Underrated: Wait

Revolver
Best: Here There And Everywhere
Worst: For No One
Overrated: Tomorrow Never Knows
Underrated: Yellow Submarine

Sgt Pepper
Best: A Day In The Life
Worst: She’s Leaving Home
Overrated: Within You Without You
Underrated: Lovely Rita

Magical Mystery Tour
Best: Strawberry Fields Forever
Worst: Your Mother Should Know
Overrated: Hello Goodbye
Underrated: Baby You’re A Rich Man

The Beatles
Best: Dear Prudence
Worst: Don’t Pass Me By
Overrated: Blackbird
Underrated: I’m So Tired

Yellow Submarine
Best: Hey Bulldog
Worst: All Together Now
Overrated: All Together Now
Underrated: Only A Northern Song

Abbey Road
Best: I Want You (She’s So Heavy)
Worst: Maxwell’s Silver Hammer
Overrated: Oh Darling
Underrated: The Sun King

Let It Be
Best: Across The Universe
Worst: One After 909
Overrated: For You Blue
Underrated: Dig It

Past Masters 1
Best: She Loves You
Worst: Matchbox
Overrated: Love Me Do
Underrated: From Me To You

Past Masters 2
Best: Across The Universe
Worst: You Know My Name
Overrated: Get Back
Underrated: Old Brown Shoe

 

Please Please Me
Best: Please Please Me
Worst: Love Me Do
Overrated: Twist & Shout
Underrated: There's A Place

With the Beatles
Best: It Won't Be Long
Worst: Hold Me Tight
Overrated: Roll Over Beethoven
Underrated: All I've Got To Do

A Hard Days Night
Best: I Should Have Known Better
Worst: When I Get Home
Overrated: If I Fell
Underrated: I’ll Cry Instead

Beatles For Sale
Best: No Reply
Worst: Everybodys Trying To Be My Baby
Overrated: Eight Days A Week
Underrated: Mr. Moonlight

Help
Best: Help
Worst: Tell Me What You See
Overrated: Yesterday
Underrated: You're Gonna Lose That Girl

Rubber Soul
Best: Norwegian Wood
Worst: Michelle
Overrated: Michelle
Underrated: If I Needed Someone

Revolver
Best: I Want To Tell You
Worst: Yellow Submarine
Overrated: Got To Get You Into My Life
Underrated: I Want To Tell You

Sgt Pepper
Best: Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds
Worst: Fixing A Hole
Overrated:With A Little Help From My Friends
Underrated: She’s Leaving Home

Magical Mystery Tour
Best: Strawberry Fields Forever
Worst: Your Mother Should Know
Overrated: Your Mother Should Know
Underrated: Baby You're A Rich Man

The Beatles
Best: Dear Prudence
Worst: Ob La Di Ob La Da
Overrated: Back In The USSR
Underrated: Long Long Long

Yellow Submarine
Best: It's All Too Much
Worst: All Together Now
Overrated: Hey Bulldog
Underrated: Only A Northern Song

Abbey Road
Best: Here Comes The Sun
Worst: Maxwell's Silver Hammer
Overrated: Maxwell's Silver Hammer
Underrated: I Want You (She's So Heavy)

Let It Be
Best: Dig A Pony
Worst: Long & Winding Road
Overrated: Get Back
Underrated: I've Got A Feeling

Past Masters 1
Best: This Boy
Worst: Either German song
Overrated: She's A Woman
Underrated: I Call Your Name

Past Masters 2
Best: Rain
Worst: Hey Jude
Overrated: Hey Jude
Underrated: Ballad of John & Yoko

 

Please Please Me
Best: Twist and Shout
Worst: Boys
Overrated: I Saw Her Standing There (great song, still overrated)
Underrated: Misery

With the Beatles
Best: It Won't Be Long
Worst: Little Child
Overrated: All My Loving
Underrated: Don't Bother Me

A Hard Day's Night
Best: If I Fell
Worst: I'm Happy Just to Dance With You
Overrated: And I Love Her or Can't Buy Me Love
Underrated: Any Time at All

Beatles for Sale
Best: Eight Days a Week
Worst: Honey, Don't
Overrated: Baby's in Black
Underrated: Words of Love

Help!
Best: You've Got to Hide Your Love Away
Worst: Act Naturally or Dizzy Miss Lizzy (their covers had become very lacklustre by this point)
Overrated: Yesterday
Underrated: It's Only Love

Rubber Soul
Best: Nowhere Man
Worst: Michelle (unpopular opinion, but I just don't like it very much)
Overrated: In My Life (Great song, but in the top 5 Beatles songs of all time? I don't think so.)
Underrated: You Won't See Me

Revolver
Best: She Said She Said
Worst: Yellow Submarine
Overrated: Tomorrow Never Knows
Underrated: I Want To Tell You

Sgt. Pepper
Best: Lucy in the Sky With Diamonds
Worst: When I'm Sixty-Four
Overrated: A Day in the Life (fantastic song, but it's greatness has been overblown by critics)
Underrated: GETTING BETTER!!!!!! (I really love this song)

Magical Mystery Tour
Best: Strawberry Fields Forever
Worst: Flying
Overrated: I am the Walrus
Underrated: Baby, You're a Rich Man

White Album
Best: Dear Prudence or Happiness is a Warm Gun
Worst: Don't Pass Me By (sorry, Ringo!)
Overrated: Blackbird
Underrated: Long Long Long

Yellow Submarine
Best: Hey Bulldog
Worst: All Together Now
Overrated: Hey Bulldog (overrated as "underrated")
Underrated: It's All Too Much

Abbey Road
Best: You Never Give Me Your Money
Worst: Her Majesty. If that's not a valid one (because it's so short), then Sun King.
Overrated: Come Together
Underrated: Polythene Pam

Let It Be
Best: Two of Us
Worst: One After 909
Overrated: can't decide between Across the Universe and Let it Be, though I genuinely love both
Underrated: I've Got a Feeling

Past Masters 1:
Best: I Feel Fine
Worst: Slow Down (that guitar solo is horrendous and John sounds like he put barely any effort into the double-tracking. IMO the worst commercially-released Beatles track)
Overrated: She Loves You
Underrated: I'll Get You or This Boy

Past Masters 2:
Best: Rain
Worst: Ballad of John and Yoko
Overrated: Hey Jude
Underrated: You Know Mah NAAAAAAAAAAIIIIIME (Look up de numbah!)

 

You really hate Paul McCartney