RATE AN ALBUM: Gaucho-Steely Dan

This is only a test.

 

Grant,

As I mentioned in the other thread maybe we should limit the actual pole to just the sound quality. The choices might include things like, harsh or smooth, resolution, and a final overall sound rating of * = poor to
***** = excellent.

Any other suggestions?

The actual review of musical merit requires more so therefore people can post below as always.

 

Good points MA. Now how can we keep the discussion on setting up the system over in the other thread (Member Disc Rating System) so people offering their opinions can refer to earlier suggestions?

I do hope that we get a lot of input on this .

 

Khorn, if you want, I can move the comments in here to the other thread, and close this thread. That should do the trick.

Let me know.

 

Sounds good I know Grant was well meaning and anxious to get it going but I think we want input from all the other "heavy duty members" here as to be fair it's their board also. Let's get this thing going properly after some discussion. I'm getting really enthused about this as I can see its value for all of us including Steve.

Yes, move the posts. Grant I hope you don't mind.
tnx.