Best Solo-Beatle Live Album?

Lots of rankings of their studio albums, but none of their live ones, I think (Until now!)
Rules:
1. No Pete Best.
2. Official stuff. If there are significantly different versions, say which.
3. Full albums, not Egypt Station bonus disk kinds of stuff.
4. No Multi-artists things, like Concert For Bangladesh, Here And There or Live Aid. 'Feat.' tracks are fine though.

 

George Harrison - Live in Japan

 

No contest. “Wings Over America.”

But I do thoroughly enjoy McCartney’s “Unplugged” album, start to finish.

 

Wings Over America by a mile.

 

Lennon - Live in New York City

 

None are great, probably Wings Over America

 

Agreed - they are not great by any means

 

Which do you think are better?

 

Non-solo-Beatle-wise

 

I would agree Wings Over America and Unplugged in the first and second spots [which is which depends on my mood..]

I think 3rd and 4th would go to Live In Japan and Back In The US/World.

Although... Amoeba Gig and Wings Over Europe may rise in my rankings after more plays...

Edit: And if Wings' Glasgow show ever gets official release [in full] that would definitely be another contender for #1!

 

Despite all the eminently reasonable limitations set by the OP, nothing I can think of (within those limits) can or could ever top...

The Concert for George

 

John - Live Peace in Toronto
Paul - Wings Over America or Unplugged
George - Live in Japan
Ringo - Vh1 Storytellers

 

My favorite solo Beatle is George, but the best live album is definitely Wings Over America.

 

This is my opinion too

 

Extra Rule:
5. If it's a live/studio album (With at least 1 LP side [Or equivalent length] of live stuff) like Sometime In NYC or Unfinished Music 2, it's the Live part on its own that counts. In the case of S(T?)INYC, the Zappa mix also counts, obviously. Just note it.

 

Lennon Sometime in NYC disc 2
Or Live Peace in Toronto

 

Totally disagree WINGS OVER AMERICA and WINGS OVER EUROPE are absolutely fantastic!
America is Wings clicking on all cylinders tight and hard rocking.
Europe is Wings loose, raw and rocking.
Both have excellent setlist with McCartney doing some of the best singing of his entire career! Now if he'll just officially release LAST FLIGHT, that would be a live album from every version of Wings!
I ABSOLUTELY LOVE THIS SONG from WINGS OVER EUROPE...

 

Wings over America

 

My favorite is Paul's "Good Evening New York City"

 

Wings Over America

 

As others said, none of them is great. And it actually depends on what kind of music one prefers. For me, the best are Lennon live albums, especially Live in NY, for the rawer feel. W over America or Live in Japan actually bore me in the end. But I get that other people like them infintely more than what sounds to them like underrehearsed bands playing unpleasant music.

However, against the rules, my real favourite is the Bangladesh concert (but it may have more to do with Leon Russell than George Harrison).

 

Yes. I always thought Youngblood/Jumping Jack Flash medley kind of stole the show [at least on the album]....

 

Wings Over America

 

Macca- Ameoba reissue in addition to WOA.

 

Wings Over America (especially side 3)