Perhaps it is this tendency of getting everything in HD that destroys the essence/soul/core of the music. That is my understanding of what you describe as too analytical. So over remastering/remixing can end up in disappointment from a listener perspective. I listen to a lot of classical music and can tell you that I seldom complain about the recording quality. Yes, there was some engineering limitations in the last century but they do not prevent the listener from enjoying stellar performance.